If you have a sweet tooth in Greenville, you have probably heard whispers about a bakery that has been delighting locals since 1947. At Strossner’s Bakery, Cafe & Deli, the cases sparkle with nostalgic layer cakes, cream pies, and pastries that taste like memory and celebration. Step inside for friendly guidance, a calm atmosphere, and a menu that makes it impossible to pick just one treat. Here is your guide to the classics and can’t miss favorites people keep coming back for.
Signature Red Velvet Layer Cake
Strossner’s red velvet is the cake you order when the celebration really matters. The crumb is tender and vibrant, with that subtle cocoa whisper Southerners expect, and the cream cheese frosting lands perfectly balanced, not too sweet. Slice it thin or thick, the layers hold beautifully for photos and seconds.
TrendingNow
Staff will box it carefully, and you can add writing for birthdays or weddings without fuss. Paired with coffee from the cafe, each bite tastes like Greenville tradition. If you have guests, this cake turns into a conversation starter, and leftovers store well.
Pro tip: ask about size options and preordering for weekend pickups. You will thank yourself later when the case gets busy.
Classic Coconut Layer Cake
This coconut layer cake is a showstopper with a fluffy crumb and generous snowfall of coconut flakes across silky frosting. Every forkful feels light and lush, offering tropical notes without overwhelming sweetness. It is the kind of cake you bring to a family table and watch disappear.
Order ahead for holidays, because coconut goes fast when relatives are in town. The team at Strossner’s can inscribe a simple message, then tuck the cake into a sturdy box for an easy ride home. It travels well for picnics or office parties.
Pair with hot tea or a latte from the cafe to highlight the vanilla and coconut aroma. You will likely decide on an extra slice for breakfast.
Chocolate Peppermint Holiday Cake
When the holidays roll in, Strossner’s chocolate peppermint cake hits the sweet spot between cozy and refreshing. Deep cocoa layers meet a cool peppermint buttercream, finished with a playful sprinkle of crushed candy canes. It looks like a postcard on a plate and tastes even better.
If you remember the review about their Christmas cake, this is that kind of memory maker. Plan ahead, because seasonal cakes tend to sell quickly on December weekends. The staff will guide you through sizes so there is enough for everyone.
Serve chilled for a firmer bite or room temperature for a softer crumb. Either way, the mint aroma floats through the room and signals dessert time.
Creamy Banana Cream Pie
Strossner’s banana cream pie brings comfort by the slice. The custard is smooth and custardy, layered with bananas that taste fresh, not syrupy, and crowned with whipped cream that holds its shape. The crust stays crisp, adding a gentle buttery crunch.
It is ideal for weeknight dessert or after a deli lunch when you just want something creamy. Grab a whole pie for gatherings and keep it chilled until serving. The flavor intensifies slightly after a day, so leftovers are delightful.
Ask the counter team for a pie server and extra napkins if you are taking it to the park. One bite and you will understand why locals call this place Greenville’s sweet tooth.
Silky Chocolate Cream Pie
This chocolate cream pie is all silk and shine. The filling is lush, with a cocoa depth that feels indulgent but never heavy, and the whipped topping keeps each bite cloud light. Chocolate curls on top add a pretty flourish that makes serving feel special.
Order a slice to follow a soup and half sandwich lunch, or take home an entire pie for an evening treat. The crust is sturdy enough to slice cleanly, which makes presentation easy. It is a solid crowd pleaser for mixed palates.
Pair with hot coffee to amplify the chocolate notes. If you like a chilled snap, pop it in the fridge until guests arrive, then slice confidently.
Old-Fashioned White Cake
Light, sweet, and nostalgic, the white cake at Strossner’s is a hometown favorite. The crumb feels airy with a fine, classic texture, and the frosting hits that bakery sweet spot fans rave about. It is the cake you pick for showers, anniversaries, and just because.
Customize with pastel roses or a short message, and the team will make it camera ready. If you prefer a lighter frosting touch, ask for a thin coat and extra decor on the side. The cake slices cleanly into tidy layers for serving.
Enjoy with fresh berries to brighten the vanilla. Leftovers stay moist wrapped tightly, making this a perfect next day breakfast slice when nobody is looking.
Custom Wedding Cakes
Strossner’s wedding cakes earn compliments that linger long after the last dance. Choose buttercream or fondant, classic piping or modern textures, and flavors that range from vanilla bean to almond or red velvet. Tastings are collaborative and friendly, guiding you toward a design that feels like your story.
Their team handles delivery and setup with calm precision, which keeps your day stress free. If you want floral accents, they coordinate neatly with your florist. Guests often ask where the cake came from, which is the best review.
Schedule early for peak seasons, especially spring and fall. Bring inspiration photos and a guest estimate, and let them translate your vision into beautiful, delicious tiers that slice perfectly for photos.
Birthday Cakes To Order
When birthdays pop up, Strossner’s makes ordering effortless. Call ahead or stop by, choose a size, and add a personalized message that looks neat and festive. Popular flavors include red velvet, chocolate, coconut, and classic white, with fillings that can be tailored.
