Chick-fil-A, we love you but taking some of the best items off the menu? That was cold. Remember the Chicken Salad Sandwich? The Frosted Sunrise? Us too, and we miss them dearly. Here are 10 discontinued Chick-fil-A items that deserve a second chance, and we’re here to make a case for their return!
10. Chicken, Egg & Cheese Bagel
The discontinuation of Chicken, Egg & Cheese Bagel still stings because it was unique in the fast food universe. The savory trio combo (chicken patty, egg, and melty cheese) created a protein-packed and flavor-rich breakfast for many. And let’s not forget the use of sunflower multigrain bagel. This added real texture and heft to the sandwich!
9. Watermelon Mint Lemonade
What happens when you combine Chick-fil-A’s classic lemonade flavors with hints of watermelon and mint? You get this authentically refreshing drink! The demand for this discontinued seasonal item was so overwhelming that Chick-fil-a brought it back in April 2023, and it wasn’t just the lemonade. They had multiple flavor variations (Sunjoy, frosted, and tea).
8. Lemon Kale Caesar Salad
The Lemon Kale Caesar Salad earned high praise during its limited-time run in April 2021. It was the first salad that featured warm Grilled Nuggets, combined with romaine, kale, shaved parmesan cheese, and lemon wedges. Instead of heavy cream, it used Lemon Caesar Vinaigrette dressing. The result was light but filling salad; it felt like a satisfying meal rather than a side order.
7. Cheesecake
It was roughly 13 years ago since we last saw the cheesecake on Chick-fil-A’s menu. This sweet treat delivered a luscious, velvety texture that was just perfect. Though only few people remember this item today, die-hard fans on Reddit couldn’t stop talking about how special it was. Chick-fil-A’s cheesecake was a rare fast food slice that felt upscale.
6. Coleslaw
Coleslaw is one of the most iconic discontinued items from Chick-fil-A. It was among the original menu items developed by the chain’s founder Truett Cathy. Sadly, in 2023, Chick-fil-A confirmed that they won’t be bringing back the well-loved coleslaw, but they did share a recipe for it that you can follow at home. Still, the original version hits different and the chicken sandwich needs it!
5. Frosted Sunrise
Who would have thought that Chick-fil-A’s vanilla Icedream dessert and orange juice would taste so good? Yup, that’s the Frosted Sunrise for you! This menu item was released for a limited time in early March 2018, creating a creamy and tart treat. If Chick-fil-A could make the Frosted Lemonade and Frosted Coffee permanent menu options, why not the Frosted Sunrise?
4. Grilled Spicy Deluxe
Health-conscious heat lovers, this one’s for you! We all know that there wasn’t a grilled sandwich with a spicy kick until Grilled Spicy Deluxe came in, and so this item fills a gap on the menu without overcomplicating things. Grilled, flavorful, and moderately spicy, this sandwich was always a welcome option for those seeking something satisfying minus the excess calories.
3. Banana Pudding Milkshake
Based on a tip we got from a Chick-fil-A employee, the Banana Pudding Milkshake isn’t making a comeback in 2025. But, really, we think it’s time to move past the tradition of bringing it back seasonally. Ever since the shake was launched in 2011, Chick-fil-A fans fell in love with the overall taste and texture. Even the chain mentioned that Banana Pudding Milkshake is one of their most requested seasonal shakes.
2. Smokehouse BBQ Bacon Sandwich
Initially launched in 2017, this sandwich made our hearts sing with its layered flavors from marinated grilled chicken, brown sugar bacon, Colby Jack cheese, lettuce, and Smokehouse BBQ sauce. Critics have shared that it’s one of the best sandwiches on the menu and rightly so, because Chick-fil-A has resurrected it a few times for a limited time. It’s a fan-loved powerhouse that deserves a permanent spot on the menu.
1. Chicken Salad Sandwich
And for the top spot we have the sandwich that offered a unique blend of comfort, nostalgia, and Southern charm. The Chicken Salad Sandwich was first released in 2008 as part of the chain’s menu enhancement campaign and was discontinued in 2017. While Chick-fil-A also shared their recipe for the chicken salad, many agreed that it didn’t feel the same. The flavor, texture, and convenience were hard to replicate.