Tucked along Lake Arrowhead Road in Myrtle Beach, Bimini’s Oyster Bar & Seafood Market is the kind of place locals keep coming back to again and again. With its laid-back Caribbean vibe, colorful island-themed decor, and seriously fresh seafood, it punches way above its weight for a modest neighborhood spot.
From golden fried shrimp to steaming oyster roasts, this hidden gem has earned a loyal following and a stellar 4.6-star rating from over 4,600 happy diners. Whether you’re a first-time visitor or a seasoned regular, there’s always something worth ordering at Bimini’s.
The Famous Fried Shrimp That Started It All
Few dishes at Bimini’s spark as much conversation as their fried shrimp. Reviewers rave about the perfectly crispy coating and the satisfying crunch with every single bite.
One diner even gave the restaurant a rare 5-star rating, specifically calling out the fried shrimp dinner as “served hot and perfect.”
The secret seems to be in the timing and the freshness of the shrimp itself. Bimini’s keeps things simple but precise, making sure every basket comes out just right.
Happy hour also features fried shrimp at a great value, making it easy to enjoy without breaking the bank.
Not every plate hits a home run every time, as one reviewer noted slightly overcooked shrimp on a busy night. But the overwhelming majority of guests leave genuinely impressed.
If fried shrimp is your thing, this is absolutely the spot to visit in Myrtle Beach.
Fresh Raw Oysters Worth Every Penny
Bimini’s raw oysters have built a reputation that’s hard to ignore. Shucked perfectly and served ice-cold, they’re the kind of oysters that make you close your eyes and appreciate the ocean.
One reviewer described them as “on point,” while another called them “delightful” after watching them get shucked right before their eyes.
At around $18.95 for a dozen, the price feels fair for the quality you receive. Oyster lovers who prefer them less well-done can request that preference, and the staff does their best to accommodate.
The happy hour menu also includes oysters at a discounted price, making it a smart time to visit if you want more for your money.
Bimini’s has become the go-to oyster roast destination for many locals, especially since other spots in the area have closed. When you find a good thing, you stick with it.
A Caribbean Atmosphere That Feels Like a Mini Vacation
Walking through the doors of Bimini’s feels like stepping onto a tropical island without ever leaving South Carolina. The walls are bright, the decor is playful, and the whole vibe screams laid-back beach life.
Long wooden tables with paper towels on them signal right away that this place is all about the food, not the formality.
Locals and tourists alike are drawn to the easygoing energy that fills every corner of the restaurant. On busy nights, the hum of conversation and clinking glasses creates a buzz that makes the wait feel like part of the fun.
Outdoor patio seating adds another layer of charm, especially when the Myrtle Beach weather is cooperating.
One regular visitor summed it up perfectly, calling Bimini’s a “little seafood pub jewel in Myrtle.” That kind of warm, unpretentious character is exactly what keeps people returning season after season.
Happy Hour Deals That Are Hard to Beat
Happy hour at Bimini’s is something of a local legend. Guests who plan their visit around these discounted hours walk away feeling like they scored big.
The happy hour menu includes favorites like fried shrimp and raw oysters, giving seafood lovers a chance to sample the best of the menu at a friendlier price point.
One Yelp reviewer discovered Bimini’s specifically through a happy hour search and ended up a devoted fan after just one visit. The extensive drink list pairs beautifully with the seafood options, and the staff knows how to keep everything moving efficiently even when the bar gets crowded.
Coming in around 3 or 4 PM on weekdays is a smart move for avoiding longer waits while still enjoying that happy hour value. It’s a relaxed, rewarding experience that gives you all the flavor of Bimini’s without the peak-hour rush.
Legendary Oyster Roasts for the True Seafood Fan
Oyster roasts at Bimini’s have become a beloved ritual for regulars who know exactly what they’re getting into. One couple described their full oyster roast as a can’t-miss experience, noting that it’s one of the few places left in the area still doing it right.
Whether you like them a little less done or steamed until they pop open easily, the kitchen works to get it just the way you want.
The oyster roast pairs naturally with other menu favorites, making it easy to build a full meal around it. Add a flounder and shrimp plate, grab some chips, and you’ve got a proper feast without overspending.
It’s the kind of meal that feels special without demanding a fancy occasion.
Bimini’s has become the default destination for oyster roast fans in Myrtle Beach. When most competitors have closed up shop, this spot keeps delivering consistently excellent results.
Snow Crab Clusters That Impress Every Time
Snow crab at Bimini’s isn’t just good, it’s genuinely memorable. One group of diners ordered six clusters and came back raving about the size, calling them some of the biggest snow crab clusters they had ever received at any restaurant.
That kind of portion generosity is rare and very much appreciated.
Cooked perfectly and served with butter for dipping, these clusters deliver that sweet, tender crab flavor that seafood lovers crave. The combination of quality and quantity makes them one of the best deals on the menu, especially when you factor in the island-themed atmosphere surrounding your meal.
Pair the crab with a cold Landshark beer and some hot fries, and you’ve got a meal that feels like a celebration. Whether you’re visiting Myrtle Beach for the first time or the fiftieth, snow crab night at Bimini’s is always a solid choice worth planning around.
Calamari That Even First-Timers Love
Calamari doesn’t always win over first-timers, but Bimini’s version has a pretty impressive track record. One family brought three kids who had never tried it before, and all three loved it immediately.
That says a lot about how approachable and well-executed the dish really is.
