Fast Food Club Fast Food Club

Before You Plan Christmas Dinner, Order A Pie From These 7 Ohio Orchard Bakeries

Hudson Dayton 6 min read
featured image 8920db515cd6 0fa80fb3ed73
Before You Plan Christmas Dinner, Order A Pie From These 7 Ohio Orchard Bakeries

Christmas dinner gets a lot easier when dessert is already handled. Ohio has orchard bakeries all over the map, from the Toledo suburbs to the hills outside Cincinnati, and many of them bake pies with fruit grown just steps from the oven.

These are not big chain bakeries. They are family farms with markets, cider presses, and pie shelves that fill up fast once the holidays roll around.

This list covers seven orchard stops where pie is a real part of the business, not an afterthought. You will find classic apple, Dutch apple, rhubarb, pumpkin, pecan, and even fry pies.

Some of these farms have been around for generations, and one has been growing fruit for more than two centuries. A few keep limited days, so planning ahead matters.

Read through, pick the one closest to your holiday table, and call before you go so your pie is waiting for you.

1. MacQueen Orchards, Holland, OH

MacQueen Orchards, Holland, OH
© MacQueen Orchards, Holland, OH

Holiday tables around Toledo have a habit of featuring a MacQueen pie. Rhubarb, fruit of the forest, and Dutch apple have long been the family favorites that show up when the calendar turns festive.

The orchard sits on Garden Road in Holland and runs a farmers’ market with an on-site bakery. Apples and cider share space with the baked goods, so you can grab a jug to go with dessert.

Apple pie leads the bakery lineup, but the extras are hard to skip. Apple fritters, apple cider donuts, and apple strudel bread make a strong case for a second bag.

Hours run daily from 9 AM to 7 PM, which is generous for a farm market. Weekend afternoons get crowded, so a weekday morning stop is the calmer play.

Call 419-865-2916 if you want to check on pie availability before Christmas week.

2. Patterson Fruit Farm, Chesterland, OH

Patterson Fruit Farm, Chesterland, OH
© Patterson Fruit Farm, Chesterland, OH

Dutch apple pie fans in Geauga County tend to have strong opinions, and Patterson Fruit Farm is usually where those opinions point. The crumb-topped classic is the star here.

Patterson is a multi-generational, family-run farm with orchards in two locations. In season, guests can pick their own apples and strawberries.

The general store on Caves Road is where pie shopping happens. Apple, peach, and pecan pies sit alongside donuts, fresh apple fritters, apple cider, and the farm’s own maple syrup.

That maple syrup makes a handy stocking stuffer, by the way. The store also carries unique gifts, so dessert and a last-minute present can come home in one trip.

Doors open daily from 9 AM to 6 PM. Saturday and Sunday are the busy days, while weekday evenings are quieter.

In-store pickup is offered, but there is no delivery, so plan a drive out to Chesterland.

3. Bauman Orchards Inc, Rittman, OH

Bauman Orchards Inc, Rittman, OH
© Bauman Orchards Inc, Rittman, OH

Twenty thousand apple trees is a lot of pie potential. Bauman Orchards in Rittman also grows 3,000 peach trees, with 25 apple varieties and 15 peach varieties on the property.

The family started farming here in 1929 on 18 acres. Today the operation covers more than 117 acres.

Here is the holiday bonus. The cider presses run from September through May, so fresh cider is still flowing in December.

The Farm Market sells homemade pies and cookies, plus gift baskets and produce. If you need a hostess gift and a dessert, both are covered under one roof.

Plan around the schedule. Bauman is open Monday through Friday from 8 AM to 6 PM and Saturday from 8 AM to 5 PM, with Sundays closed.

A free parking lot sits on site at 161 Rittman Ave.

4. Burnham Orchards, Berlin Heights, OH

Burnham Orchards, Berlin Heights, OH
© Burnham Orchards, Berlin Heights, OH

More than 200 years of apple growing is the kind of resume most bakeries can only dream about. Burnham Orchards calls itself a 209-year-old family orchard, now run by the seventh generation.

That history shows up in a market that sticks to the basics. Apples, donuts, and pies fill the shelves alongside plenty of other farm favorites.

The family takes pride in affordable prices and quality fruit. For a big holiday crowd, that combination counts.

Burnham sits on OH-113 in Berlin Heights, an easy drive from Sandusky and the Lake Erie shoreline. It is open daily from 9 AM to 6 PM.

I like this one for families who want a little story with their slice. Telling the table that the pie came from a seven-generation orchard is a pretty good conversation starter.

5. Brumbaugh Fruit Farm, Arcanum, OH

Brumbaugh Fruit Farm, Arcanum, OH
© Brumbaugh Fruit Farm, Arcanum, OH

Pumpkin pie is a Christmas dessert too, and Brumbaugh Fruit Farm in Darke County makes a well-loved one. It is a smart pick if your family wants something besides apple.

The farm market stocks fruits and vegetables, jams, jelly, and honey. A bakery on the premises handles the sweet side.

Expect a wide selection of pies, plus donuts, donut holes, pastries, and apple fritters. The fritters have a strong following of their own.

Cider is on hand too. As of 2025, a gallon ran $9.95 and a half gallon $6.95.

Brumbaugh sits on Hollansburg Arcanum Road, out in the farm country west of Dayton. Hours are not posted in the usual places, so call 937-692-8084 before heading out, especially in the weeks around Christmas.

6. Hidden Valley Orchards, Lebanon, OH

Hidden Valley Orchards, Lebanon, OH
© Hidden Valley Orchards, Lebanon, OH

Picking up a pie at Hidden Valley Orchards can easily turn into an afternoon. The Lebanon farm has a market, a full bakery, a lunch spot, a patio, and plenty of open land.

The bakery turns out homemade breads, pies, pastries, and sweet treats. Apple cider donuts are a big draw.

Hungry before the drive home? Pizza and burgers are on the menu, with apple cider and slushies to drink.

Families get perks here. The farm offers kid-friendly activities, changing tables, and restrooms, plus free on-site parking.

Timing matters most at this stop. Hidden Valley is open only Friday and Saturday from 10 AM to 7 PM and Sunday from 10 AM to 4 PM.

Saturday afternoons are the busiest stretch, so Friday is the easier day to shop.

7. Lynd Fruit Farm, Pataskala, OH

Lynd Fruit Farm, Pataskala, OH
© Lynd Fruit Farm, Pataskala, OH

Fry pies are the twist at Lynd Fruit Farm. The handheld treats make a fun add-on to a whole pie, or a snack for the car ride home.

Lynd is a big farm east of Columbus, known in fall for U-pick apples, a corn maze, apple cannons, and a pumpkin patch. The market keeps the place useful well past harvest season.

Inside, you will find a selection of pies, jams and jellies, and specialty farm products. Squash, onions, apples, and other produce round out the shelves.

A Christmas tip: grab a jar of jam with your pie. It works for breakfast the next morning or as a small gift.

Lynd is open Wednesday through Sunday from 10 AM to 5 PM and closed Monday and Tuesday. Saturdays are busiest, so a weekday visit keeps things simple at 9399 Morse Rd SW.

Enjoyed this story?

Add Fast Food Club as a preferred source to see more of our reporting on Google.

Follow us on Google

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *