If you crave a hoagie that feels like a celebration in every bite, you need to know where locals go. Dattilo’s Delicatessen has been packing rolls so generously that fillings spill from edge to edge. You get old school hospitality, house sliced meats, and that unmistakable Philly attitude that keeps lines moving and taste buds loyal. Stick around and discover what to order, when to go, and how to do it right.
The Classic Italian Hoagie
Order the classic Italian and watch the counter crew stack prosciutto, capicola, and soppressata like a friendly challenge. Sharp provolone slides in, then lettuce, tomatoes, onions, oregano, and that signature oil and vinegar. The seeded roll holds firm while every slice kisses the next.
TrendingNow
Ask for light onions if you want the meats to sing louder. The balance is salty, tangy, and bright, with crunch that keeps each bite snappy. You will need both hands and a couple napkins.
This is Dattilo’s in a sandwich: tradition, pace, and pride. Come hungry, leave smiling. And yes, it really is packed wall to wall.
Sharp Provolone Power Move
Sharp provolone fans, this is your playground. Ask for extra sharp and they will shave it so you taste those tiny crystals and nutty bite. It cuts through rich meats and stands tall against oil and vinegar.
The cheese adds backbone, giving the hoagie that assertive Philly swagger. Pair it with spicy capicola and roasted peppers for fire and depth. The finish lingers, savory and slightly peppery.
If you think cheese is an afterthought, this will convert you. It turns a good sandwich into a loud, memorable one. Order confidently, and let the provolone lead.
Seeded Rolls That Never Quit
The roll at Dattilo’s is not a prop. It matters, and you taste it immediately. Sesame seeds add nuttiness while the crust snaps cleanly, giving way to a soft, sturdy interior.
These rolls handle big fillings without collapsing. Every bite stays structured, so flavors stack instead of sliding away. The bread becomes part of the seasoning, not just a container.
If you care about texture, this is your happy place. A proper hoagie starts with a proper roll. Dattilo’s treats it like gospel, and you will too after one crunchy, satisfying bite.
Oil, Vinegar, and Oregano Ritual
The finishing ritual is hypnotic. A measured pour of oil, a bright splash of vinegar, and a snowfall of oregano. It looks simple, but the ratio is everything.
That balance wakes up cured meats and sharp provolone without overpowering them. A little tang lifts the fat, and the herbs add clean fragrance. Ask for extra vinegar if you like a sharper bite.
Watch closely and you will see why locals trust the crew. They hit the same cadence every time. Your hoagie tastes tuned, not drenched, and the last bite is as lively as the first.
Roasted Long Hots Heat
Long hots at Dattilo’s bring that slow, smoky heat Philly craves. They are roasted until tender, kissed with char, then tucked into the fold like a secret. The spice creeps, not blasts.
Add them to an Italian or turkey and watch the flavor climb. Their bitterness and burn cut fat and brighten every chew. Ask for a little oil to carry the pepper flavor through the roll.
If you like heat with character, this is your move. Not reckless, just confident. You will finish the sandwich faster than you planned, chasing that glow.
Turkey Italiano Upgrade
When you want lighter but still crave bold, go Turkey Italiano. House roasted turkey gets stacked high with sharp provolone, roasted peppers, lettuce, tomatoes, and the same oil vinegar magic. It is clean yet satisfying.
The turkey stays juicy, not watery, and the peppers add sweetness and smoke. Oregano pulls everything together. Ask for thin onions if you want extra snap.
This combo lets you taste every layer without heaviness. It works for lunch when you still have a busy afternoon ahead. You will finish refreshed and ready, not weighed down.
Prosciutto and Fresh Mozzarella Moment
Prosciutto meets fresh mozzarella and time slows down. Thin, silky slices melt into cool, milky cheese while tomatoes and basil lift the palate. Ask for a light oil drizzle and a whisper of vinegar.
The contrast is what makes it special. Salty, creamy, bright, and herbaceous, all wrapped in that seeded crunch. It tastes like summer, even in February.
If you want elegance inside a hoagie, this is the lane. No heavy sauces, just quality speaking clearly. You will take smaller bites to make it last.
Cutlet Day: Chicken Parm
When the cutlets hit the case, the deli hum shifts. Chicken parm lands with a crisp shell, tender center, and a marinara that hugs rather than drowns. Melted mozzarella blankets the whole build.
It is comfort food with a Philly edge, substantial yet balanced. Ask for extra grated cheese and a touch of crushed red pepper if you like heat. The roll soaks just enough sauce to get savory.
You will taste crunch, tang, and cream in every bite. Perfect for a cold day or when you need a hug. Get there early, because cutlets move fast.
Sicilian Tuna with Bite
This is not bland tuna salad. Dattilo’s Sicilian style tuna brings olive oil richness, capers, celery crunch, and a little lemon pop. It spreads beautifully across the roll without getting soggy.
Add sharp provolone for contrast and a few long hots if you like heat. The flavor is savory and coastal, not mayo heavy. Each bite feels clean and lively.
Great for warm days or when you want a break from cured meats. You will not miss the deli classics, promise. This one deserves more hype than it gets.
Sunday Hours Strategy
Sunday runs are clutch, but hours are shorter. Doors open at 8:30 AM and close at 2 PM, so plan early. Grab a coffee, hit the counter by mid morning, and avoid the last minute rush.
Call ahead if you are ordering for a game day spread. The team moves fast, but lines build because locals know the drill. You will leave with hoagies still warm from slicing.
Philly does Sunday right with sandwiches on the table. Dattilo’s keeps the tradition alive. Show up prepared and you will eat like a champion.
Grocery Gem Add ons
Beyond hoagies, the grocery selection is a quiet superpower. Snag San Marzano tomatoes, quality olive oil, pasta, and jarred peppers for home cooking. You can rebuild your favorite flavors in your own kitchen.
Pick up sliced meats and cheeses by the pound for later. The same quality you taste in the sandwich goes into your fridge. It is value that stretches beyond one meal.
Grab a cookie or cannoli on your way out if they are in stock. Little treats complete the visit. You will thank yourself after dinner.
House Sliced to Order
Watching the slicer at Dattilo’s is part of the show. They cut meats to order, dialing thickness so each bite lands just right. Thin for prosciutto, a touch thicker for ham or turkey.
That precision means texture never fights flavor. Instead, it layers, folds, and melts into the roll. Ask questions and the staff will guide you without fuss.
You leave knowing someone paid attention to your lunch. It is old school care in a fast moving world. The difference is obvious from the first bite to the crumbs.
The Wall to Wall Build
Locals are not exaggerating about wall to wall. Fillings reach the edges so every bite is prime real estate. No barren bread zones, just flavor from end to end.
It makes sharing easier too, since halves feel equal and generous. The wrap is tight, keeping structure without squeezing life out. Unwrap at home and the sandwich still stands tall.
That consistency keeps people coming back. You know what you are getting, every time. A hoagie built with intention, not shortcuts.
Game Day Party Tray
Feeding a crowd The party tray is your best friend. Mix Italians, turkey, tuna, and cutlet halves so everyone wins. Call ahead to lock timing, especially on Fridays and Saturdays.
The hoagies arrive tight wrapped and labeled, ready for quick setup. Add a tub of roasted peppers and a side of long hots for extra flair. Napkins are not optional here.
Set it out and watch the room go quiet for a minute. Good sandwiches do that. Your only regret will be underestimating how fast they disappear.
First Timer Ordering Tips
New here Take a breath, scan the board, and decide your bread, meats, and heat level. Keep your order clear and your phone ready if you are reading notes. The crew appreciates speed.
Ask for recommendations and they will happily steer you. If you want classic Philly style, say oil, vinegar, oregano. Want heat Say long hots.
Pay, step aside, and watch the magic. You will hear your name fast, even during rush. Then step out and claim a curbside bite like a local.
Discussion about this post