Served as a popular starter, the calamari strips come out golden and lightly crispy with a tender inside that avoids the rubbery texture that turns people off. Multiple reviewers across different visits mentioned ordering calamari and walking away happy every time.
It pairs nicely with a cold drink while you wait for the main event to arrive.
At $12.95, it’s a reasonably priced appetizer that sets a great tone for the rest of the meal. If you’re visiting Bimini’s for the first time and feeling adventurous, starting with the calamari is a decision you’re very unlikely to regret.
Friendly and Attentive Staff Who Make the Difference
Service at Bimini’s gets mentioned in almost every glowing review, and that’s no accident. The staff here seems genuinely happy to be there, creating an energy that makes guests feel welcome from the moment they walk in.
One longtime industry veteran compared Bimini’s bartender Jaimie to the best service professionals she had ever encountered, calling her performance nothing short of exceptional.
Servers like Carley and Luigi also earned personal shoutouts from diners who appreciated their attentiveness and menu knowledge. On packed nights when the restaurant is running at full capacity, the team somehow keeps things moving without making anyone feel rushed or forgotten.
Management clearly sets a strong example, with one reviewer noting that the manager was actively filling in wherever needed to keep the experience smooth. That kind of leadership trickles down into every interaction.
At Bimini’s, good service isn’t a happy accident, it’s a consistent standard.
Crab Cakes Worth Ordering Again and Again
Crab cakes at Bimini’s have quietly become one of the menu’s most celebrated items. Packed with real crab meat and cooked to a perfect golden crust, they show up in reviews alongside high praise and repeat orders.
One visitor who spent four days in Myrtle Beach ate at Bimini’s twice specifically to enjoy the three-combo platter featuring the crab cake alongside fried flounder and shrimp.
The combo platter at $31.95 offers serious value when you consider the quality and portion size involved. Each component holds its own, but the crab cake often steals the spotlight with its rich, savory flavor.
It’s the kind of dish that reminds you why seafood done simply and freshly is always the right move.
Whether ordered solo or as part of a platter, the crab cake at Bimini’s delivers a consistently satisfying experience that keeps people talking well after their plates are cleared.
Hush Puppies That Redefine the Standard
Hush puppies might seem like a small side detail, but at Bimini’s they’ve earned serious devotion. One diner who claimed to have eaten hush puppies at almost every seafood spot in Calabash, North Carolina, declared Bimini’s version her new all-time favorite.
That’s high praise from someone who clearly knows their way around a seafood menu.
Light, fluffy on the inside, and perfectly golden on the outside, these little cornmeal bites have a homemade quality that sets them apart from the frozen versions found at chain restaurants. Multiple reviewers called them out specifically as a highlight of their meal, often mentioning them in the same breath as the main courses.
They don’t come automatically with every meal like at some other spots, but when they arrive they more than make up for the wait. Order them early and enjoy every single one before the entrees arrive.
Coconut Shrimp With Serious Island Flavor
Coconut shrimp at Bimini’s captures everything the Caribbean theme of the restaurant promises. The sweet, crunchy coconut coating wraps around each plump shrimp, creating a flavor combination that feels both indulgent and surprisingly light.
One couple ordered it specifically and came away calling it very good, which at a spot like Bimini’s is a reliable indicator of quality.
The dish works beautifully as an appetizer or as a main event depending on your appetite. Paired with a tropical cocktail from their extensive drink list, it transforms a simple dinner into something that feels genuinely festive.
The kitchen doesn’t rush these, and that patience in preparation shows clearly in the final result.
Coconut shrimp lovers visiting Myrtle Beach often end up at tourist traps that disappoint. Bimini’s delivers the real deal with fresh shrimp and a coating that actually stays on through every satisfying bite.
Steam Pots Big Enough to Feed the Whole Crew
Bimini’s steam pots are the kind of meal that turns a regular dinner into a full-on event. Loaded with shrimp, crab, corn, and potatoes, these generously sized pots are built for sharing and seriously satisfying to dig into as a group.
One enthusiastic reviewer put it simply: the steam pots will feed friend, foe, and family alike.
The long wooden tables at Bimini’s were practically designed for this kind of communal eating experience. Spread out the contents, grab some paper towels, and get ready for a meal that’s as much about the shared fun as it is about the food itself.
It’s a tradition that feels perfectly at home in a coastal South Carolina setting.
Groups visiting Myrtle Beach looking for a memorable and filling seafood experience should put the steam pot near the top of their list. Few dishes at any price point deliver this much flavor and satisfaction all at once.
A Local Gem That Outshines the Tourist Traps
Myrtle Beach is full of big, flashy seafood restaurants that promise the world and sometimes deliver very little. Bimini’s takes the opposite approach, staying modest in size and atmosphere while consistently delivering food that beats restaurants three times its size.
One longtime visitor put it directly, recommending Bimini’s over the “ginormous seafood restaurants” that dominate the area.
With over 4,600 reviews averaging 4.6 stars, the numbers back up what locals have known for years. This isn’t a place that relies on clever marketing or tourist foot traffic.
It earns its reputation one fresh plate of seafood at a time, night after night, season after season.
Located at 930 Lake Arrowhead Road and open until 10 PM most nights, Bimini’s is accessible and worth seeking out. Call ahead at 843-449-5549 or visit biminisoysterbar.com to check hours before you go.
Some things in Myrtle Beach come and go, but Bimini’s endures.