If you have a soft spot for old school charm, Silvercryst Supper Club Resort & Motel in Wautoma might be your happy place. Think sizzling steaks, buttery seafood, and a lakeside lodge vibe that makes Friday feel like a mini vacation. Locals swear it is a throwback weekend the moment you step inside, with cocktails, live tunes, and gracious service. Come hungry, stay a while, and let the nostalgia do the rest.
The Classic Friday Fish Fry
Nothing says Wisconsin weekend like a classic fish fry, and Silvercryst nails it with crispy perch and walleye. You get golden fillets, a squeeze of lemon, tangy tartar, and rye bread on the side. The hushpuppies crunch, the slaw cools, and suddenly the week melts away.
TrendingNow
Slide into a wood backed booth, sip an old fashioned, and watch the dining room bustle. There is chatter about fishing and Packers scores, and that soft clink of ice. You feel like a regular, even on your first visit.
Service moves with friendly rhythm, refilling drinks without fuss. Portions satisfy without overdoing it. Save room for dessert if you can.
Hand Cut Ribeye on the Grill
The ribeye at Silvercryst is the steakhouse promise fulfilled. Thick, juicy, and hand cut, it lands with that satisfying sear you can smell before you see it. Butter glosses the top while the knife glides through like a quiet drumroll.
You choose your doneness, then add classic sides like a loaded baked potato or buttery mushrooms. Each bite has that smoky kiss from the grill. It is the kind of steak that slows conversation and lifts eyebrows.
Pair it with a brandy old fashioned sweet, because you are in Wisconsin. The staff checks the temp, then lets you enjoy. Leave content, not rushed.
Buttery Lobster Tail and Drawn Butter
Seafood lovers get spoiled with the lobster tail at Silvercryst. It is broiled to a gentle tenderness, then served with warm drawn butter that perfumes the plate. A squeeze of lemon brightens every luxurious bite.
The portion feels right for date night indulgence or a celebratory dinner. You can add a petite steak for a surf and turf moment that makes the meal feel epic. The plating is simple and classic, letting the sweet meat shine.
Servers anticipate what you need without hovering. Order a crisp white wine or a cold beer for balance. You will remember this one on the drive home.
Supreme Surf and Turf Combo
When you cannot decide between steak and seafood, Silvercryst solves it with a polished surf and turf. A tender steak sits beside a buttery lobster tail, both steaming and irresistible. Garlic herb butter melts into a glossy sauce that ties everything together.
This combo comes with classic sides that feel cozy but never fussy. Expect attentive pacing so your steak stays warm and your lobster does not overcook. The result is a throwback luxury that still feels fresh.
Split it or savor it solo, either way you win. Ask for wine suggestions if you like guidance. You will leave feeling treated, not teased.
Iconic Brandy Old Fashioned Sweet
Walk into the bar at Silvercryst and you will see a parade of brandy old fashioned sweets. It is muddled just right, with orange, cherry, and a touch of bitters, then topped with soda. Balanced, bright, and nostalgic, it sets the tone for the evening.
Bartenders keep the conversation flowing while ice clinks in heavy rocks glasses. You can switch to sour if that is your style. Either way, the drink tastes like northern Wisconsin weekends.
Sip slowly and watch the dining room glow. It pairs beautifully with fried fish, steak, or shrimp. Grab a bar stool, breathe, and settle in.
Lakeside Lodge Atmosphere
Silvercryst’s lodge ambiance is half the magic. Warm wood, stone accents, and little nods to lake life make it feel like vacation the minute you arrive. The glow off the lamps turns conversations into whispers and laughter.
Windows hint at the water beyond, and you can almost smell pine even indoors. It is casual but elevated, the kind of place where jeans and a nice sweater feel perfect. Staff moves with practiced ease, adding to the comfort.
You settle into the hush of a room filled with stories. The setting makes food taste better without trying. That is the supper club secret.
Live Entertainment Nights
On select nights, live entertainment turns dinner into an easygoing show. Local musicians play acoustic favorites that fit the room like a well worn flannel. You catch yourself humming between bites of steak and shrimp.
The volume stays conversation friendly, so you never feel drowned out. It adds rhythm to the pacing, drinks, and dessert decisions. Servers time courses around sets with a smile.
Order another round and relax into the evening. The music makes date nights feel cinematic and family outings more memorable. It is simple, genuine fun.
Comfortable Motel Rooms
Make the night last by booking a room at the attached motel. It is simple, clean, and conveniently close to all the food and fun. After a big dinner, walking to your room is the best kind of luxury.
