If you crave comfort food that feels like a Sunday on the farm, Mrs. Yoder’s Kitchen in Mount Hope is calling your name. This beloved Amish-country buffet is famous for broasted chicken, cloud-light mashed potatoes, and a spread that tastes like it came straight from a farmhouse table. Expect warm hospitality, honest prices, and dishes that lean into simple ingredients done right. Come hungry, because seconds are practically guaranteed.
Signature Broasted Chicken
The crispy broasted chicken is the star of the buffet, golden outside and unbelievably juicy inside. Each bite has that perfect crackle followed by tender, well-seasoned meat that tastes like it was cooked in a family kitchen. You will understand why locals call it the best chicken in Ohio.
TrendingNow
Grab a plate fresh from the buffet while it is hot, then pair it with mashed potatoes and gravy. The seasoning is balanced, not too salty, just right for comfort-food cravings. If you only try one thing here, make it this.
Mashed Potatoes And Gravy
These fluffy mashed potatoes taste like a Sunday supper memory. They are creamy, buttery, and just the right amount of rustic, with a smooth gravy that ties everything together. Spoon them next to the broasted chicken and let the flavors mingle.
There is a farm-fresh quality you can taste in every bite. It is comfort without pretense, the kind that makes you go back for a second scoop. If you came for the classics, this bowl delivers.
Creamed Corn Bliss
The creamed corn is rich, slightly sweet, and silky, with kernels that pop with freshness. It tastes like it came straight off an Ohio field and into the pot. Pair it with roast beef or chicken for that comforting, stick-to-your-ribs balance.
It is simple food, perfectly prepared, and it rounds out a plate with nostalgic flavor. You might be tempted to underestimate it, but one spoonful will change your mind. This side quietly steals the show.
Slow-Roasted Beef
The roast beef is tender and savory, with juices that soak into a warm dinner roll. It shreds with a fork and delivers deep, homestyle flavor. The gravy is mellow and beefy, perfect for drizzling over potatoes.
This is the kind of roast that reminds you of family gatherings. It is unfussy, generous, and deeply satisfying. A classic that never disappoints on the buffet line.
Country Noodles And Pot Roast
Thick Amish-style noodles soak up savory broth and mingle beautifully with pieces of pot roast. The texture is soft yet hearty, built for a chilly Ohio day. You will want to ladle on extra gravy for good measure.
It tastes like something grandma would serve without fuss. The flavors are straightforward and comforting, perfect for a second helping. Simple ingredients come together for maximum coziness.
Meatloaf With Farmhouse Glaze
This meatloaf is tender and homey, with a light glaze that leans sweet and tangy. The slice holds together but stays moist, just how it should be. Pair it with corn and a scoop of potatoes for the full comfort lineup.
It is exactly what you want from a country buffet: familiar, flavorful, and generous. No frills, just well-seasoned goodness. One bite and you will be planning a return trip.
Salad Bar Favorites
The salad bar is surprisingly robust, with crisp greens, pickled red eggs, beets, and classic salad fixings. It is fresh, colorful, and a perfect way to balance the comfort-heavy plates. You can keep it light or build a hearty starter.
Fans love the variety and the farmhouse feel of the toppings. Add cottage cheese, crunchy croutons, and a drizzle of house dressing. It sets the tone for a satisfying meal.
Fried Cod And Fish Fridays
When fried cod appears on the buffet, it draws a crowd. The breading is crisp and light, giving way to flaky, mild fish that pairs nicely with tartar sauce. It is a great alternative if you want a break from chicken.
Ask about daily specials so you catch it at its best. With a squeeze of lemon and a side of slaw, it hits all the right notes. Clean flavors, satisfying crunch, repeat-worthy.
BBQ Pork Ribs
These ribs go big on tenderness and smoke-kissed sweetness. The sauce is sticky and savory with just enough tang to keep you chasing another bite. You will want extra napkins, and you will not regret it.
They are a popular feature when they land on the buffet. Put them next to cornbread and a scoop of creamed corn. Suddenly, your plate looks like a backyard cookout in Amish country.
Homemade Pies To-Go
The pies are the kind you dream about on the drive home. Blackberry, coconut cream, and seasonal slices sit in the case, each with flaky crusts and generous filling. If you are too full after the buffet, order a slice to-go.
There is real craft in these desserts, from the whipped topping to the fruit-forward flavor. It is a sweet finish that tastes like a family recipe. Save room if you can, but there is no shame in a take-home box.
Pickled Pantry Treasures
Pickled red eggs and pickled tomatoes bring a bright pop to the plate. They cut through the richness of fried chicken and potatoes with welcome tang. This is a small detail that makes the buffet feel personal and regional.
Layer them onto your salad or nibble between bites of heavier dishes. The colors are vibrant and the flavors memorable. It is a nod to Amish pantry traditions you will not forget.
Warm Rolls And Apple Butter
Nothing says welcome like a basket of warm rolls with soft butter and sweet apple butter. Tear one open and let the steam and aroma hit first. It is simple, comforting, and dangerously easy to refill.
The apple butter adds a spiced, orchard-kissed sweetness that plays well with savory bites. Spread generously or treat it like dessert. Either way, it feels like home on a plate.
Hours, Price, And Planning Tips
Mrs. Yoder’s Kitchen is open Monday through Saturday from 11 AM to 7 PM and closed on Sunday. Prices run about 10 to 20 dollars, which feels fair for the quality and portions. It fills quickly, so arrive near opening or expect a short wait.
Parking can be tight during peak times, but staff keeps things moving. Call +1 330-674-0922 or check the website for current buffet details. A little planning makes the meal even better.
Friendly Service And Local Crowd
The staff keeps things friendly and efficient, even when the dining room is full. Seats turn quickly, and you get that small-town hospitality that makes a meal linger. You will see a mix of Amish and English guests sharing the space.
The vibe is relaxed and real, more like a family kitchen than a tourist stop. It sets the tone for an unpretentious, satisfying experience. You feel taken care of from the first hello to the last refill.
Why It Is Worth The Trip
Between the broasted chicken, creamy sides, and honest prices, this buffet nails the comfort-food brief. It is not flashy, it is simply excellent, and that is the point. You come hungry and leave happy, every time.
The reviews back it up with praise for flavor, value, and that home-cooked feel. Whether you are local or exploring Amish country, put this on your route. It tastes like Sunday on the farm, any day of the week.
Location And How To Get There
You will find the restaurant at 8101 OH-241, Mt Hope, OH 44660, right in the heart of Ohio Amish country. The drive is peaceful, and you will likely share the road with horse and buggies. It adds charm before you even walk in.
Use the coordinates 40.6244121, -81.7855409 for easy navigation. There is a small lot and overflow parking when it gets busy. Plan a midday visit and enjoy the countryside along the way.
Discussion about this post