Some towns are known for a bridge or a ballpark. One small borough just outside Scranton is known for pizza that comes in rectangles and gets sold by the cut, not the slice.
People have flown in from California and driven in from Connecticut just to pick up boxes of it. Folks in Ohio order it online and have it shipped to their door.
At the center of that loyalty sits a family kitchen that has been turning out trays since 1938, long before most pizza chains existed. Its white pies have fans, its red pies have fans, and the debate between the two may never end.
Keep reading to learn where it is, what to order, how the takeout setup works, and why one stop here rarely stays a one-time thing.
A Pizza Landmark on South Main Street

Every pizza pilgrimage needs a destination, and this one ends at Arcaro and Genell, 443 S Main St, Old Forge, PA 18518, in the United States.
Old Forge sits just a short drive from Scranton in northeastern Pennsylvania. The borough has earned a reputation that is much larger than its footprint, mostly thanks to one regional pizza style.
Arcaro and Genell is listed as an Italian restaurant, and it has been part of the local routine since 1938. That kind of staying power is rare in any business, let alone one built on dough and sauce.
The building itself is large, with room for indoor and outdoor seating. There is also a rental hall and even a bocce court on the property.
For locals, the name is shorthand for dinner on a busy night. For travelers, it is often the first stop when they want to understand what Old Forge pizza is all about.
The place holds a 4.5-star average across more than 670 Google entries, which says plenty about how steady the kitchen has been. Not bad for a spot that has been doing the same thing well for decades.
Decades of Trays and Family Tradition

Back in 1938, the pizza world looked nothing like it does today. Old Forge was already building its own way of doing things, and Arcaro and Genell became one of its anchors.
Many people who grew up nearby describe the restaurant as one of the pillars of Old Forge pizza. It is the kind of place that shows up in childhood memories next to school days and family birthdays.
That history carries forward in a very personal way. The owner, Angelo, is known for greeting customers, and he knows many of the lunchtime regulars by first name.
Families have used the restaurant for big moments too. Gatherings, luncheons, and holiday parties have all taken place under its roof.
Former Scranton residents keep the bond alive from far away. Some plan entire trips around a return visit and leave with several boxes for the road home.
A business does not last this long by accident. It lasts because generations keep coming back and bringing the next generation with them.
The Old Forge Style Explained

First-timers often ask a simple question: what makes Old Forge pizza different? The short answer starts with the shape.
Pies here come in squares and rectangles, baked on trays and cut into pieces. A small order brings 6 cuts, while the classic red pie comes in 12.
The crust is thick and crunchy on the bottom yet airy inside. Many describe it as somewhere between thick and thin, or between a grandma slice and a Sicilian slice.
Then there is the cheese blend, which gives the pizza its own identity. Plenty of first-timers call the flavor unique and unlike anything back home, including people from New Jersey who take their pizza seriously.
The traditional crust with its sweeter sauce is a favorite among fans of the style. It is a good starting point for anyone new to the town’s signature pie.
Some say it is not traditional pizza at all, just a welcome change of pace. Either way, it is a style worth learning one square at a time.
Red Versus White, the Friendly Rivalry

Ask five regulars which pie is best, and you might get five passionate answers. The red and the white each have loyal camps.
The red pie is the classic introduction. It comes with that crunchy, airy crust and a sauce that many call spot on.
The white pizza is a different animal. It often comes double crusted, with pizza sandwiched between layers, and fans call it a must-have in Old Forge.
Some customers say the white is perfect and the red is also delicious. Diplomatic, sure, but also honest.
The double crust idea goes beyond plain white too. Broccoli versions have their own following, and they turn a simple order into something heartier.
Since many tables order both, the rivalry rarely gets heated. The real winner tends to be whoever grabs the last square.
Toppings That Earn a Family Following

Shrimp and hot pepper on a pizza square may surprise a newcomer. Around here, it is a family favorite for good reason.
Arcaro and Genell offers a range of toppings, and the menu lets customers build their order the way they like it. One handy detail is that a meatball topping has been listed at just 25 cents.
Broccoli works its way into the double crust lineup. It pairs nicely with the white style for anyone who wants a few greens with their crust.
Simple orders shine as well. Grated parmesan and red pepper flakes sit ready for anyone who likes to adjust each piece to taste.
That flexibility keeps big groups happy. One person can stick to plain red while another goes bold with shrimp.
It is proof that a style with deep roots still has room to play. The tray is old school, but the toppings keep things interesting.
Beyond the Pie: Italian Classics

Pizza may be the headliner, but the supporting cast deserves a curtain call. The menu here is large and varied, with very generous portions.
The porketta sub is a standout. At around $10, it surprises people with its size and the amount of pork packed into the roll, and adding provolone is a popular choice.
Tripe has a devoted crowd too. It comes tender in sauce and can be paired with hot sausage or meatballs on a platter.
The takeaway store also carries a handful of classic Italian American side dishes and specialties. It is easy to walk in for pizza and leave with dinner for tomorrow.
Gluten-free options are available as well, including gluten-free ravioli. That makes the stop friendlier for mixed groups with different needs.
For a pizza place, that is a surprisingly deep bench. The squares open the door, and the rest of the menu keeps people coming back.
Sweet Endings Worth Saving Room For