Amenities like free Wi Fi, air conditioning, and pet friendly options make stays easy. Families appreciate kid friendly touches and the relaxed setting. It feels retro in the best way, with modern comforts where they matter.
Wake up rested, grab coffee, and plan another lake day. You will be back for breakfast thoughts or dinner dreams. Staying here stretches the weekend.
Pool and Relaxation Perks
Between meals, the pool is a refreshing reset. Grab a lounge chair, lean back, and let the Wisconsin sky do its calming work. Families love the easy energy while couples carve out quiet corners.
It fits the throwback vibe, like summer camp for grown ups with better snacks. Free parking and Wi Fi mean you come and go without stress. Everything is designed to make unwinding feel natural.
After a swim, drift back to the bar for an afternoon cocktail. Then plan your next plate of shrimp or steak. The day stretches in the nicest way.
Kid Friendly Dining Done Right
Silvercryst makes families feel welcome without dumbing down the experience. Kids can dig into crispy chicken tenders or simple pastas while adults enjoy ribeye and lobster. The vibe stays relaxed, never rushed, and everyone gets fed well.
High chairs, patient servers, and space between tables make dining with little ones easier. You can actually finish a conversation while the kids color. It feels like the supper club your grandparents trusted, and you will too.
Cap it with ice cream or a shared dessert. The memory sticks around longer than screen time. That is worth the drive.
Pet Friendly Stays and Walks
Traveling with a pup gets easier at Silvercryst’s pet friendly motel. Check in, drop your bags, and take a quick walk under tall pines. Your dog will be sniffing happily while you soak in the fresh air.
Rooms keep it comfortable and practical, so you can relax without worry. The property layout makes late night walks simple. Bring treats, enjoy the calm, and plan tomorrow’s adventures around meals.
It is a relief when hospitality includes pets rather than tolerates them. You feel welcome from the start. That makes every stay smoother.
Free Wi Fi and Easy Parking
Details matter on a weekend getaway, and Silvercryst gets them right. Free Wi Fi means you can check maps, share photos, or stream after dinner. Parking is plentiful and close, so arriving never feels like a hassle.
These little conveniences stack up, especially for families and groups. You spend time where you want to, not tracking logistics. That leaves more room for steaks, shrimp, and late night conversations.
Settle in, connect, and forget worry. When it is time to head out, everything is simple. The relaxed experience starts in the lot.
Smoke Free, Air Conditioned Comfort
Comfort is baked into the Silvercryst routine. Dining rooms and rooms are smoke free, which keeps the air clean and appetites focused. Air conditioning keeps summer humidity from stealing your energy.
It is the kind of invisible hospitality you notice only when it is missing elsewhere. Here, you simply feel good and stay longer. That comfort turns one course into three without effort.
Order the soup, linger over dessert, enjoy another drink. You are not battling the room, just savoring the moment. Simple, thoughtful, and appreciated.
Airport Shuttle and Easy Access
If you are flying in or meeting friends from out of town, the airport shuttle is a helpful perk. It smooths the logistics so meals take center stage. No one argues about directions when dinner smells this good.
Call ahead to coordinate timing and confirm availability. The team is practical, friendly, and focused on making your trip seamless. You will land, ride, check in, and be seated with a drink before long.
It keeps the weekend easy and unhurried. That is the Silvercryst way. Food first, stress last.
Fitness Center for Morning Reset
After a hearty supper club feast, a quick morning workout feels right. Silvercryst’s fitness center is small but handy, with treadmills, an elliptical, and free weights. It is exactly what you need to shake off last night’s butter.
Grab a towel, cue a playlist, and keep it short. You are on vacation, not training for a marathon. The point is balance, not bragging rights.
Afterward, coffee tastes better and appetite returns in time for lunch. That means more steak, seafood, or a return to the fish fry. Your weekend rhythm resets nicely.
Planning Your Visit
Set your GPS to w7015 WI 21, Wautoma, and make a reservation if you are coming on a weekend. Check hours on silvercryst.com and glance at recent reviews for fresh tips. The rating sits strong because the experience delivers.
Call +1 920 787 3367 with special requests, from pet friendly rooms to celebration desserts. Mention timing if you want live music. Staff will guide you without any pressure.
Arrive hungry, bring good company, and plan to linger. Silvercryst turns dinner into a mini vacation. That is the whole point of a Wisconsin supper club.
Discussion about this post