Some dinners in South Jersey come with a side of movie trivia, a mural of famous mob bosses, and an owner who stops by your table to say hello. One Collingswood restaurant has built a loyal crowd around generous plates of chicken parm and a cheeky gangster theme.
Friends have booked their holiday dinner there for a decade, and couples save it for anniversaries. Here is what makes the place worth the trip, plus the hours and tips you need before you go.
A Corner Of Haddon Avenue With A Secret Identity

The Kitchen Consigliere sits at 700 Haddon Ave, Collingswood, NJ 08108, in the heart of a walkable South Jersey borough. Regulars often shorten the name to Kitco, which sounds friendly enough until you notice who is painted on the walls.
Officially, it is a Southern Italian restaurant. Unofficially, it is a playful tribute to famous American Mafia figures, both real and from the movies.
The location makes it easy to fold into a bigger night out. Haddon Avenue is lined with shops and other eateries, so plenty of diners wander in after a stroll down the street.
It also sits close to the Scottish Rite Auditorium. Concertgoers and show ticket holders treat it as a handy pre-event stop, and the staff seems used to working around curtain times.
Out-of-towners make the drive too. Diners from Delaware County in Pennsylvania and from Dover, Delaware, have called it the best spot they have tried on this stretch of Collingswood.
The restaurant takes reservations, though walk-ins on quieter weeknights can sometimes get seated right away. Weekends are a different story, so a call ahead is smart.
So what is behind that clever name? The answer starts with the man running the kitchen.
The Owner Who Works The Room

Plenty of restaurants have an owner. Fewer have one who makes the rounds at every table like a host at a family party.
Angelo Lutz is the owner and the originator of the menu at The Kitchen Consigliere. He is known for stopping to chat with diners, and guests regularly mention how much they appreciate that personal touch.
That hands-on style sets the tone for the whole operation. The kitchen is open, and dishes are made to order rather than pulled from a warming tray.
The staff also gets a lot of credit by name. Servers like Kim, Patsy, and Romero come up again and again for being gracious, helpful with recommendations, and quick to make people feel like family.
A few small gestures stand out. One server packed leftovers with a bag of ice so a couple could head to a concert without worrying about their meal going bad.
Another time, a solo diner on a busy Saturday worried about taking up a table. The reply was simply that a table would be found, no fuss.
The manager also handles baking duties, which says something about how close-knit the crew is. Small team, big personality, and nobody hiding in the back office.
Mob Murals And A Movie On Loop

Forget plain beige walls. The dining room here is a full gallery of famous mob characters, some pulled from history and others from Hollywood.
The wall murals are the headline act of the decor. Guests describe them as outstanding, and they give the room a quirky, whimsical feel that matches the restaurant’s own description.
Classic gangster films sometimes play on a TV in the dining room. On some nights that means Goodfellas running in the background while you work through dinner.
The theme is clearly tongue in cheek. Nobody is asked to kiss a ring, and the only thing getting whacked is a stack of napkins.
Not everyone loves it, of course. A few people find the look a bit much, and one group compared a very long evening there to a themed escape room.
Most guests land on the other side, though. The atmosphere comes up as one of a kind, very cool, and even stunning enough for milestone celebrations.
If you enjoy pop culture with your pasta, this is the right address. If you prefer minimalist decor, at least you will have plenty to talk about.
Chicken Parm, The Unofficial Boss Of The Menu

Among all the dishes on the menu, one name keeps popping up more than any other. Chicken parm is the most talked-about plate at The Kitchen Consigliere.
The breaded cutlet arrives under a generous layer of red sauce, which many Italian families call gravy. Diners point to that sauce as a big part of why they return.
Portions are serious business here. Fans describe the food as exceptional in both quality and quantity, and leftovers are common.
Chicken lovers have other options as well. Chicken Sicilian has its own following, and Chicken Marsala has won over at least one husband who usually avoids Italian food altogether.
Honesty matters, so here is the other side. A few diners have found the breading soggy or the penne on the side overcooked on a given night.
That kind of inconsistency can happen in any made-to-order kitchen. Still, the dish remains the restaurant’s most popular order by a wide margin.
First-timers who are unsure what to pick can safely start here. It is the plate most likely to explain why this place has such a loyal crowd.
Good Food, Not Fast Food

