Is that the smell of a freshly baked cookie? I bet it’s the fall treats from Milk Bar calling us. 🍂
Pastries and the fall season always go together. It’s even better when you don your apron and mix up some cake batter while the 2005 movie The Family Stone plays in the background. I know, right. There’s something special about seeing the iconic trio of Diane Keaton, Sarah Jessica Parker, and Rachel McAdams all on screen!
But as much as we like to have the ideal fall, we can’t. With all the deadlines and stress we face at work and in life, there is little to no time to relax. But don’t fret just yet, you can always buy a little sweet treat with your big girl money as Milk Bar rolls out their fall pastries menu.
With an assortment of sweet treats and goodies, Milk Bar is the perfect place to buy this season’s cravings. From cookies, pumpkin-flavored cakes, and soft-serve, their offerings are sure to bring you comfort in this chilly weather. Choose among their wide variety of fall offerings as they’re available at Milk Bar stores and online. Also, take advantage of their free shipping on orders $100 and above, which is available for a limited time only.

Here’s a cake, take a break. You deserve it! 🍰
Fall Cakes
Milk Bar is famous for their bestselling Birthday Cake, which has three tiers of flecked rainbow cake that resembles the one you used to get as a kid. This fall, they are returning a fan-favorite cake and unveiling a new one.

Pumpkin Coffee-Cake Cake
It’s back! The Pumpkin Coffee-Cake Cake is back for fall, and they’re definitely selling like hotcakes! Milk Bar tags this flavor as their cake that sells out every year. How could you not love a vanilla cake with a layer of cinnamon goo? But that’s just the base of the cake, as it has an added layer of crunchy cinnamon streusel and pumpkin flavors of frosting and cheesecake filling. The best part of the cake would probably be its topper with loads of coffee cake topping.
Quadruple Chocolate Cake
Milk Bar is bringing a gift for chocolate lovers with the new Quadruple Chocolate Cake. This moist and fudgy chocolate base sponge is something that you never tasted before. It is filled with brownie jam and chocolate cake crumbs that are crunchy enough for the layers. The chocolate cake is topped with a rich chocolate frosting. This quadruple goodness is death by chocolate!
RELATED: Handel’s Reimagines Classic PB&J Sandwich With a New Ice Cream Flavor
Pies, Pastries, and Soft Serve
This New York bakery is bringing a piece of them wherever they go, as they have been in the dessert scene since 2008. Milk Bar is committed to feeding flavorful treats to those who “crave the unexpected.” Unexpected means craving a birthday cake even when it’s no one’s birthday. And speaking of the unexpected, they are more than just a bakery that serves the typical cookie-cake duo. Check out these fall treats and choose your pick.

Milk Bar Pie Soft Serve
The Milk Bar Pie is one of the most well-loved desserts at Milk Bar. Its filling can be described as somewhat sticky but buttery. Are you ready for the best part? It has a sweet and salty milk filling. Now imagine all of these but in the form of a creamy frozen soft serve. Sounds good, right? Get a swirl of the Milk Bar Pie Soft Serve and see for yourself.
Chocolate Milk Bar Pie
We’ve got another Milk Bar variant; this time, it’s not an undercover soft serve. 🤣It’s the same as the Milk Bar Pie; the only difference is that its butter center is made out of gooey chocolate. What’s even better is that the crust of the pie is made out of chocolate chip cookies for extra gooeyness. The pie is finished off with a powder of chocolate sugar. Sadly, they’re only available at New York and Los Angeles Milk Bar flagship stores.
Cider Donut Truffles
Looking for the perfect fall snack? Say hello to the Cider Donut Truffles that completes the fall flavors. This cake truffles are soaked in cinnamon apple studded cake with cider. It is then coated in a shell of donut-flavored sand for an added fall flavor. Get these bite-sized truffles for 12 pieces, or choose to bundle them with the Pumpkin Coffee-Cake Cake and save $8.
Cookie Classics Collection
Milk Bar believes that every cookie has a texture and flavor story to tell. With their wide variety of cookies, they create the texture according to the flavor and filling. This fall season, Milk Bar is keeping it simple as they bring fans a classic cookie collection featuring the cookies that we make at home. Nothing is more fall than this!

Chocolate Chip ‘N Chunk Cookie
Chocolate Chip Cookie may be one of the most common cookie flavors out there, but nothing beats it. Milk Bar wants to put their own spin on this classic treat by creating buttery and vanilla-based cookie dough. It’s encrusted with gooey chocolate chips and chocolate chunks.
Oatmeal Cream Cookie
The classic oatmeal cookie takes a spin at Milk Bar as this lunch bag favorite just gets better. It has a hearty brown sugar base that is encrusted with white chocolate chips. This nostalgic treat will remind you of the ones that your mom or grandmother used to make at home.
Triple PB
Another classic and easy-to-make cookie flavor is the peanut butter cookie, but of course, with Milk Bar’s touch. It features a soft and nutty energy from the peanut butter but of course, Milk Bar would want to put their touch on it. The spin? They overload it with peanut butter with peanut butter chocolate chunks and chips. If you’re a peanut butter fan, you’ll definitely love this!
RELATED: Cookie Lovers Rejoice: Crumbl Drops New and Cant-Miss Flavors
From The Club
I’ve known Milk Bar to be a brand serving quality soft serve as its cups became a popular Instagram feed filler. I haven’t known until now that they’re also a bakery and desserts shop serving pastries and cake. I’m excited to try their fall flavors, specifically the Milk Bar Pie Soft Serve and the Oatmeal Cream Cookie. With these snacks by my side, I guess I’m ready for a fall marathon of watching Gilmore Girls — my ideal fall relaxation. 😌