Tucked inside a small strip mall in the Moon Valley neighborhood of Phoenix, Mamma Toledo’s The Pie Hole has quietly built a loyal following that stretches far beyond city limits. With a 4.6-star rating from nearly 500 reviews, this cozy pie shop has earned its reputation one flaky crust at a time.
From dreamy sweet pies to savory quiches that customers rave about, there is something here for every kind of pie lover. Whether you are a longtime local or just passing through Arizona, this is one stop you absolutely cannot miss.
The Legendary Quiches That Started It All
Before most people in Phoenix even knew this little shop existed, word about the quiches at Mamma Toledo’s The Pie Hole was already spreading through the Moon Valley neighborhood like wildfire. Customers who tried them once kept coming back, often making it a weekend ritual.
The quiches are baked fresh with high-quality ingredients, featuring creamy egg fillings tucked inside a perfectly crisp crust. One regular reviewer mentioned keeping a quiche in the fridge overnight and enjoying it the next morning, calling it a standout breakfast experience.
What makes these quiches so special is the balance of flavors — rich but not overwhelming, hearty but not heavy. Whether you grab a slice to enjoy in the cafe or take a whole quiche home, the quality never disappoints.
This is the item that truly put Mamma Toledo’s on the Arizona map.
Chicken Pot Pie That Feels Like a Warm Hug
Ask any regular at Mamma Toledo’s what they order every single visit, and the chicken pot pie will come up almost every time. It has become the shop’s most talked-about savory option, beloved for its thick, creamy filling and irresistibly buttery crust.
One longtime customer described it as their go-to lunch whenever they are anywhere near the Moon Valley area. Another reviewer, a self-proclaimed pie enthusiast, gave it a chef’s kiss and called it one of the best they had ever tasted anywhere.
The filling is generous and satisfying, packed with tender chicken and vegetables in a rich sauce that does not feel overly heavy. The crust holds everything together beautifully without getting soggy.
For anyone who has never experienced a truly great chicken pot pie, this is the one that sets the standard. It is comfort food at its absolute finest.
Coconut Cream Pie Worth Writing Home About
One customer wrote that when his wife brought home a coconut cream pie from Mamma Toledo’s, he literally could not believe how good it was. He grew up with a celebrated pastry cook for a mother, and he still said this was the best coconut cream pie he had ever tasted in his life.
That kind of reaction says everything. The coconut cream pie here is silky smooth, perfectly sweetened, and layered with real coconut flavor that feels authentic rather than artificial.
Multiple reviewers have pointed to it as a standout, noting that it is not cloyingly sweet, which makes it easy to enjoy slice after slice.
The crust slices clean and holds its shape beautifully, which is harder to pull off than most people realize. If you only try one sweet pie at Mamma Toledo’s, let the coconut cream be the one.
You will not regret it.
Banana Cream Pie That Tastes Like Grandma Made It
“It truly tasted like grandma made it” — that is exactly what one customer said after trying the banana cream pie at Mamma Toledo’s for the first time. That single sentence captures everything this pie is meant to be: familiar, comforting, and made with real care.
The homemade crust carries a distinct, old-fashioned flavor that no store-bought version can replicate. Layered with fresh banana and rich vanilla custard, each bite feels like a small trip back to a simpler time.
Customers from out of state have even called ahead to reserve one, not wanting to risk missing out.
The banana cream pie is also available in smaller sizes, making it a great option to share or enjoy solo as a dessert after dinner. Fans of the shop’s food truck have listed it among their top picks.
Once you try it, it becomes a staple order every time you visit.
Pecan Pie That Redefines the Classic
Multiple customers have used the same phrase to describe Mamma Toledo’s pecan pie: the best they have ever had. That is a bold claim for a dessert that has been around for generations, but this shop backs it up with every single slice.
The filling strikes a rare balance between sweet and nutty, with whole pecans sitting in a gooey, caramelized center that is rich without crossing into overpowering territory. The crust provides just enough buttery contrast to keep each bite grounded and satisfying.
One customer specifically called it out as a holiday favorite, planning to order more for upcoming celebrations. Families visiting with young children have also raved about it, making it a crowd-pleaser across all ages.
Whether you are a lifelong pecan pie devotee or someone who has never been fully convinced by the classic, Mamma Toledo’s version might just change your mind completely.
Triple Chocolate Pie for the True Chocolate Lover
Chocolate lovers, this one was made for you. The triple chocolate pie at Mamma Toledo’s brings together three distinct layers of chocolate flavor in a way that feels indulgent without ever tipping into overly rich or sickeningly sweet territory.
