If you have ever chased the perfect pulled pork sandwich, Payne’s Bar-B-Que in Memphis is the finish line. Housed in a simple cinderblock building, this beloved spot turns smoke, patience, and tradition into something unforgettable. Locals call it legendary for a reason, and one bite of that chopped or pulled pork with neon slaw makes the case. Come hungry, come early, and let Memphis barbecue history meet your plate.
The Legendary Pulled Pork Sandwich
You hear the legend before you taste it, but the first bite settles everything. Payne’s pulled pork sandwich piles tender strands and barky edges onto a soft bun, then crowns it with that tangy, mustard-yellow slaw. Sweet heat from the sauce seeps into every bite, balancing smoke with brightness.
TrendingNow
There is nothing fussy here, just focused craft. The pork is chopped or pulled to order, so texture stays lively and juicy. Hold the sandwich with two hands, tilt your head, and let it drip a little. That is the Memphis way, and it feels right the second you taste it.
Neon Mustard Slaw Magic
The neon-yellow slaw at Payne’s is not just garnish. It is the secret handshake that makes their pork sing. Cabbage stays crunchy while a mustard-forward dressing brings tang, a touch of sweetness, and just enough heat to cut through smoky richness.
You can order without slaw, but you should not. The color alone sets the tone, like sunshine on barbecue. Each bite gets snap, zing, and lift, turning heavy into balanced and craveable. Ask for extra on the side if you love acid and crunch. It brightens the sandwich, perks up ribs, and loves shared plates.
Chopped vs Pulled: Texture Tales
At Payne’s, chopped pork delivers bits of bark in every forkful, giving you smoke, char, and soft interior all at once. Pulled pork is silkier, with long strands that hold sauce differently. Both honor the pit while showing off distinct textures.
If you want chew and snap, go chopped. If you are after lush, saucy strands, go pulled. The counter team will guide you with a smile and a nod. Either way, the mustard slaw ties it together. Try half-and-half if you are indecisive. Memphis barbecue rewards curiosity, and Payne’s makes the choice fun.
That Signature Sauce
The sauce at Payne’s is a personality. It leans sweet with a peppery kiss, then settles into gentle heat that lingers just long enough. You can taste tomatoes, vinegar, and smoke in a conversation that respects the meat.
Order light, medium, or heavy sauced and watch the balance shift. Light lets the bark shout. Heavy gives you a rib-sticky, finger-licking ride. Medium is the move for first timers. Napkins are plentiful, and you will need them. If you love extra, ask without hesitation. Hospitality here is generous, and sauce belongs on everything.
Smoked Sausage Worth The Detour
Pulled pork gets the spotlight, but the smoked sausage sneaks up and steals a scene. Links arrive with blistered skins and juicy centers, catching sauce like they were made for it. A few slices with slaw create a spicy, snappy counterpoint to the pork.
If you are sharing, this is a perfect add-on. The smoke is assertive but friendly, the fat well rendered, and the seasoning bold. Throw some sausage onto a sandwich for texture fireworks. Or let it stand alone and enjoy those charred edges. Either way, it proves Payne’s mastery goes beyond one legend.
Inside The Cinderblock Icon
Payne’s feels like a postcard from Memphis barbecue history. The cinderblock walls, the counter, the hum of lunch hour, and the steady rhythm of orders create calm confidence. No frills, no pretense, just smoke and smiles.
You step in, scan the board, and realize everyone here is on a mission. The team moves with easy precision, piling pork, slaw, and sauce like a ritual. Seats are limited, but the vibe is welcoming. Whether you are local or passing through, you are part of something classic the moment you walk in. It is humble and perfect.
Timing The Short Hours
Payne’s keeps tight hours, so timing is everything. Tuesday, Wednesday, Friday, and Saturday run 11 AM to 2 PM. Sunday, Monday, and Thursday are closed. That narrow window means lunch is the move, and early is smart.
Show up before noon if you want the easiest pace and full selection. The line moves quickly, but once something sells out, that is it. The scarcity adds charm and urgency. Plan your day around this stop and savor the reward. Memphis afternoons feel brighter when you leave with sauce on your fingers and a satisfied grin.
What To Order First Visit
First time at Payne’s? Start with a pulled pork sandwich dressed with yellow slaw and medium sauce. Add a side, then split an order of smoked sausage if you are sharing. This lineup gives you the hallmarks without overwhelming.
Ask for chopped if you crave barky bits. Pulled if you want a juicy, saucy feel. Either route delivers the signature flavors that built the legend. Keep an eye on the board for specials and be ready to pivot if something calls your name. The joy here is tasting Memphis distilled into simple, perfect choices.
Price And Value
Payne’s is famously affordable, marked with a single dollar sign and big flavor. Portions are generous enough to satisfy without needing extras, though you will want them anyway. It is proof that craft does not need to be expensive to be exceptional.
The value becomes obvious when you taste the smoke and care in each bite. Locals keep coming because the quality stays high and the prices stay friendly. Visitors leave impressed that legends can be accessible. Bring cash or card and an appetite. You will spend modestly and eat like royalty.
Why Locals Call It Legendary
Legend status is not declared overnight. It is earned sandwich by sandwich, year after year. Payne’s keeps the flame with consistency, hospitality, and flavors that feel like home. Locals come back because the experience never loses its soul.
That bright slaw, the smoky pork, and the no-nonsense service add up to identity. You can taste Memphis here without needing a tour guide. Visitors often become evangelists after one visit. The legend lives because it is shared, one satisfied grin at a time. That is the power of a place that knows exactly who it is.
Sauce, Slaw, And Bark Harmony
Great barbecue is balance. Payne’s nails harmony between bark, sauce, and slaw. Bark brings crunch and concentrated smoke. Sauce adds sweetness and heat. Slaw cuts through with tang and texture. The trio turns into a melody you cannot stop humming.
When you bite, notice how the bark anchors the flavors while the slaw sparkles. It is a conversation rather than a clash. If you want to tweak the ratios, ask for sauce on the side and build each bite. You are in control, and every combination still feels right.
Small Menu, Big Focus
A short menu can be a promise. Payne’s focuses on doing a few things incredibly well. That tight range keeps quality high and wait times manageable. You are not choosing from pages. You are trusting a craft dialed in over years.
The kitchen hits rhythm fast, and plates land hot. You can taste the repetition in the best way, like a favorite song played by seasoned hands. Every item supports the star, and nothing distracts. That is why people drive across town for lunch. Focus turns into flavor, and flavor becomes memory.
How To Beat The Lunch Rush
To glide through Payne’s at peak hour, think like a regular. Arrive 10 to 15 minutes before 11 AM, park nearby, and scan the menu while you wait. Know your order by the time you hit the counter. The line moves, but efficiency helps everyone.
Bring a friend to share trays and try more. If seating fills up, take your prize to go and find a shady spot. The sandwich travels well, though it begs to be eaten immediately. A little planning gets you maximum enjoyment and minimal stress. That way, the only thing you worry about is napkins.
Takeout Tips For Travelers
Grabbing Payne’s to go is a power move when you are on the road. Ask for sauce and slaw on the side to keep the bun from soaking too fast. Wraps are snug, but a second layer of foil helps hold heat.
Keep napkins and wet wipes handy, and stash a trash bag in the car. If you have a cooler, slide the bag inside to retain warmth. When you stop, assemble each bite so the slaw stays crunchy. It is road trip bliss, Memphis style. Just try not to eat it all before the first stoplight.
Dietary And Kid-Friendly Notes
Payne’s is straightforward barbecue, so you know what you are getting. If you are watching spice, sauce can be kept light or served on the side. Slaw is mustard based, so plan for that flavor profile. Portions split easily for kids, and the staff keeps things friendly.
Vegetarian options are limited, as expected at a barbecue institution. For gluten concerns, ask about buns or consider a tray without bread. The team is happy to guide you. Simplicity is the theme, and clarity helps everyone eat well. You will leave full and smiling.
Neighborhood And Vibes
Located on Lamar Ave, Payne’s feels woven into Memphis daily life. The building is humble, the sign is simple, and the welcome is real. You are not here for glitz. You are here for smoke and soul served without pretense.
Parking is straightforward and turnover is quick during lunch hours. You might chat with a regular in line or hear a story about the old days. The vibe says community first and flavor always. You step outside with a full belly and a sense that you just met a neighborhood classic.
Planning A Memphis BBQ Crawl
If you are building a barbecue crawl, anchor it with Payne’s early in the day. The short hours and big flavors make it the essential first stop. From there, pace yourself with water and small shares so you can keep tasting.
Use Payne’s as your benchmark for slaw, sauce, and bark balance. It sets a high bar and frames the rest of Memphis. Take notes between bites and compare textures, smoke levels, and sweetness. By evening, you will know exactly why Payne’s sits near the top.
Contact And Practical Info
Here is what you need: Payne’s Bar-B-Que, 1762 Lamar Ave, Memphis, TN 38114. Phone is +1 901-272-1523. Hours are Tuesday, Wednesday, Friday, and Saturday from 11 AM to 2 PM. Closed Sunday, Monday, and Thursday. Price range is friendly.
Rating sits around 4.5 stars with hundreds of glowing reviews. It is counter service, quick, and no fuss. Arrive early, bring an appetite, and let the pit masters do the talking. If you are calling ahead, keep it simple and clear. Good plans begin with good info.
How To Find Us
You will find Payne’s Bar-B-Que at 1762 Lamar Ave, Memphis, TN 38114. Plug in coordinates 35.1182188, -90.0030944 and follow your map. Look for the simple cinderblock building and the steady lunchtime crowd. Parking is nearby and turnover is brisk.
The doors open at 11 AM on Tuesday, Wednesday, Friday, and Saturday, closing again at 2 PM. If you pass by outside those hours, you will see the Closed sign. Plan your route, arrive a bit early, and you will land a taste of Memphis barbecue history. When you see that bright slaw, you are home.
Discussion about this post