Fridays in Wisconsin are not just a meal, they are a ritual with crispy edges and stories told across Formica tables. I hit the highway with a cooler, napkins, and a map, determined to crown the true fry champs. You will smell the butter, hear the crackle, and maybe plan your own road trip by the time we are done. Four spots begged for trophies, but every plate had a tale worth tasting.
White Stag Inn – Rhinelander, Wisconsin
Pulling into White Stag Inn feels like stepping into Wisconsin’s pine scented memory. The fish arrives shatter crisp, a beer batter that crackles before the fork sinks in. Tangy slaw cools the bite, while rye bread soaks up butter like a faithful friend. You squeeze a lemon and the room hums with Friday chatter.
TrendingNow
Waffle fries come salted just right, sturdy enough to swipe through tartar. You taste lake country pride in every crunchy corner. Service is friendly, no fuss, and quick with extra lemons and napkins. If you love a classic Northwoods vibe, this one wraps you in flannel and sends you home happy.
Local Ocean Seafoods – Newport, Oregon
Okay, I detoured west for comparison and science. Local Ocean serves ocean bright halibut that flakes like sea foam under a crisp jacket. The batter is thin, almost tempura light, letting the fish sing first. Tartar is herb speckled, briny, and clean, with a lemon snap.
Fries are hand cut and sturdy, great with malt vinegar. You hear gulls outside and smell salt on the breeze, which makes each bite feel alive. Coleslaw leans citrusy, balancing richness without heavy mayo. It is not Wisconsin, sure, but it sharpened my standards before the trophy hunt back home.
Buckhorn Supper Club – Milton, Wisconsin
The Buckhorn plates nostalgia with a wink. You start with an Old Fashioned sweet, then the fish arrives golden and proud. Batter clings just enough, leaving wisps of steam when you break it open. The baked potato is salt crusted, butter melting into a tiny lake.
Coleslaw is creamy but lively, with pepper bite. Service moves like clockwork, refilling drinks before you notice. Rye bread is warm and soft enough to cradle leftover fish. This is a trophy contender, the kind of Friday that turns into a tradition without asking permission.
Mark’s East Side – Appleton, Wisconsin
Mark’s is perch paradise, crisp fillets stacked like golden ribbons. Potato pancakes come lacy edged and hot, perfect with applesauce. The combo tastes like fall fairs and church basements, comforting but not sleepy. Each bite stays light, never greasy, and you keep reaching back.
Servers move fast and smile faster, making full rooms feel easy. Tartar skews dill forward, bright enough to wake the palate. You will want a second round of pancakes, trust me. This spot delivers a reliable, hometown hug that still leaves room for surprise.
Five O’Clock Club – Eau Claire, Wisconsin
Five O’Clock Club nails walleye with a husky, crunchy coat that protects delicate flesh. Crinkle fries transport you right to childhood, salty grooves holding ketchup like treasure. The room buzzes with easy laughter and the clink of short glasses. You settle in quickly, like a regular who never left.
Coleslaw brings cabbage snap and a peppery finish. Tartar tastes house made, with pickle chunks that pop. Portions are generous but not sloppy, and plates stay hot to the last bite. It is a Friday that feels earned after a week of work.
Van Abel’s of Hollandtown – Kaukauna, Wisconsin
Van Abel’s serves family style comfort with community heartbeat. Bowls of slaw and rye hit the table, then the haddock arrives piping and fragrant. The batter is crisp but gentle, letting the fish flake in wide petals. Potato wedges carry crispy jackets and tender centers.
You pass plates, trade stories, and realize this is how Friday is meant to feel. Tartar leans sweet pickle, a classic Wisconsin note. Service is practiced and warm, like church volunteers who never forget a face. A quiet contender for a trophy, built on generosity and balance.
Ishnala Supper Club – Lake Delton, Wisconsin
Ishnala pairs a postcard view with a fish fry that respects the scene. Perch is the star, golden and tender, with a whisper crisp coat. You sip a brandy Old Fashioned while the lake glows outside. Buttered rye and a chive dotted potato tie everything together.
Service is polished without being stiff. Tartar stays bright and lemony, nudging the fish forward. Prices run higher, but the setting elevates each bite. For a special Friday, this is a memory maker and yes, a worthy trophy spot.
The Packing House – Milwaukee, Wisconsin
The Packing House goes big without losing finesse. Cod fillets arrive in a crisp shell that audibly shatters. Potato pancakes are golden, with edges like lace and a soft center. The clam chowder starter warms you right to your elbows.
Servers hustle with practiced grace through a sea of red booths. Tartar is creamy and bright, anchoring each bite. Lines can be long, but turnover is quick and friendly. This is a Milwaukee institution and a trophy level heavyweight in my book.
Bootleggers Lodge – Tomahawk, Wisconsin
Bootleggers Lodge serves bluegill that tastes like summer on the dock. The fillets are small and super crisp, seasoned so the sweetness shines. Potato wedges land hot and peppery, perfect for scooping tartar. The dining room glows with timber and firelight, pure Northwoods comfort.
Coleslaw is bright, hinting at celery seed. Service is neighborly, easygoing but attentive with refills. Order a second plate if you love bluegill, because it disappears fast. This is a sleeper hit that nudged my shortlist for hardware.
Kroll’s West – Ashwaubenon, Wisconsin
Kroll’s West brings stadium energy to a classic fry. The cod is crunchy outside, juicy inside, tucked beside seasoned fries that disappear quickly. A buttered hard roll shows up like a local handshake. Add stadium sauce and you are basically tailgating at the table.
Coleslaw stays zippy and crisp. Service moves fast, even on game weekends, which says a lot. The vibe is loud, happy, and unapologetically Green Bay. Not my top trophy, but a must stop when the lights at Lambeau glow.
Toby’s Supper Club – Madison, Wisconsin
Toby’s is pure Madison comfort with zero pretense. Lake perch is delicate and perfectly fried, with a whisper thin crust. The baked potato splits open to welcome butter and sour cream. Rye bread is warm enough to fog the butter packet.
The bar pours honest Old Fashioneds, sweet and cherry kissed. Tartar leans tangy and herb bright. Service feels like neighbors looking out for you, not just staff. I would hand them a small trophy for keeping Fridays simple and right.
Schwarz’s Supper Club – New Holstein, Wisconsin
Schwarz’s is where tradition tastes like celebration. Haddock arrives flaky under a crisp, even coat, while perch brings buttery sweetness. Hash browns are crackly on top and tender below, perfect with a splash of ketchup. The relish tray starts the night with pickles and radishes.
Servers handle crowds with calm precision. Tartar balances dill, lemon, and a touch of sweetness. You feel the years in the walls, but the plate stays fresh and lively. This is final trophy territory, the kind of Friday you measure others against.
Discussion about this post