You do not need a plane ticket to LaGuardia to find a proper bagel with lox. Indiana has quietly built a solid lineup of bagel shops that boil, bake, and hand-roll their dough, then pile on smoked salmon, schmear, capers, and pickled onions like they mean it.
Some of these spots have been around for decades, while others are newer shops with fresh ideas and early-morning baking schedules. A few even carry true East Coast staples like pork roll, Taylor ham, and the bodega favorite known as the chopped cheese.
This list covers six places from Gary down to Bloomington that bring a real taste of New York to the Hoosier State. Each one earns its spot for a different reason, whether that is history, sourdough, deli sandwiches, or a lox spread worth planning a Saturday around.
Save it, share it, and bring your appetite along for the ride.
1. Sidedoor Bagel, Indianapolis, IN
Sourdough is the twist that sets this Near Eastside shop apart. Sidedoor Bagel hand-rolls its bagels from sourdough, giving them a soft, chewy interior and a slightly crisp outside.
The star for smoked fish fans is the Lox and Loaded Open Face. It comes loaded with lox, dill schmear, pickled onions, and fresh dill, which is about as New York as a breakfast order gets.
Toppings like spicy everything and flaky salt add some personality to the lineup. If you keep it simple, the Bagel and Schmear comes with generous spreads, and the Turkey Run and the vegetarian White Beanie round out the sandwich side.
Plan for a to-go stop, since there is no dine-in service, though there is outdoor seating. Hours run 7:30 AM to 1:30 PM on weekdays and 8 AM to 1:30 PM on weekends.
Weekend mornings get busy, so I would aim for a weekday if you want a shorter wait. Free parking in a lot and on the street makes the quick visit easy, and a cold brew pairs nicely with that lox.
2. Gables Bagels, Bloomington, IN
Pork roll, egg, and cheese on a bagel in southern Indiana. That alone tells you Gables Bagels takes its East Coast roots seriously.
The shop bills itself as authentic New York-style, with fresh house-made bagels and a lineup of deli sandwiches. Taylor Ham Egg Cheese and Brisket Egg Cheese sit on the menu next to the pork roll, which is a rare sight this far from New Jersey.
Smoked fish lovers get a lot to work with here. The lox is well balanced, the salmon is smoked with care, and the cream cheese is homemade, with vegan cream cheese available too.
The energy behind the counter is part of the draw. Music, quick banter, and a playful crew keep the line moving and entertaining.
Gables opens daily at 6:30 AM and closes at 2 PM, which works for early classes and early commutes. Dine-in, takeout, and delivery are all options, and the vegan Bagel Crisps make a good snack for later.
3. Bagel Fair, Indianapolis, IN
Since 1975, a family-run shop on East 86th Street has been boiling and baking bagels the old-school way. Bagel Fair is the veteran of this list, and it shows in the details.
The bagels are hand-made, boiled, then baked, which is the traditional New York method. Flavors range from blueberry to everything to a jalapeno cayenne option with some kick.
The lox cream cheese is the signature move. Spread it on an everything bagel and you have the order many regulars come back for, though scallion cream cheese on a jalapeno bagel is a strong runner-up.
A warm blueberry bagel with butter and cinnamon sugar is another sweet way to go. Prices are among the friendliest here, usually under 10 dollars per person.
Bring cash, because Bagel Fair is cash-only. It is takeout-focused, open 7 AM to 2 PM Monday through Saturday and until 1 PM on Sunday, and early arrival gets you the freshest batch.
4. Clutch Bagels and Spreads, Gary, IN
Around 1:30 in the morning, while most of Gary is asleep, the owner of Clutch is already at work making bagels from scratch. That early start is why the bagels here taste so fresh.
Clutch Bagels and Spreads is a light, airy neighborhood shop on South Lake Street with outdoor tables. Breads, buns, and bagels are all made in-house.
The Lox bagel is a standout for smoked fish fans and makes a strong lunch pick. Then there is the Chopped Cheese, the New York bodega classic that you rarely see on an Indiana menu.
The menu stretches further than most bagel shops, with Steak and a Bagel, a Grilled Tenderloin Sandwich, a Spicy Italian, Cajun fries, and even Detroit-style pizza. Prices mostly land under 10 dollars per person.
Hours are 7 AM to 3 PM, but note that Clutch is closed on Wednesdays. Saturdays are the busiest, and parking is usually plentiful, which helps if you are heading to the nearby lakefront.
5. Bloomington Bagel Company, Bloomington, IN
Bloomington gets two spots on this list, and that says plenty about the college town’s bagel standards. Bloomington Bagel Company holds down the downtown corner on North Morton Street.
Bagels here are hand-rolled and fresh, backed by a lineup of specialty cream cheeses. It is a small, comfortable shop with a few tables and quick service.
For smoked salmon, the Supernova bagel sandwich is the one to know. It is the shop’s go-to choice for anyone chasing that New York deli feel.
Other picks include the Deli Bagelwich, a vegetarian Egg and Cheese, and a vegan Bagel and Schmear. Smoothies, iced mochas, and good coffee cover the drink side.
The shop is open every day from 7 AM to 2 PM. Weekend mornings fill up fast, so a weekday visit is the easier play, and delivery is available if you would rather stay in.
6. The Great American Bagel, Munster, IN
Early risers in Munster have an easy win here. The Great American Bagel opens at 5:30 AM on weekdays, the earliest start on this list.
This counter-service spot on Calumet Avenue mixes a wide variety of bagels with deli-style sandwiches and salads. The bagels come out fresh, and the staff keep things friendly and efficient.
Order the Lox Bagel if smoked fish is your goal. The Tuna Wrap is another solid pick when you want something for lunch.
Unlike many bagel shops, it stays open into the afternoon, until 4 PM on weekdays and 3 PM on weekends. Seating inside and out, kid-friendly appeal, and plenty of free parking make it a simple family stop.
I would save this one for a commute breakfast or a quick lunch while running errands in the Region.
Enjoyed this story?
Add Fast Food Club as a preferred source to see more of our reporting on Google.