Pennsylvania takes its perogies seriously, and some of the best ones never show up in a restaurant at all. They come from church kitchens, where volunteers gather to pinch, boil, and pack thousands of these little dumplings by hand.
Many of these sales happen on set days, so locals know to call ahead or show up early before the batch sells out. If you love comfort food with a side of community, this list is worth saving.
1. St. Nicholas Ukrainian Catholic Church Perogy Sale, Millville, New Jersey area tradition in Pennsylvania
Ukrainian Catholic parishes across Pennsylvania have long been known for handmade dumplings, and St. Nicholas continues that tradition with regular perogy sales.
The classic potato and cheese filling is the star, made in batches by volunteers who have been rolling dough for years.
Orders are usually placed ahead of time, and pickup happens on scheduled days. If you want to guarantee your dozen, calling the parish office first is the smart move.
2. St. Mary Byzantine Catholic Church, McKees Rocks, Pennsylvania
McKees Rocks sits in the heart of Pittsburgh’s Eastern European roots, and St. Mary Byzantine has kept the perogy tradition alive for generations.
The kitchen crew produces potato and cheese dumplings in large quantities, especially heading into holiday seasons when demand climbs.
Sales here often run on Fridays during Lent, which is when many local Pennsylvania churches ramp up production. Pre-ordering by phone is the usual way to lock in your dozen before they are gone.
3. St. John the Baptist Ukrainian Catholic Church, Whitehall, Pennsylvania
Whitehall, near Allentown, is home to a Ukrainian parish that has built a loyal following for its handmade dumplings.
Volunteers gather regularly to prepare potato and cheese perogies, and the sales help support the parish while feeding hungry neighbors.
Pickup dates are typically posted in advance, and the batches move quickly once word gets out. Placing an order early is the safest bet if you are counting on a full tray for the family.
4. Holy Trinity Ukrainian Orthodox Church, Carnegie, Pennsylvania
Carnegie has deep Eastern European heritage, and Holy Trinity’s kitchen reflects that history with every batch.
The parish is known for potato and cheese perogies made the traditional way, with dough rolled and filled by hand.
Regular sales draw steady crowds from around the Pittsburgh area, and many customers return month after month. Ordering ahead helps the volunteers plan their production and ensures you do not leave empty handed.
5. St. Vladimir Ukrainian Orthodox Church, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
Pittsburgh may be famous for many foods, but for a lot of families the perogy reigns supreme, and St. Vladimir helps keep that love alive.
The church community turns out handmade potato and cheese dumplings that customers grab by the dozen.
Sales here tend to follow a set schedule, so checking the parish calendar or calling ahead makes the trip worth it. The dumplings are typically sold ready to boil at home, which lets you serve them fresh.
6. St. Josaphat Ukrainian Catholic Church, Bethlehem, Pennsylvania
Bethlehem’s blend of steel-town history and immigrant roots shows up in unexpected places, including the perogy kitchen at St. Josaphat.
Parish volunteers prepare dumplings by hand, keeping the classic potato and cheese filling front and center.
The Lehigh Valley has a strong appetite for these sales, and regulars know to reserve early. A quick call to the parish is usually all it takes to add your name to the pickup list.
7. St. Michael Ukrainian Catholic Church, Shenandoah, Pennsylvania
Shenandoah, deep in Pennsylvania’s coal region, has one of the strongest Eastern European legacies in the state, and food is a big part of it.
St. Michael carries that tradition forward with perogy sales that pull in customers from across Schuylkill County.
The potato and cheese variety is the standard favorite, made in the same hands-on style families have used for decades. Given how quickly these sell in a town that loves them, ordering ahead is strongly encouraged.
8. Assumption of the Blessed Virgin Mary Ukrainian Catholic Church, Perth Amboy tradition serving Pennsylvania families
Holiday seasons bring a surge in perogy demand, and Ukrainian parishes like this one answer the call with major production runs.
The kitchen focuses on the beloved potato and cheese filling, packaged by the dozen for easy pickup and cooking at home.
Many Pennsylvania families make these sales an annual tradition, especially around Christmas and Easter. Because the volunteer crews can only make so many, placing your order early is the difference between a full table and a sold-out sign.
If you have never turned a church perogy sale into a road trip, this is a fine reason to start.
Enjoyed this story?
Add Fast Food Club as a preferred source to see more of our reporting on Google.