Discover some of New York’s hidden gems where the pizza rivals the best slices from the big city. These small-town spots boast unique flavors and a local charm that’s hard to match. Let’s explore these nine must-visit pizzerias.
Capri Pizzeria – Lake George, NY
Capri Pizzeria offers more than just a meal; it’s a lakeside experience. Situated near the scenic Lake George, this pizzeria pairs great views with even better pizza. The menu boasts an array of specialty pizzas that cater to every palate.
The outdoor seating provides a relaxing atmosphere, perfect for enjoying a slice on a sunny day. Locals love the creative toppings that add a unique twist to classic flavors.
Capri Pizzeria is a family-run gem, ensuring every pizza is made with love and attention to detail.
Naples Wood Fired Pizza & Smokehouse BBQ – Naples, NY
In the heart of Naples, NY, lies a culinary delight for pizza and BBQ lovers alike. Naples Wood Fired Pizza & Smokehouse BBQ combines the best of both worlds. Their wood-fired pizzas are known for a smoky flavor that enhances every bite.
The charming, rustic setting provides a warm, welcoming vibe that keeps locals coming back. Each pizza tells a story, crafted with fresh ingredients and a hint of BBQ flair.
The fusion of pizza and BBQ might sound unconventional, but it’s a bold venture that has paid off deliciously.
Pizza Villa – Oswego, NY
Pizza Villa in Oswego is where flavor meets fun. This family-friendly spot is a beloved fixture in the community, known for its vibrant atmosphere and exceptional pizza.
Each slice is a testament to the rich flavors that Pizza Villa prides itself on. The dough is hand-tossed to perfection, resulting in a crispy yet chewy delight.
The friendly staff and playful decor make it a hit with both kids and adults. Whether a local or a visitor, Pizza Villa promises a memorable pizza experience.
Lazaro’s Pizzeria & Mexican Food – Catskill, NY
Lazaro’s in Catskill is where pizza meets fiesta. This unique establishment offers a delightful mix of Italian and Mexican cuisines, creating a fusion that’s nothing short of extraordinary.
The pizzas come with a Mexican twist, featuring toppings like jalapeños and chorizo, which add a spicy kick. The vibrant atmosphere reflects the colorful menu.
Lazaro’s isn’t just a restaurant; it’s an experience that invites you to explore new flavors. Locals rave about the creative combinations that promise a fiesta in every bite.
The Brick House Bakery – Cobleskill, NY
Known for more than just its pastries, The Brick House Bakery in Cobleskill serves pizzas that leave a lasting impression. This charming bakery combines the art of baking with the rustic appeal of wood-fired pizzas.
The crust is a masterpiece, crispy and airy, a perfect base for fresh toppings. The aroma of freshly baked dough and the warmth of the bakery make each visit special.
Bakers here take pride in their craft, ensuring each pizza is a testament to their dedication. It’s a hidden gem worth discovering.
Jerlando’s Ristorante & Pizza Co. – Watkins Glen, NY
Jerlando’s in Watkins Glen is a slice of Italy in the heart of New York. Known for its authentic Italian flavors, the pizzeria offers a menu full of traditional delights.
The pizzas are crafted with love, using recipes passed down through generations. Each bite carries the essence of Italy, from the rich sauce to the perfectly melted cheese.
The elegant setting adds a touch of class, making it a favorite for both casual diners and special occasions. Jerlando’s is a culinary journey worth taking.
Dante’s Pizzeria – Oneonta, NY
Dante’s Pizzeria in Oneonta is known for its modern twist on traditional flavors. With an open kitchen and lively atmosphere, it’s a place where pizza becomes performance art.
The pizzas are crafted with creativity, offering unique toppings that surprise and delight. Locals appreciate the innovative approach that Dante’s brings to the table.
Whether it’s a casual meal or a special celebration, Dante’s provides a vibrant backdrop for all occasions. Each slice is a testament to their culinary creativity.
Sal’s Original Pizzeria of Oneonta – Oneonta, NY
Sal’s Original Pizzeria is a staple in Oneonta, known for its retro charm and timeless pizzas. The decor pays homage to the classic pizzerias of the past, creating a nostalgic dining experience.
Each pizza is a blend of tradition and taste, with a focus on high-quality ingredients and authentic recipes. The bustling environment reflects the pizzeria’s popularity among locals.
Sal’s is more than just pizza; it’s a piece of Oneonta’s history. The beloved establishment continues to serve happiness, one slice at a time.
Bucciero’s Pizzeria – Stillwater, NY
Nestled within the heart of Stillwater, Bucciero’s Pizzeria is where tradition meets taste. The locals swear by their thin, crispy crust topped with homemade sauce. Each slice is a perfect balance of cheese and toppings, offering a mouthful of flavors.
The warm, inviting ambiance makes you feel right at home. Regulars enjoy the friendly chatter of staff and patrons alike. Bucciero’s doesn’t just serve pizza; it’s a slice of community.
Legend has it, the secret sauce recipe has been passed down through generations, making every bite a taste of history.