If you need same day options, ask about ready to go case cakes. Staff are patient and will walk you through designs without rushing. Boxed securely, the cakes ride safely to restaurants, offices, or home parties.
Pick up candles and a knife if you are celebrating on the go. The result is a cake that tastes like a happy memory and looks great in photos, which is exactly what a birthday deserves.
Cafe Lunch: Chicken Salad Sandwich
Locals swear by the chicken salad sandwich, and it is easy to see why. The salad is lightly dressed, studded with tender chicken and a gentle crunch, piled onto fresh baked bread that makes the whole thing sing. It is comfort food without the heaviness.
Pair it with a cup of broccoli cheddar soup for a cozy combo on cool days. Portions are generous, and service feels calm and kind. If you are indecisive, the half sandwich option is perfect so you can save room for dessert.
Grab a cookie for the road and call it balance. This lunch is exactly what a bakery cafe should deliver: simple, satisfying, and made with care.
Soup and Half Sandwich Combo
The soup and half sandwich combo hits a perfect midday rhythm. Broccoli cheddar arrives creamy and smooth, with a gentle bite of cheddar that warms you up. Pair it with turkey, ham and cheese, or chicken salad on freshly baked bread, and you are set.
It is quick, reasonably priced, and friendly to tight schedules. Staff bring out trays promptly, and you can slide right into the bakery line for dessert. The combo lets you taste the deli side without skipping sweets.
On chilly afternoons, snag a window seat and watch the steady hum of locals. Finish with a pie slice or a petite cake round for a complete Greenville lunch ritual.
Assorted Pastry Sampler Box
When choosing feels impossible, the sampler box saves the day. Mix danishes, brownies, cookies, and petit fours into a portable parade of treats, perfect for office drop offs or weekend guests. Every bite shows the bakery’s range from buttery to fudgy to delicately iced.
Ask staff for guidance if you need nut free or kid friendly picks. The box travels well and looks generous on a brunch table. Leftovers keep nicely for a next day coffee pairing.
You will discover new favorites without committing to a single pastry. This is also a smart way to preview items before ordering larger quantities for parties. Expect smiles when you open the lid at home.
Petit Fours and Special Occasions
Strossner’s petit fours are tiny celebrations wrapped in neat icing. Beneath the glossy finish are soft cake layers and a whisper of filling that pairs with tea or champagne. They look elegant on dessert tables for showers or open houses.
You can order by the dozen with color themes that match your event. Staff package them carefully so edges stay sharp and icing stays flawless. Display on tiered trays for easy grabbing and pretty photos.
These little squares also make thoughtful thank you gifts. Add a handwritten card, and you have a sweet gesture that feels considered. They are proof that small bites can deliver big happiness.
Breakfast Pastries and Coffee
Mornings at Strossner’s feel like a neighborhood ritual. Croissants, danishes, and muffins arrive with that just baked aroma that pairs naturally with a hot latte. Grab and go is easy, but there is something soothing about sitting down for a quiet start.
If you have an early meeting, call ahead and box a dozen mixed pastries. The variety satisfies chocolate lovers and fruit fans alike. Prices are friendly, and the quality makes it feel like a treat.
Settle by the window and watch the bakery get into its stride. A flaky pastry plus coffee is a simple formula, yet it can turn an ordinary morning around quickly.
Holiday Preorders and Pickup Tips
Holiday weeks bring lines, but Strossner’s has a smooth system. Place preorders early, confirm pickup time, and head to the counter when your name is called. Staff are efficient and kind, guiding you through last minute additions without pressure.
Transport cakes on a flat trunk space and keep pies chilled if custard based. Ask for extra supports if you are driving far. A simple checklist avoids party day mishaps and keeps dessert photo ready.
If you forgot to order, do not panic. The case still holds plenty of beautiful options, and the team will help you choose quickly. You will walk out confident, even on the busiest days.
Pricing, Hours, and Planning
Open Monday through Saturday with varied morning start times, Strossner’s keeps things convenient for workday coffee and weekend cake pickups. Most treats fall into the approachable 10 to 20 dollar range, depending on size and customization. The steady 4.5 star reputation signals consistency and care.
Call +1 864-233-3996 or check the website for seasonal menus, deli specials, and cake lead times. Parking is straightforward, and the atmosphere stays calm even when the line looks long. Staff guide you at the case so you never feel rushed.
Plan ahead for large events and wedding consultations. Whether you are craving lunch or dessert, you will find Greenville hospitality baked right in at 21 Roper Mountain Rd.
Customer Service and Atmosphere
The vibe at Strossner’s is unpretentious and welcoming. Even when the line stretches, staff move with purpose, calling customers to the case and answering questions patiently. You will feel taken care of, which makes selecting treats more fun.
Reviews often mention how calm the dining room feels, ideal for sandwiches and a quiet chat. It is a place where regulars and first timers both feel comfortable. The display cases sparkle, showing off cakes, pies, and pastries like little gifts.
On busy Saturdays, bring curiosity and a few minutes to explore. Let the team guide you toward something new, then sit and enjoy Greenville’s sweet tradition that has lasted since 1947.
Discussion about this post