Sometimes, you need a milkshake to turn your ordinary day into something special. However, not all milkshakes are created equal. Some are just meh, others are pure magic, and we’re here to talk about the best of the best. When it comes to fast food milkshakes, these are the ultimate cool kids!
15. Sonic’s Peanut Butter Classic Shake
If you’re looking for a thick shake that’s worth your money, head over to Sonic Drive-In and get their Peanut Butter Classic Shake. It’s already good on its own, nailing the peanut butter flavor without being overpowering or too salty. However, fans swear by adding hot fudge into the mix to make it totally addictive!
14. Arby’s Jamocha Shake
Who says you can’t get your caffeine fix if you settled on a milkshake? At Arby’s, the Jamocha Shake boasts a thick, creamy texture with a modest amount of caffeine. While not as potent as a cup of coffee, it’s definitely a sweet way to get a gentle energy boost. Of course, the rich chocolatey flavor won’t let you down as well.
13. Culver’s Salted Caramel Shake
Sweet meets salty perfection in Culver’s Salted Caramel Shake. Aside from the buttery flavor with a hint of saltiness, what sets this shake apart is its base. It’s made with Culver’s signature Fresh Frozen Custard, so it offers a luxurious mouthfeel. Savor each sip slowly and two words will come to mind: creamy and decadent.
12. Steak ‘n Shake’s Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Shake
If you’re ready for cookie dough delight, don’t miss the chance to try this shake made with real vanilla ice cream and delicious chunks of chocolate chip cookie dough. It also comes with more cookie dough on top, chocolate syrup, and a cherry. It’s got multiple flavor layers, making you feel like you’re drinking a full-on sundae.
11. Shake Shack’s Black and White Shake
This shake flavor from Shake Shack offers a beautiful contrast of cool vanilla and deep chocolate. It’s simple, iconic, and endlessly satisfying. Even though it uses fudge sauce rather than chocolate custard, it tastes more like a chocolate shake. If you want an even combination of chocolate and vanilla flavors, the Vanilla and Chocolate Shake would be a better fit.
10. Sonic’s Strawberry Cheesecake Master Shake
Strawberry cheesecake is one of the iconic flavors out there because of its satisfying balance of sweet and tangy flavors. This flavor in a shake? You can get it at Sonic! The Strawberry Cheesecake Master Shake offers a harmonious blend of rich cheesecake, strawberries, vanilla soft serve, plus whipped cream and cherry, making it a must-try for shake enthusiasts.
9. Carl’s Jr.’s Vanilla Shake
Vanilla never goes out of style, but Carl’s Jr.’s Vanilla Shake? It deserves way more love than it gets. Carl’s Jr.’s Vanilla Shake got that fragrant vanilla bean taste—sweet, smooth, and nostalgic. The shake’s thickness also gives it a slow-sipping indulgence that makes the overall experience feel extra special.
8. Chick-fil-A’s Cookies and Cream Shake
Fans of Chick-fil-A’s Cookies & Cream Milkshake unite in this Reddit thread, with one of them saying that it was heaven in a cup! It’s hand-spun in the old-fashioned way, ensuring a perfect blend of ingredients. Fans love the quality of the ice cream and Chick-fil-A’s generosity when it comes to cookies and cream bits. A tip? You can get it with an extra crushed cookie!
7. Culver’s Mint Shake
Culver’s Mint Shake is a lowkey gem. It’s not too fancy and it’s not too basic either. While most people default to chocolate or vanilla, mint got its own personality. It’s the kind of shake that cools you down and wakes up your taste buds. Its simplicity (no chunks or extra toppings) makes it a great choice for daily indulgence.
6. Del Taco’s Strawberry Shake
For those who appreciate a bit of texture in their shakes, you can’t go wrong with Del Taco’s Strawberry Shake. It might be weird for a taco place to offer a strawberry shake, but give this item a chance. It incorporates real strawberries, which already makes it a standout among other shakes that rely on artificial flavorings. Even past Del Taco employees love this shake flavor!
5. Five Guy’s Strawberry OREO Milkshake
What’s better than a strawberry shake? Strawberry + OREO milkshake from Five Guys! This is one of the best desserts you could get at the restaurant, offering the perfect blend of fruity freshness and creamy indulgence. Similar to Del Taco, Five Guys uses fresh strawberries for their strawberry mix-ins, resulting in a genuine, fruity taste.
4. In-N-Out’s Neapolitan Milkshake
Can’t pick among the big three of milkshake flavors (chocolate, vanilla, and strawberry)? What if we told you that at In-N-Out, you can enjoy all three in one cup! Yup, that’s what fans call Neapolitan shake and it’s a secret menu item. To order, kindly ask your server for a “Neapolitan Shake” and they will prepare it for you.
3. Portillo’s Chocolate Cake Shake
Here’s a legendary dessert that could captivate you in an instant. Portillo’s doesn’t just offer a regular chocolate shake, they blend an actual slice of moist chocolate cake into the shake! Just imagine for a moment how dreamy is that. Because of the unique ingredients, the shake is notably thick and often requires a spoon. Ditch the straw and get ready for a chunky, sweet adventure!
2. Shake Shack’s Chocolate Shake
Of course, we can’t have a list of the best milkshake flavors without the classic chocolate. The best place to get it? Shake Shack! Aside from using a creamy frozen custard for the base, this brand incorporates real chocolate from premium sources, so this isn’t your average, syrupy shake. Spoon is also mandatory for this one.
1. Jack in the Box’s OREO Shake
Jack in the Box’s OREO Shake has earned the reputation for being “the fairest of them all” because all you could ever want in a milkshake is here. Creamy vanilla base, generous OREO cookie chunks, spoon-worthy consistency: check, check, and check. Also, unlike other seasonal offerings, this OREO Shake is available throughout the year. Get it when the craving strikes!