If you crave a classic Wisconsin supper club that nails the details, Mark’s East Side in Appleton feels like coming home. Prime rib that cuts like butter, Old Fashioneds mixed just right, and a warm German American touch keep locals returning decade after decade. The family run vibe, fair prices, and friendly bartenders make it easy to settle in for the evening. Bring your appetite and a friend you love to impress.
Prime Rib Tradition
Prime rib at Mark’s East Side is a rite of passage. The cut arrives rosy and glistening, with a savory crust that hints at careful seasoning and slow roasting. You will taste that classic supper club comfort in every bite, especially dipped into rich au jus with a side of cool horseradish.
TrendingNow
Choose a baked potato, maybe sour cream and chives, or go old school with hash browns. Servers guide you without fuss, making sure your plate lands hot and exactly how you asked. Bring a friend who loves hearty plates, because the portions are generous and the vibes are welcoming.
Old Fashioned, Wisconsin Style
Order a brandy Old Fashioned and watch the ritual unfold. The bartender muddles fruit, adds bitters, a touch of sugar, then tops with soda to your preference sweet, sour, or press. The glass arrives chilled, fragrant, and balanced, exactly how locals swear it should be.
Pair the drink with a relish tray or the Friday fish fry for the full experience. If you like it drier or boozier, just say the word and they will tune it perfectly. One sip, and the whole supper club night opens up, friendly and unpretentious.
German American Comforts
Mark’s East Side leans into its German roots with honest, satisfying plates. Think pork schnitzel crisp outside and tender within, spätzle tossed with gravy, and tangy red cabbage that brightens the whole plate. You will find other nods too, from sausages to gravies that taste lovingly simmered.
It is the kind of menu that invites sampling across the table. Share bites, swap sauces, and do not skip a squeeze of lemon over that schnitzel. When hunger meets nostalgia, this kitchen delivers comfort without pretense or shortcuts.
The Relish Tray Welcome
A proper supper club evening starts with a relish tray, and Mark’s East Side keeps the tradition alive. Crisp pickles, olives, celery, and radishes wake up your palate while drinks arrive. It is simple hospitality, a small gesture that says you are among friends.
Nibble while deciding between prime rib or schnitzel, maybe both if you are sharing. The tray sets an easy pace, encouraging conversation and a second Old Fashioned. Traditions like this do not fade because they make guests feel cared for from the first moment.
Friday Fish Fry Ritual
Friday nights at Mark’s East Side mean crispy fish fry done the classic Wisconsin way. Expect flaky fillets with a golden coat, rye bread and coleslaw, plus your choice of potato. Potato pancakes with applesauce hit that nostalgic note, especially alongside a brandy Old Fashioned.
Service hums with familiar rhythm, and the bar glows with locals catching up. If you are new, the staff makes ordering effortless, guiding you to favorites without any fuss. It is comfort food that feels communal, week after week.
Schnitzel Night Favorite
Pork schnitzel at Mark’s East Side is crisp, thin, and deeply satisfying. Each cutlet lands with a golden crunch, inviting a bright squeeze of lemon. Ask for mushroom gravy if you like it saucy, then pair with spätzle and sweet sour red cabbage.
A cold German beer ties the flavors together without crowding the plate. This is comfort food with heritage, built on careful technique and good ingredients. If you love leftovers, you might plan for them, because portions are generous and travel well the next day.
Cozy Supper Club Atmosphere
Step inside and the lighting softens, voices mingle, and time slows in the best way. Wood paneling, comfortable booths, and a friendly bar set a relaxed mood. It feels timeless, like the kind of place where anniversaries and Tuesday dinners both fit.
You will notice servers greeting regulars by name, but newcomers get the same warmth. Grab a booth if you like to linger or sit at the bar to chat. Either way, the hospitality is steady and sincere, keeping the supper club spirit alive.
Lunch at 11 AM
On Tuesdays, Wednesdays, and Fridays, doors open at 11 AM for lunch. It is a perfect window for a relaxed midday bite, whether you want soup and sandwich or a lighter German plate. The staff keeps service quick without rushing you, ideal for work breaks.
Menus still carry comforting touches, and portions remain generous even at lunch. If you plan ahead, you beat the evening rush and still enjoy the same hospitality. Appleton locals know this trick, and now you do too.
Beer List with German Roots
Beer drinkers have it good here, with German styles that fit the menu perfectly. A crisp pilsner clears the palate after schnitzel, while a malty lager hugs the prime rib. Ask the bartender for pairing suggestions, they know what sings with each dish.
Steins and pints arrive cold, no nonsense and refreshing. If cocktails are your thing, you can still sneak a half pint to sip between bites. The list reflects heritage without being fussy, just well chosen and crowd pleasing.
Family Run Hospitality
There is a family heartbeat at Mark’s East Side that you feel right away. Staff move with purpose and kindness, like hosts rather than clock watchers. The result is smoother service and small thoughtful touches, from check ins to refills before you ask.
Regulars trade stories with servers, and newcomers quickly join the conversation. That sense of belonging might be the secret ingredient behind the food. When people care, you taste it, and it keeps you coming back.
Price Point and Value
Prices sit comfortably in the mid range, which feels fair for the portions and quality. A prime rib dinner, a cocktail, and sides will not break the budget. You walk out full, happy, and confident you got true value for your night out.
It is why locals celebrate milestones here and still pop in on an ordinary Friday. The consistency matters, and so does the service. When a place respects your wallet and your time, it earns loyal fans.
Reservations and Busy Nights
On weekends or prime hours, the dining room fills fast. A quick reservation can save you a wait, especially if your group is larger. If you do land at the bar first, consider it a bonus round for Old Fashioneds.
Staff keep the line moving with calm efficiency and clear communication. You will feel looked after even before you sit. The buzz adds to the charm, turning dinner into an occasion without any fuss.
Seasonal and Holiday Touches
Holidays and seasonal moments bring extra warmth to Mark’s East Side. Twinkle lights and thoughtful specials make winter evenings glow. In summer, the mood is lighter, but the hospitality stays steady and kind.
Ask about limited time dishes or desserts that nod to the season. You get familiarity with a spark of surprise, perfect for date nights or family gatherings. Traditions evolve gently here, never losing the dependable core that regulars love.
Appleton Local Favorite
Located at 1405 E Wisconsin Ave, Mark’s East Side sits comfortably within Appleton’s everyday rhythms. Locals treat it like a trusted friend, a place to celebrate, commiserate, or simply eat well. Reviews reflect that steady 4.6 star glow earned over years of good nights.
Walk in and you will see families, couples, and coworkers sharing the room with easy camaraderie. That mix of guests says a lot about the restaurant’s balance. It feels special without trying too hard.
When To Go
Planning around hours makes the experience smoother. Tuesday and Wednesday run 11 AM to 8:30 PM, Friday 11 AM to 9:30 PM, Saturday 4 to 9:30 PM, while Sunday, Monday, and Thursday are closed. Aim early for lunch or a slightly later dinner to miss the rush.
If you like lingering, Saturday evenings feel festive without being overwhelming. A well timed arrival means more time to enjoy dessert and a nightcap. Simple planning turns a good meal into a relaxed occasion.
How To Make The Most Of It
Start with a brandy Old Fashioned, then share a relish tray while you decide on mains. Consider splitting prime rib and schnitzel so you taste both traditions. Add a side of potato pancakes if it is Friday, or spätzle on any night.
Save room for dessert if you can, and chat with your server for insider picks. Bring someone who appreciates old school charm and honest cooking. You will leave full, content, and already planning the next visit.
Discussion about this post