Patience is part of the deal. Everything comes out of an open kitchen and is cooked to order, so dinner here is not a race.
Many guests say the extra 15 to 20 minutes at the table is worth it. Good servers help by giving updates while the kitchen works through the tickets.
On busy nights, though, the pace can drag. One birthday party reported a three-hour evening, with long gaps before menus and checks arrived.
Another diner noted that a server spent time chatting with regulars while other tables waited to order or pay. These moments are not the norm, but they do happen.
The smart move is to plan around it. Leave yourself a cushion if you have show tickets at the nearby auditorium, and let your server know your timing up front.
Concertgoers who do that seem to manage fine. Couples have fit in a full meal and a final course before heading to their events.
A relaxed attitude goes a long way at this table. Treat dinner as the main event rather than a pit stop, and the slower rhythm starts to feel like part of the charm.
Anniversaries, Solo Suppers And Holiday Traditions

One group of friends has held its Christmas dinner here for about ten years running. That kind of loyalty says a lot about how the restaurant fits into local life.
The crowd is wonderfully mixed. Parties of six fill weekend tables, couples mark ten-year anniversaries, and solo diners slip in on the way home from the shore.
Birthday groups are common too. The staff will happily help a table sing to the guest of honor.
Families who want a sit-down meal without stiff formality tend to feel at ease. The mood is welcoming, and the owner’s table visits make even first-timers feel like regulars.
Outdoor seating is available as well. On pleasant evenings it gives you a front-row view of Haddon Avenue.
The specials board keeps longtime guests interested. Regulars mention that the rotating appetizers and dinners give them a reason to try something new each visit.
The place is less suited to anyone in a hurry or anyone who wants a quiet, plain room. For everyone else, it works for date nights and big reunions alike.
Hours, Costs And A Few Handy Tips

Dinner is the only shift here, so plan your evening accordingly. The restaurant is open seven days a week with these hours:
Monday: 3 to 9 PM. Tuesday through Thursday: 5 to 9 PM.
Friday: 5 to 10 PM. Saturday: 4 to 10 PM.
Sunday: 3 to 9 PM.
Those earlier Sunday and Monday openings are handy for families. Friday and Saturday stay open later, and guests have found tables filling up even late in the evening.
Costs are widely described as fair and reasonable for the portion sizes. Entrees come with a house salad, and swapping it for a Caesar adds a $6 charge.
Some of the pricier specialty plates run past $30. Most diners still feel the bill matches the amount of food on the table.
The restaurant is BYO, so bring your own beverages if you want something beyond what is offered. Plenty of first-timers have not realized this before arriving.
Reservations are accepted and recommended for weekends or larger groups. The official website, kitconcafe.com, is a good place to check details before heading out.
Worth An Offer You Shouldn’t Refuse

Every family has its quirks, and this one happens to have mob murals and a movie on the TV. Underneath the theme is a very personal neighborhood restaurant.
The Kitchen Consigliere has earned a 4.6-star average from more than a thousand diners. That number reflects years of anniversaries, holiday dinners, and pre-show meals in Collingswood.
It is not flawless. Service can slow down on packed nights, and a dish might miss the mark now and then.
Still, the strengths are easy to spot. Big plates, a lively room, friendly servers, and an owner who actually shows up at the tables add up to a memorable evening.
Chicken parm remains the best place to start. Chicken Sicilian and Chicken Marsala are solid backups if you want to branch out.
Give yourself time, bring your appetite, and check the hours before you go. A reservation on a weekend will save you from waiting at the door.
For a South Jersey dinner with personality to spare, this Haddon Avenue hideout makes a strong case. Consider it a standing invitation from the family business.
Enjoyed this story?
Add Fast Food Club as a preferred source to see more of our reporting on Google.