One reviewer noted that you can actually taste the difference between each type of chocolate, which speaks to the care and quality ingredients that go into every pie here. It is the kind of dessert that makes you slow down and actually pay attention to what you are eating.
The small size is perfect for sharing with someone special after dinner, though you may find yourself reluctant to hand over your fork. A customer who picked up a mini version alongside a coconut cream pie said both were equally impressive.
For those who live and breathe chocolate, this pie is an experience worth planning your visit around, no question about it.
Key Lime Pie With a Gingersnap Pecan Crust
Some pies play it safe. The key lime pie at Mamma Toledo’s is not one of them.
With a gingersnap pecan crust that adds a crunchy, spiced base, this version of a classic takes a creative turn that customers absolutely love.
The filling is described as tart, silky smooth, and uniquely flavored, with one out-of-state visitor calling it unlike any key lime pie she had tasted before. The crust is firm and crunchy by design, which provides a satisfying contrast to the creamy, bright filling layered on top.
Even the owner has noted that the gingersnap pecan base is intentionally bold, and it has become one of the shop’s most recommended offerings. If you appreciate a pie that takes creative risks and delivers on every one of them, this is your order.
Bring a fork, find a seat in the cozy cafe, and take your time with every bite.
Raspberry Cream Cheese Pie: A Hidden Gem
Not everyone talks about the raspberry cream cheese pie at Mamma Toledo’s, but the ones who have tried it cannot stop thinking about it. One customer grabbed it alongside a banana cream pie for a dessert run and raved about how flaky and buttery the crust was on both.
The combination of tangy cream cheese and bright, fruity raspberry creates a filling that feels elegant and homey at the same time. It is the kind of pie that surprises you — you might not expect to fall in love with it, but one bite changes everything.
This pie works beautifully as a dessert for gatherings or celebrations, and it photographs just as well as it tastes. Mini versions are also available, making it easy to sample alongside other flavors without committing to a full slice.
For anyone looking to branch out from the usual choices, the raspberry cream cheese pie is a truly rewarding pick.
Mini Hand Pies Perfect for Every Occasion
Sometimes you want a little of everything, and that is exactly what the mini hand pies at Mamma Toledo’s allow you to do. Available in a rotating selection of flavors, these single-serving pies are ideal for sampling multiple options without committing to a full-sized pie.
One family visited with four young children and ordered five mini pies, with everyone leaving happy and satisfied. A couple even chose them as the dessert for their wedding, and guests raved about how delicious and beautifully made each one was.
The food truck version of Mamma Toledo’s also exclusively sells these single-serving pies, bringing the magic of the shop to different corners of the Phoenix area. Popular flavors include banana, peanut butter, peach, and apple.
For casual snacking, gifting, or sharing at events, the mini hand pies are one of the most versatile and crowd-pleasing items the shop has to offer.
The Warm, Community-Centered Atmosphere Inside
Walking into Mamma Toledo’s feels like stepping back in time — in the best possible way. One customer described the interior as quaint, like being in a small town forty years ago, with a layout that feels personal and unhurried rather than commercial and rushed.
The shop features a small cafe area with seating, a coffee bar, and a pie display that makes it nearly impossible to walk out empty-handed. The owner, often described as passionate and joyful, sets the tone for an experience that feels warm and genuine from the moment you walk in.
Community matters deeply here. The shop has become a weekend ritual for many Moon Valley families, and the staff treats regulars and first-timers with equal friendliness and care.
There is even a merchandise section where you can take a piece of the Pie Hole spirit home with you. This is more than a bakery — it is a neighborhood gathering place.
How to Order and What to Know Before You Visit
Planning your visit to Mamma Toledo’s The Pie Hole takes just a little bit of preparation, and it is absolutely worth it. The shop is located at 15414 N 7th St Suite 6 in Phoenix, AZ 85022, and is open Tuesday through Friday from 8 AM to 6 PM, Saturday from 8 AM to 6 PM, and Sunday from 8 AM to 4 PM.
Mondays the shop is closed.
Online ordering is available through the website at mammatoledos.com, and it is strongly recommended for special occasions or holiday pies. One customer learned the hard way that holiday orders close as early as mid-October, so planning ahead is key to avoiding disappointment.
You can also call ahead at 602-332-7346 to check on availability or reserve a pie that just came out of the oven. Signing up for the mailing list gives you access to food truck locations and special announcements.
With a little planning, every visit becomes a truly memorable experience.