Exploring the hidden nooks of Indiana, I embarked on a delightful journey to find the most delectable donuts. Here are my top picks from a whirlwind tour of ten unique shops.
Long’s Bakery – Indianapolis
Long’s Bakery in Indianapolis is a beloved institution known for its incredibly fluffy and sweet glazed donuts. Locals often line up early in the morning, eager to grab a dozen before they sell out.
The aroma of fresh pastries fills the air, creating an irresistible pull for anyone nearby. Long’s has been serving the community for decades, maintaining a tradition of quality and taste.
Their yeast-raised donuts have a light, airy texture that melts in your mouth, making them a must-try for any donut enthusiast visiting the city.
Titus Bakery – Lebanon / Westfield
Titus Bakery, with locations in Lebanon and Westfield, exudes a charming small-town atmosphere. Known for their maple pecan donuts, they offer a combination of sweetness and crunch that delights the senses.
Family-owned and operated, Titus Bakery has been a favorite for generations, providing a comforting taste of hometown hospitality. Their diverse range of flavors caters to all preferences, ensuring every customer leaves satisfied.
Whether you’re a fan of classic or creative flavors, Titus Bakery promises a delightful experience with every bite.
Dan’s Variety Bakery – Kokomo
Dan’s Variety Bakery in Kokomo is a hidden gem offering an array of delectable treats. The bakery’s apple fritters, with their perfect balance of sweetness and spice, have earned them a loyal following.
Each visit feels like stepping back in time, with its quaint decor and friendly service. The bakery’s diverse assortment ensures there’s something for everyone, from traditional glazed to unique flavor combinations.
Dan’s has been a staple in the community for years, and its reputation for quality keeps patrons coming back for more.
Hilligoss Bakery – Brownsburg
In Brownsburg, Hilligoss Bakery is a cherished spot for donut lovers. Known for their famously soft and buttery cinnamon rolls, this bakery offers a nostalgic experience.
The bakery’s friendly atmosphere and welcoming staff make it a delightful morning stop. Generations have enjoyed their delightful treats, creating a beloved tradition in the community.
Whether it’s cinnamon rolls or classic glazed donuts, Hilligoss ensures every visit is filled with warmth and flavor, leaving you craving more.
Mary Lou Donuts – Lafayette
Mary Lou Donuts in Lafayette is a vibrant hub for donut enthusiasts. Their chocolate frosted and peanut butter-filled donuts are crowd favorites.
The shop’s lively atmosphere and colorful treats create an inviting environment for all ages. With a rich history in the city, Mary Lou’s remains a staple for locals and visitors alike.
Their commitment to quality and variety makes every visit an adventure in flavor, ensuring you leave with a smile and a satisfied sweet tooth.
Boyden’s Southside Bakery – Indianapolis
Boyden’s Southside Bakery offers a warm, inviting atmosphere with a touch of nostalgia. Known for their custard-filled long johns, they have been a favorite in Indianapolis for years.
The bakery’s traditional approach to baking brings out the rich flavors in every bite. Each donut is crafted with care, delivering a taste of homemade goodness.
Boyden’s commitment to quality and community ensures a delightful experience with every visit, making it a beloved morning stop for locals.
Munster Donut – Munster
Munster Donut is renowned for its old-fashioned charm and exceptional donuts. Their blueberry cake donuts are a standout, praised for their moist texture and vibrant flavor.
This cozy bakery offers a welcoming ambiance that draws in both locals and visitors. The friendly staff and delectable offerings make it a memorable stop in Munster.
From classic glazed to unique creations, Munster Donut provides a delightful escape from the ordinary, ensuring every bite is a taste sensation.
Pana Donuts – Indianapolis
Pana Donuts in Indianapolis is a modern twist on the traditional donut shop. Known for their mango-filled donuts, they offer an exciting splash of tropical flavor.
The shop’s contemporary design and innovative flavors attract a diverse crowd, looking for something beyond the ordinary. Pana’s commitment to creativity and quality stands out in every bite.
Whether it’s a classic favorite or a new discovery, Pana Donuts promises a unique and flavorful adventure for all who visit.
Square Donuts – Terre Haute
Square Donuts in Terre Haute offers a distinctive twist with their signature square-shaped donuts. Known for their rich chocolate icing, these treats are a visual and culinary delight.
The shop’s quirky design and innovative approach make it a fun destination for donut lovers. Their commitment to quality ensures that each donut is as delightful as it is unique.
Square Donuts is more than just a novelty; it’s a delicious experience that challenges the ordinary, leaving a lasting impression with every visit.
Tim’s Bakery – McCordsville
Tim’s Bakery in McCordsville is a community favorite, renowned for its delicious apple cinnamon donuts. The bakery’s cozy setting offers a friendly and inviting atmosphere.
Known for fresh, homemade goodness, Tim’s creates a sense of belonging for everyone who walks through the door. Their dedication to quality and tradition has earned them loyal customers over the years.
From early mornings to late afternoons, Tim’s Bakery promises a delightful experience that embodies the heart of McCordsville.
Rise’n Roll Bakery – Greenwood
Rise’n Roll Bakery in Greenwood is famed for its melt-in-your-mouth caramel cinnamon donuts. The cozy atmosphere and friendly staff make it a beloved spot.
This Amish-inspired bakery offers a taste of tradition with every bite. The donuts are crafted with care, reflecting a commitment to quality that shines through.
Whether stopping for breakfast or a midday treat, Rise’n Roll provides a warm and satisfying experience, cherished by locals and newcomers alike.
Doughnut Vault – Fort Wayne
Doughnut Vault in Fort Wayne combines elegance with indulgence, offering gourmet creations like their lavender honey donuts. The shop’s chic design complements the artful flavors.
Each donut is a masterpiece, blending culinary creativity with traditional techniques. This bakery’s dedication to innovation ensures a memorable taste experience.
From its stylish decor to its exquisite offerings, Doughnut Vault captivates the senses, making it a must-visit destination for Fort Wayne locals and visitors.
Jack’s Donuts – Carmel
Jack’s Donuts in Carmel is a lively spot known for its creative flavor combinations, like their popular banana cream donuts. The shop’s vibrant energy draws in a diverse crowd.
With a rich history and a commitment to excellence, Jack’s continues to surprise and delight its patrons. Each donut is thoughtfully crafted, ensuring a flavorful journey.
From classics to bold new tastes, Jack’s Donuts offers something for every palate, establishing itself as a cornerstone of Carmel’s donut scene.
General American Donut Company – Indianapolis
The General American Donut Company in Indianapolis offers a sleek, modern take on traditional donuts. Known for their salted caramel creations, the taste is as refined as the setting.
The minimalist decor and artisanal focus draw in those seeking a sophisticated treat. Each donut is crafted with precision, showcasing a dedication to quality and flavor.
Whether you’re a local or just passing through, this shop promises a delightful experience, blending innovation with timeless appeal in every bite.