Chess pie might be the most Southern dessert that nobody can fully explain. It starts with simple pantry staples like butter, sugar, and eggs, and somehow turns into a rich, custardy slice that shows up at nearly every Tennessee holiday table.
Some bakeries keep it classic, while others add lemon, chocolate, or blueberry to the mix. If you plan to bring dessert to a family gathering this year, or you just want an excuse to taste-test, these six Tennessee bakeries are a smart place to start.
They range from a small-town square in Columbia to a mini pie shop near Chattanooga, and a few of them make chess pie in forms you may not expect. Grab a fork, check the hours before you go, and maybe order an extra slice for the ride home.
1. Pie Sensations, Columbia, TN
Few places suit a pie shop better than a historic courthouse square. Pie Sensations sits right on Columbia’s Public Square at number 26, which makes it an easy stop during a stroll through downtown.
The bakery focuses on homemade pies, with a large selection that rotates alongside other baked sweets. Turtle and chocolate peanut butter pies get plenty of attention, and pecan pie is a menu regular.
The chess pie here leans traditional. It has that classic Southern flavor with a balanced sweetness rather than a sugar overload, which makes it a good pick if you are feeding a crowd with mixed tastes.
There is a small outdoor seating area if you want a slice right away. Hours run Monday through Saturday from 10 AM to 5 PM, and the shop is closed Sundays, so plan weekend pie runs for Saturday.
2. Merridee’s Breadbasket, Franklin, TN
Chess pie in bar form is a brilliant idea for anyone who hates cutting neat slices. Merridee’s Breadbasket in downtown Franklin sells chess bars, which are easy to stack on a holiday dessert platter.
The bakery also turns out chess pie, and its cinnamon rolls make a strong partner order. Pecan pie, peanut butter pie, and molasses cookies round out the sweet side of the counter.
I like this stop because it works for a full meal too. Breakfast brings biscuits and gravy and breakfast burritos, while lunch leans on soups and a well-known chicken salad sandwich, mostly in the 10 to 20 dollar range.
You will find it at 110 4th Ave S, opening at 7 AM Monday through Saturday with closing times that vary by day. Saturday mornings get busy, and free parking options, including a garage, are nearby.
3. Pie R Square, Red Bank, TN
Lemon chess, chocolate chess, lemon blueberry chess. Pie R Square treats chess pie like a flavor family instead of a single recipe.
The Red Bank shop specializes in mini pies, both sweet and savory, so trying three or four kinds in one visit is completely reasonable. Prices sit mostly between 1 and 10 dollars per person.
The lemon chess is the one people come back for, and the staff are happy to steer first-timers toward it. Cinnamon pecan, banana caramel, lavender cream, and quiche also show up in the case.
Timing matters here. The shop at 4403 Dayton Blvd is open only Wednesday through Saturday from noon to 7 PM, with a free parking lot out front.
4. Julia’s Homestyle Bakery, Murfreesboro, TN
Some fans make a drive of more than an hour just for the chess pie squares at Julia’s Homestyle Bakery. That tells you plenty about the reputation this Murfreesboro shop has built.
The squares are the star, but the bakery is best known for custom cakes for every occasion. Red velvet cake, peanut butter pie, butter cookies, and a lineup of cupcakes fill out the menu.
For holiday planning, that mix is handy. You can pick up a tray of chess squares and order a celebration cake in one trip.
The shop is at 1911 Medical Center Pkwy, Suite B, with a free lot. Hours are Monday through Saturday 9 AM to 7 PM and Sunday noon to 6 PM, and Saturdays are the busiest stretch.
There is no public restroom, so keep it a quick stop.
5. Dozen Bakery, Nashville, TN
Sourdough loaves and croissants might pull you in, but the blueberry chess pie is the reason Dozen earns a spot here. It puts a fruity spin on the old custard classic.
This minimalist counter-serve bakery on Grandview Avenue also makes coffee toffee, chocolate creme, and butterscotch pecan pies. Cherry cornmeal scones and chocolate croissants are popular morning picks.
Savory eaters are covered too, with a focaccia egg sandwich, quiche, and other sandwiches alongside coffee drinks. Most visits land in the 10 to 20 dollar range.
Dozen opens at 7 AM every day, closing at 4 PM on weekdays and 3 PM on weekends. Weekend mornings get crowded, and there is a free lot plus street parking at 2522 Grandview Ave.
6. The Three Mothers Cuisine & Bakery, Murfreesboro, TN
Office birthday coming up? A chess pie and a tres leches cake from The Three Mothers make a combo that covers both Southern and Latin dessert fans.
The bakery case here is wide. Expect doughnuts, flan, eclairs, cookies, cakes, fruit desserts, and full-size and mini pies, all with a careful, polished look.
It doubles as a breakfast and lunch cafe. French toast with berries, avocado toast, biscuits and gravy, and a chicken salad croissant are on the menu, with coffee to go with them.
Find it at 1002 Memorial Blvd, open seven days a week from 7 AM, with closing times between 3 and 6 PM depending on the day. Curbside pickup is available, which helps when you are juggling holiday orders.
From a square in Columbia to a mini pie counter in Red Bank, chess pie in Tennessee comes in more styles than most people realize. Pick one, or plan a little tasting tour before the holiday rush begins.
Enjoyed this story?
Add Fast Food Club as a preferred source to see more of our reporting on Google.