In Indiana, chicken and noodles is not a side dish or a soup. It is a full meal, and the Hoosier way to eat it is ladled right over a pile of mashed potatoes.
That carb-on-carb combo might confuse out-of-state friends, but it has kept families warm through plenty of long winters. When the temperature drops and the wind picks up, these six spots across the state serve the plate that ends a cold day best.
Some are big Amish country dining halls, some are buffets, and one is a small-town diner with a long history. Each one brings something different to the table, from homemade pies to lakeside views.
Save this list for the next chilly evening, and maybe send it to the friend who still thinks noodles belong only on spaghetti night.
1. Das Dutchman Essenhaus, Middlebury, IN
Indiana’s largest restaurant sits right on US-20 in Middlebury, and it has earned that size by feeding a lot of hungry people. Das Dutchman Essenhaus leans fully into homestyle cooking in a folksy, historic setting.
The family-style dinner is the move on a cold night. It brings chicken and beef, mashed potatoes, homemade noodles, dressing, green beans, salad, and homemade pie to the table.
Spoon those noodles over the potatoes and you have the classic Hoosier stack.
Pie is the other big reason people come. The restaurant is known for it, so leaving room is a smart plan.
A fireplace adds to the casual, cozy dining room, and a full vegetarian menu is available too.
Hours run Monday through Saturday, 6:30 AM to 8 PM, and it is closed Sunday. Saturday afternoons and evenings get busy, while Monday and Tuesday mornings are quieter.
Parking is usually plentiful, and expect to spend about $20 to $30 per person.
2. Blue Gate Restaurant & Bakery, Shipshewana, IN
Shopping in Shipshewana builds an appetite, and Blue Gate sits right alongside an Amish crafts marketplace to handle it. This family-owned country kitchen and bakery serves all day.
Homemade noodles in chicken gravy over mashed potatoes is one of the house signatures. The plate is filling, so plan your dessert strategy early.
That matters because the pie list is long. Blueberry, cherry, and lemon meringue all show up, along with cookies, homemade rolls, and apple butter.
The honey French dressing at the salad bar has its own following.
Other comfort plates include homestyle fried chicken, meatloaf, and pot roast. Vegan and vegetarian menus are available, and there is sometimes live music.
Blue Gate is open Monday through Saturday from 10:30 AM to 7 PM. There is usually a wait, especially Saturday afternoon, so a Monday visit is easier.
Budget around $20 to $30 per person.
3. MCL Restaurant & Bakery Castleton, Indianapolis, IN
Grab a tray. MCL is an old-school cafeteria, and the Castleton location in Indianapolis keeps that tradition going with comfort food at friendly prices.
Chicken and noodles rank among the customer favorites here. Pair them with mashed potatoes and gravy, then pick a green bean side.
The smoky version and the cinnamon sugar version both have fans.
Blue plate specials, roast beef, and Beef Manhattan round out the hearty options. The bakery case covers coconut cream, apple, and cherry pie, plus cornbread.
I like this one for weeknight dinners when you want something homemade without a long drive. Most plates land around $10 to $20 per person.
It is open every day, 11 AM to 8:30 PM Monday through Saturday and 11 AM to 8 PM Sunday. Sunday afternoon is the busy stretch.
Reservations are not taken, but parking is usually easy.
4. Gasthof Amish Village, Montgomery, IN
Southwestern Indiana gets its own Amish country stop at Gasthof Amish Village, set on farmland outside Montgomery. The buffet is the main event, and it covers a lot of ground.
Homemade mashed potatoes, noodles, and gravy sit near fried chicken, roast beef, meatloaf, and roast pork. Seafood fans will spot catfish fiddlers, fried fish, and shrimp.
Fresh bread, green beans, and fried sweet potatoes help fill out the plate. Cobbler makes a good finish if there is any room left.
After dinner, the gift shop and antique shop give you a reason to linger. Reservations are accepted, which helps with larger groups.
Hours are Monday through Thursday 11 AM to 8 PM, Friday and Saturday 11 AM to 9 PM, and Sunday 10:30 AM to 3 PM. Weekends draw the biggest crowds, while Monday is calm.
5. Stoll’s Lakeview Restaurant, Loogootee, IN
A buffet with a lake view is not something you find every day in rural southern Indiana. Stoll’s Lakeview Restaurant on US-231 in Loogootee offers just that, with Amish and American cooking for breakfast, lunch, and dinner.
Fried chicken leads the lineup. Next to it you will find buttered noodles, mashed potatoes, gravy, dressing, and mac and cheese, which makes building a noodles-over-potatoes plate easy.
Vegetables like corn, green beans, and Brussels sprouts add some balance. A salad bar helps too.
Desserts lean classic with pecan, cherry, and chocolate pie, plus bread pudding. Prices sit around $10 to $20 per person.
Opening times vary, so check before you go. It opens at 10:30 AM Monday through Thursday, 8 AM Friday, and 7:30 AM Saturday, closing at 8 or 8:30 PM.
Sunday is closed, and reservations are accepted.
6. Nick’s Kitchen, Huntington, IN
Here is the one twist on the list: Nick’s Kitchen closes at 2 PM. So this cold-weather fix works best as a hearty lunch before the evening chill sets in.
The Huntington diner on North Jefferson Street is best known for its breaded pork tenderloin sandwiches. Still, the chicken and noodles are a strong reason to visit, and the mashed potatoes hold their own too.
The menu stays classic small-town. Think chicken pot pie, biscuits and gravy, a tenderloin biscuit, and a meatloaf sandwich with fries.
Homemade pies close things out.
Service is quick and friendly, and the room has a historic hometown feel. Most meals cost $10 to $20.
Nick’s is open every day from 7 AM to 2 PM. Friday and Saturday mornings get busy, and parking can be tricky, so give yourself a few extra minutes.
Enjoyed this story?
Add Fast Food Club as a preferred source to see more of our reporting on Google.