Fast Food Club Fast Food Club

Arizona Pie Lovers Plan Their Thanksgiving Drive Around These 6 Small-Town Cafes Off The Highway

Emma Larkin 6 min read
featured image ad61269bc704 5ea4dd51d85a
Arizona Pie Lovers Plan Their Thanksgiving Drive Around These 6 Small-Town Cafes Off The Highway

Thanksgiving in Arizona usually means a long drive, and long drives need a good pie stop. Across the state, small-town cafes sit just off the interstates and state routes, baking homemade pies that make the detour easy to justify.

Some are on Route 66, some sit in the mountains, and one is right in the middle of red rock country. Here are six cafes that pie fans build their holiday road trips around, with practical details so you can plan your route and your slice.

1. Rock Springs Café, Black Canyon City, AZ

Rock Springs Café, Black Canyon City, AZ
© Rock Springs Café, Black Canyon City, AZ

Anyone who has driven Interstate 17 between Phoenix and the high country has probably seen the exit for this one. Rock Springs Café sits right off the freeway in Black Canyon City, a rural foothills community of about 2,700 people.

Pie is the headliner here. The cafe is known for homemade pies in a wide range of flavors, including Apple, Apple Crumb, Cherry Crumb, Lemon Meringue, Strawberry Rhubarb, and a Tennessee Lemon that stands out from the usual lineup.

There is even a Sugar Free Apple for travelers watching their sugar.

The setting adds to the stop. The historic building has a fireplace and mountain views, and a garden with a natural stone staircase leads down to the springs that give the place its name.

A gift shop sells homemade salsa and fruit butters, which make easy hostess gifts if you are heading to someone else’s table. The main menu covers steaks, chicken, sandwiches, and the famous calf fries, plus big breakfasts with plate-sized pancakes and grits.

Hours run daily from 7 a.m. to 8 p.m., and the cafe does not take reservations. Weekends get busy, so a weekday stop is the calmer choice.

2. Pine Country Restaurant, Williams, AZ

Pine Country Restaurant, Williams, AZ
© Pine Country Restaurant, Williams, AZ

Grand Canyon travelers love Williams for its old-fashioned Route 66 main street, and Pine Country Restaurant is one of its best reasons to slow down. It sits at 107 N Grand Canyon Blvd, close to both the historic route and Interstate 40.

The pie menu changes, so part of the fun is seeing what is in the case that day. German Chocolate is one slice that shows up on the menu, and the restaurant also bakes chocolate cake for anyone who wants a break from crust.

Inside, knotty pine tables and a gift shop give the place a homey, nostalgic look. The food matches it, with Country Fried Steak and Eggs, Hot Roast Beef Sandwiches, Pot Roast Sandwiches, and Huevos Rancheros.

I would save this stop for the dinner leg of a northern Arizona trip, then walk the downtown blocks afterward. The restaurant is open daily from 7 a.m. to 9 p.m. and accepts reservations, a handy perk on a busy holiday weekend.

3. Westside Lilo’s Cafe, Seligman, AZ

Westside Lilo's Cafe, Seligman, AZ
© Westside Lilo’s Cafe, Seligman, AZ

Seligman has only about 450 residents, yet it pulls in a steady stream of Route 66 road trippers. Westside Lilo’s Cafe is a big part of that draw.

Walls and shelves here are packed with tchotchkes, so there is plenty to look at while you wait. The menu leans classic American with a twist of German favorites, served in very generous portions.

Homemade pies are a highlight, and so is Lilo’s Homemade Carrot Cake, which has a loyal following of its own. Splitting one of each is a smart move for a table that cannot decide.

Savory options include Lilo’s Famous Burger, Biscuits and Gravy, a Patty Melt, and Huevos Rancheros. Coffee comes in branded mugs, and there is a coffee bar too.

The cafe sits at 22855 AZ-66 and is open daily from 7 a.m. to 8 p.m. It does not take reservations, and weekend mornings fill up fast.

4. Trapper’s Cafe, Taylor, AZ

Trapper's Cafe, Taylor, AZ
© Trapper’s Cafe, Taylor, AZ

More than a dozen kinds of homemade pie is a strong opening argument for any cafe. Trapper’s Cafe in Taylor offers over 12 varieties, which makes it a favorite on the eastern side of the state.

Taylor is a small Navajo County town of about 4,300 people, and the cafe sits at 9 S Main St, right off State Route 77. It is a natural stop for anyone heading to or from the White Mountains.

Cream pies get plenty of attention, with Banana Cream and Lemon Cream on the menu. Cherry and Apple cover the fruit side for traditionalists.

The rest of the menu is straightforward hometown cooking. Think Biscuits and Gravy, Bacon and Eggs, Country Fried Steak, burgers, and Hot Beef Sandwiches in a quiet, relaxed room.

Plan ahead on timing. Trapper’s opens Monday through Saturday from 6:30 a.m. to 8 p.m. and is closed on Sundays.

5. Beeline Cafe Payson Az, Payson, AZ

Beeline Cafe Payson Az, Payson, AZ
© Beeline Cafe Payson Az, Payson, AZ

Early birds, this one is for you. Beeline Cafe opens at 5 a.m. daily and closes at 3 p.m., so it fits a dawn departure better than a late lunch.

The cafe sits along the Beeline Highway (AZ-87) in Payson, the Mogollon Rim town that many Valley drivers pass through on the way north. Inside, wood paneling and a lunch counter give it a classic old-school diner look.

Pie is the reason to save room. Homemade apple pie with ice cream and blackberry pie a la mode are two slices that keep regulars coming back.

Breakfast covers cinnamon rolls and Blueberry Pancakes, while lunch brings Chicken Fried Steak, a French Dip, a Turkey Club, Pork Chops, and liver and onions. Portions are big and prices are reasonable.

Bring cash, since the cafe is cash only, though there is an ATM on site. Weekend mornings are the busiest stretch.

6. Black Cow Cafe, Sedona, AZ

Black Cow Cafe, Sedona, AZ
© Black Cow Cafe, Sedona, AZ

Pie and ice cream under one roof makes the a la mode decision very easy. Black Cow Cafe in Sedona serves both, all in a small space with a 1950s look.

The housemade pie list includes apple crumb, pecan, and strawberry rhubarb, a strong trio for a holiday trip. Pecan in particular feels right for late November.

Ice cream flavors range from classic Vanilla and Belgian Chocolate to Peppermint Chip, Espresso Swirl, and a Prickly Pear Ice Cream that leans fully into Arizona. Coffee, scones, banana splits, and hot dogs round things out.

Prices run low, roughly $1 to $10 per person, which helps after a pricey Sedona weekend. The cafe sits on State Route 89A and is open daily from 10:30 a.m. to 9 p.m.

Seating is counter style with no table service, so it works best as a quick dessert stop before the drive home.

Enjoyed this story?

Add Fast Food Club as a preferred source to see more of our reporting on Google.

Follow us on Google

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *