Embark on a savory adventure through Indiana as I pursue the legendary tenderloin sandwich. Each stop offers its unique twist on this cherished Hoosier delicacy. From crispy coatings to juicy flavors, here are my nine notable finds.
Nick’s Kitchen – Huntington, IN
Nick’s Kitchen is a slice of Americana, nestled in Huntington. Known for its breaded tenderloin, the sandwich here is legendary.
The tenderloin is perfectly crisp on the outside, while maintaining a juicy interior. A bite into this sandwich transports you back to simpler times.
Served with fresh lettuce and tomatoes, it’s a culinary classic that’s hard to resist. Founded in 1908, Nick’s Kitchen has become an institution, celebrating Indiana’s proud culinary heritage. This sandwich is not just a meal; it’s a piece of history.
Edwards Drive-In – Indianapolis, IN
Edwards Drive-In offers a delightful retro experience in Indianapolis. The tenderloin sandwich here is generously sized and full of flavor.
Crispy and light, the breading complements the tender meat inside. Paired with pickles and mustard, each bite is a nostalgic journey.
The drive-in setting adds to the charm, making it a perfect spot for a throwback meal. Known for its family-friendly atmosphere, Edwards Drive-In is a must-visit for those who appreciate classic American eats.
Workingman’s Friend – Indianapolis, IN
Workingman’s Friend in Indianapolis is a gem among tenderloin enthusiasts. The sandwich here is thick, juicy, and bursting with flavor.
Topped with caramelized onions, it offers a delightful contrast to the crisp breading. Accompanied by a cold beer, it’s a taste sensation.
This venue, with its lively atmosphere, is a favorite among locals. Known for its welcoming vibe, Workingman’s Friend promises a hearty meal with a side of camaraderie.
Nine Irish Brothers – Lafayette, IN
Nine Irish Brothers in Lafayette brings an Irish twist to the tenderloin sandwich. The sandwich here is hearty and satisfying.
Battered in a unique blend, it offers a mouthwatering crunch. Paired with seasoned fries, it’s a pub classic.
Enjoyed best with a pint of Guinness, the ambiance adds to the experience. The friendly service and cozy setting make it a charming spot to enjoy your meal.
Upland Brewing Wood Shop – Bloomington, IN
At Upland Brewing Wood Shop in Bloomington, creativity meets tradition. The tenderloin sandwich here is a culinary masterpiece.
Crafted with locally sourced ingredients, it features artisan pickles that enhance its flavor profile. The brewery’s craft beer pairs flawlessly.
The innovative atmosphere invites exploration, making it a top choice for foodies and beer enthusiasts alike. Known for its commitment to quality, Upland Brewing delivers a memorable dining experience.
Plump’s Last Shot – Indianapolis, IN
Plump’s Last Shot in Indianapolis offers a tenderloin sandwich with a fiery twist. The addition of spicy mayo and jalapeños sets it apart.
This sandwich is a bold, flavor-packed experience, perfect for those who like a kick. The crisp breading and juicy meat are a dynamic duo.
Surrounded by sports memorabilia, the vibrant atmosphere makes each visit exciting. It’s a hotspot for fans and food lovers alike.
The Willard – Franklin, IN
The Willard in Franklin is a charming historic venue that serves a memorable tenderloin sandwich. Known for its vintage charm, this inn delights with every bite.
The tenderloin is wonderfully crispy, paired with homemade coleslaw for a refreshing twist. The flavors are well-balanced and delicious.
Set within a rustic backdrop, The Willard offers a sense of nostalgia and warmth, making it a beloved destination for both locals and visitors.
The Friendly Tavern – Zionsville, IN
The Friendly Tavern in Zionsville lives up to its name by offering a warm and inviting atmosphere. Their tenderloin sandwich, with Swiss cheese and caramelized onions, is a standout.
This combination creates a rich, savory flavor that leaves a lasting impression. The sandwich is perfectly paired with a local craft beer.
With its casual setting, The Friendly Tavern is an ideal spot for a relaxed meal with friends. Its reputation for quality food makes it a community favorite.
Hollyhock Hill (tenderloin special) – Indianapolis, IN
Hollyhock Hill in Indianapolis is famed for its tenderloin special. This sandwich is an elegant take on the classic, featuring garlic aioli and arugula.
The tenderloin is expertly prepared, offering a delightful mix of flavors and textures. The cozy ambiance enhances the dining experience.
Surrounded by vintage decor, Hollyhock Hill exudes charm and comfort, making it a perfect stop for those seeking a refined meal.