Ready for a lakeside evening that actually feels special. Bar Harbor Supper Club in Lake Shore is where classic steakhouse tradition meets dress-up-worthy ambiance. Locals swear the steaks and sunsets are worth planning an evening around, and the polished service seals the deal. If you are craving confident flavors, martinis with a view, and that timeless supper club charm, this is your spot.
Signature Ribeye With Lake View
The ribeye arrives sizzling, edges charred just right, and a pat of herb butter cascading into every groove. You catch the lake sparkling through tall windows while the aroma of sear and rosemary drifts upward. It feels like the evening slows down so your first bite can land perfectly.
TrendingNow
Order it medium-rare and let the marbling do the heavy lifting. Pair with a classic martini or a bold cabernet, then lean back and enjoy the hush of conversation around you. It is old-school, proud, and satisfying in a way only a true supper club steak can be.
Old Fashioned At Golden Hour
The bartender builds it with care, not flash, and you can taste the respect in every sip. A sturdy whiskey backbone, subtle bitters, and citrus perfume come together like a low-key symphony. Held to the window, the drink glows the same color as the sunset ribboning across the lake.
You will want to linger, watching ice crackle as boats draw soft lines on the water. This is the kind of cocktail that encourages conversation and patience. Order one before dinner, then another after dessert, and let the night stretch in that comfortable, well-dressed way.
Walleye Almondine Tribute
Minnesota pride shows up golden and crisp. The walleye flakes beautifully under a toasty almond crown, with browned butter running like a warm whisper across the plate. A lemon squeeze brightens each bite, nodding to lake life without getting too precious.
It is comfort and polish in equal measure, especially with a glass of chilled white. You can taste the kitchen’s respect for a regional classic. If steak is not calling your name, this dish makes a persuasive case for going local and letting the lake write your dinner story.
Prime Rib Saturday Ritual
Saturday feels different when prime rib is involved. A blushing slice arrives tender and generous, ringed with a light crust that hints at slow roasting and patient seasoning. The au jus is savory and clean, while horseradish cream wakes everything up with a pleasant tingle.
Take your time with it. Dip, dab, and let the juices mingle with a buttery side. You dress up a little, lean into tradition, and somehow the night remembers you. It is a ritual that rewards those who show up hungry and ready for classic steakhouse gratification.
Lakeside Booth Ambiance
You slide into a booth and the room softens around you. Candlelight bounces off glassware while the lake throws quiet reflections against the windows. The soundtrack is clinking ice, low laughter, and servers who move with unhurried confidence.
It is romantic without fuss, celebratory without noise. A place where birthdays, proposals, and regular Thursdays all feel worthy of good shoes. When the steak arrives, the setting turns the first cut into a moment. You might come for the food, but the booth turns dinner into memory.
Crab Cakes And Champagne
These crab cakes go heavy on crab and light on filler, which is exactly how they should. The sear is crisp, the interior sweet and delicate, and a lemony aioli ties everything together. One sip of bubbly, and the richness lifts and resets your palate.
It feels celebratory even on a casual night. Share them or do not, but you might regret giving away that last bite. Simple, polished, and quietly indulgent, they set the stage for a steak without crowding the performance.
The Classic Manhattan
This Manhattan leans balanced, neither too sweet nor too stern. The rye gives structure, vermouth adds depth, and the cherry is more garnish than candy. It is the sort of cocktail that earns silence after the first sip.
Sit at the bar for a better view of the craft. Watching the stir, the strain, and the precise pour becomes part of the ritual. By the time your steak hits the table, the world feels a little steadier, and your appetite is perfectly tuned.
Steakhouse Sides To Share
Do not skip the sides. The mashed potatoes are velvet, the gratin is a bubbling blanket of comfort, and asparagus snaps with a garlicky shine. Sharing turns the table into a small celebration, even if it is just you and a friend comparing forkfuls.
Pro tip: let the steak juices mingle with the potatoes for bonus flavor. Everything supports the main event without stealing the spotlight. It is textbook steakhouse harmony, delivered with Midwestern hospitality that makes you feel taken care of.
Sunset Patio Season
When the patio opens, the whole place breathes differently. String lights glow, the lake hushes conversations, and that first breeze tastes like summer. You watch boats drift while the server refreshes your drink and the day unspools into something easy.
It is a perfect pre-dinner spot or a leisurely dessert destination. Snap a photo if you must, but do not forget to just be there. The sunset does the heavy lifting, and the supper club supplies the rest.
Dress-Up Night Done Right
You do not need a tux, but you will want to look sharp. Something about this place invites a little extra effort, and the room answers with grace. When you settle in, it feels like your evening clothes earned their keep.
The effect is subtle but real: better posture, slower bites, longer conversations. A classic supper club respects the ritual of going out, and Bar Harbor keeps that spirit alive. Consider it permission to dress well and eat better.
Reservations And Hours
Plan ahead because prime hours fill up quickly, especially on weekends. The supper club opens at 4 PM Wednesday through Sunday, and rests Monday and Tuesday. Call +1 218-963-2568 or use the website for straightforward booking and current updates.
Showing up prepared means you get the table you want and the timing you prefer. It also lets you build the evening around that steak or walleye craving. A little planning turns good into great.
Wine List With Purpose
The wine list is built to flatter steak and seafood without overwhelming you with options. You can go big with a structured cabernet or keep it light with a crisp chardonnay for walleye. The staff offers easygoing guidance that feels friendly, not fussy.
A good pairing turns a solid dinner into an elevated one. Pause, ask a question, and let them steer you toward the bottle that fits your night. You will taste the difference in every bite and sip.
Date Night Blueprint
Start at the bar with an Old Fashioned, wander to a window table, and split crab cakes before a medium-rare ribeye. Order a bottle that fits your mood, not a rule. Dessert arrives with spoons and a view that feels tailor-made for lingering.
Everything moves at a comfortable pace so conversation can bloom. You will leave feeling unrushed and well cared for, which is the point. It is a date night you can repeat without it feeling repetitive.
Service With Midwest Warmth
Here, hospitality feels natural. Servers anticipate needs without hovering and know the menu like a favorite playlist. Water glasses catch light, bread arrives warm, and timing stays on your side.
Ask for recommendations and you will get honest, thoughtful guidance. It is professional service with neighborly heart, which fits the lakeside setting perfectly. You feel looked after from hello to goodbye.
Dessert By The Water
Save room if you can. A chocolate torte or seasonal cheesecake tends to close the night with satisfying richness and a neat presentation. The lake outside turns into inky glass, and the dining room settles into a low glow.
Sharing is smart, but claiming your own fork has its merits. Coffee or a digestif helps draw the evening to a soft landing. You get that contented feeling where conversation trails off and smiles linger.
Plan A Lakeside Celebration
Birthdays, anniversaries, and small celebrations find a gracious home here. The team helps tailor pacing, wine, and courses so everything feels seamless. A lakeside table adds that little extra magic you cannot manufacture.
Bring your people, dress the part, and let the supper club do what it does best. Good lighting, confident cooking, and polished service take the stress out of hosting. You get to enjoy the toast instead of managing the details.
Discussion about this post