A sign at the counter holds a little secret. Cannoli are filled fresh on request, so all anyone has to do is ask.
That small detail turns dessert into a quick custom treat. It is the kind of touch that makes a takeout stop feel personal.
The limoncello cake has its own fan club. Some say it reminds them of homemade lemon flavors from family kitchens.
Lemon bars also appear in the case. Served warm, they make an easy add-on for the ride home.
Desserts here are not an afterthought tacked onto a pizza menu. They fit the old school Italian spirit of the whole place.
So plan ahead and leave a little room. Skipping the sweets here would be a crumby decision.
How the Takeaway Setup Works

Here is a practical note that saves confusion: the restaurant has recently operated as takeaway only. Dine-in has not been available at times, even though the building is large.
That does not mean the experience feels rushed. The takeout area has stools, and some customers simply eat right there in peace.
Staff have been known to welcome groups inside even when short staffed. That generous spirit comes up again and again.
Orders tend to come out hot, fresh, and quick. Families often buy several boxes at once, especially those heading back out of state.
The pizza travels well. Plenty of people reheat it at home and find it tastes much like it did at pickup.
Calling ahead or checking the website before a visit is smart. Setups can change, and a quick check keeps the plan smooth.
Bocce, Music, and Outdoor Seating

Not many pizza places come with their own bocce court. Arcaro and Genell does, and it adds a playful layer to the property.
Outside, there are tables and chairs for anyone who wants to eat in the open air. Music plays out there too, which makes the space especially inviting in warmer months.
That setup suits a summer road trip nicely. Grab a box, find a seat, and settle in for a relaxed lunch.
The outdoor area also helps when the inside is set up for pickup only. It gives customers a comfortable option that is right on site.
Bocce fits the place’s Italian American roots. It is a nod to tradition that feels right at home next to tray pizza.
Bring a friend with a competitive streak. The game is easy to learn and hard to stop.
A Banquet Hall for Big Occasions

Holiday parties, family luncheons, and work events all find a home here. The property includes a rental hall that hosts gatherings of many sizes.
Event planning is handled with care. Lisa, who coordinates many of these events, earns steady praise for being easy to work with.
The banquet room can be decorated for the occasion. Thoughtful extras, such as tables for photo props and a standing table for guest check-in, have made parties run smoothly.
Catering is another option. Food arrives packaged thoroughly, with nothing leaking or spilling on the way.
Families have marked meaningful moments here too. Angelo and his team are known for making those gatherings feel well cared for.
A place that feeds a town for decades naturally becomes its gathering spot. The hall simply makes that role official.
Mom and Pop Spirit, Old School Vibes

Small towns run on familiar faces, and this restaurant is a perfect example. The atmosphere feels like a classic mom and pop shop that has simply been around for a very long time.
Many people describe it as having old school Italian restaurant vibes. That comes from the menu, the people, and the way regulars are treated.
Friendliness is a recurring theme. The staff come across as genuinely kind, not just polite.
Names like Drew and the crew pop up when people talk about great service. The person at the front counter gets warm words too.
It suits travelers who want a real local stop, families picking up dinner, and groups on a pizza tour. It also suits anyone who likes being greeted like a neighbor.
The decor and tone reflect a small town personality. That character is part of what keeps the place feeling rooted.
Hours, Parking, and Shipping Tips

Timing matters for any pizza run. Arcaro and Genell opens at 11 AM every day.
Monday through Saturday, it stays open until 8 PM. On Sunday, the doors close earlier, at 6 PM.
Parking is simple. A small lot on the corner serves takeaway customers, and it is usually all that is needed.
The location makes a handy pit stop for road trips. People heading through from places like Jim Thorpe often swing by.
Too far away to visit? The pizza has been available on Goldbelly, so fans in other states can order it shipped.
For the latest menu and details, the website at arcaroandgenell.com is the best place to check. A little planning makes the trip a slice of cake.
Worth the Detour to Old Forge

After all these decades, the formula has not needed much fixing. Square pizza, friendly faces, and a menu full of Italian American comfort still do the job.
Arcaro and Genell works for a quick lunch, a family pickup, or a big celebration. It also works as a crash course in Old Forge pizza for curious travelers.
The red pie makes a solid first step. The double crust white is the follow-up that turns casual fans into regulars.
Do not forget the sides and sweets. A porketta sub or a freshly filled cannoli can easily steal the show.
Plan around the takeaway setup, check the hours, and bring an appetite. Extra boxes for the drive home are never a bad idea.
Since 1938, Scranton and its neighbors have trusted this kitchen with their pizza nights. One visit makes it clear why that trust has lasted.
Enjoyed this story?
Add Fast Food Club as a preferred source to see more of our reporting on Google.