Fast Food Club Fast Food Club

Four South Carolina Pie Shops Where Grandmothers’ Recipes Still Fill The Case

Elias Camden 5 min read
featured image 29b4d2583cf3 a9075d784a06
Four South Carolina Pie Shops Where Grandmothers' Recipes Still Fill The Case

Some of the best pies in South Carolina come from recipe cards that once sat in a grandmother’s kitchen drawer. Across the state, a handful of small shops still bake that way, with crusts made by hand and fillings that follow old family methods.

These four spots stretch from the Upstate to the coast and down into the Lowcountry. Each one earns its place for a different reason, so keep reading to find the pie stop that fits your next road trip.

1. Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop Greenville, Greenville, SC

Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop Greenville, Greenville, SC
© Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop Greenville, Greenville, SC

Two grandmothers, known in the family as Granny and Nanny, are the quiet backbone of this shop. The core lineup of pies is built on traditional recipes handed down from them to the founders.

You will find Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop at 2222 Augusta St #9, Greenville, SC 29605. It is a charming neighborhood spot that bakes scratch-made pies in two sizes, full and personal mini.

The minis are a smart move for anyone who cannot pick just one flavor. Grab a few and turn the drive home into a tasting session.

Crust is the real star here. Staff are happy to walk guests through the handmade crust and pie process, and samples are often offered at the counter.

Coconut cream is a standout in the case. The I-40 is another one to try, since it puts a twist on pecan pie that sets it apart from the usual lineup.

Coffee is available too, which makes a pie break feel complete. Free wi-fi and a restroom add to the easy, quaint setup.

Hours run Monday through Saturday from 10 AM to 6 PM, and the shop is closed Sunday. Delivery, pickup, and takeout are all options, and parking is in a paid lot nearby.

Plan on a quick stop, though leaving with only one box is a challenge few people win.

2. Jupiter Pies, Myrtle Beach, SC

Jupiter Pies, Myrtle Beach, SC
© Jupiter Pies, Myrtle Beach, SC

Beach traffic on SC-707 has a sweet reward waiting at 9261 SC-707 B in Myrtle Beach. Jupiter Pies is a family-owned bakery that turns out a wide variety of handmade pies and fresh pastries.

The pies here are made from scratch, the old way a grandmother would do it. That homemade crust is the foundation for everything in the case.

Variety is the big draw. Fruit pies, nut pies, and cream pies share space with a savory tomato pie, a classic Southern dish that many shops skip.

Presentation gets real care, so these pies look ready for a holiday table. Prices stay friendly, with most people spending around $10 to $20.

Here is a handy bonus for road trippers. Jupiter Pies has a drive-through, along with takeout, in-store pickup, and a free parking lot.

Hours are Tuesday through Saturday from 10 AM to 5 PM, closed Sunday and Monday. Afternoons on Wednesday, Thursday, and Saturday tend to be the busiest.

Friday and Saturday mornings are usually calmer, so an early visit means first pick of the case. Grab a coffee too, and the pie plan is set.

3. The Corner Pie Company, Seneca, SC

The Corner Pie Company, Seneca, SC
© The Corner Pie Company

Short hours make this little bakery feel like a well-kept secret. The Corner Pie Company opens Tuesday through Saturday from 11 AM to 3 PM, so timing matters.

The shop sits on E North 1st St in Seneca, SC 29678, in the heart of the Upstate lake country. It is a pie specialty bakery through and through, with scratch-made crusts and fillings.

The owner is friendly and hands-on, and that personal touch shows in every pie. The case leans into heritage Southern flavors baked with family-style methods.

Apple pie is a dependable classic here. Key lime and peanut butter pies also hold steady fans.

Blueberry buttermilk is the one that tends to surprise newcomers. It is an old-fashioned flavor that is getting harder to find.

The Kentucky Derby pie rounds out the list for anyone who loves a rich, nutty slice.

Coffee is on hand, and most trips here are quick. Takeout and in-store shopping are the options, and there is no delivery.

Arrive before the afternoon wraps up, because a 3 PM closing comes faster than expected.

4. Carolina Cider Company & Clockwise Coffee, Yemassee, SC

Carolina Cider Company & Clockwise Coffee, Yemassee, SC
© Carolina Cider Company & Clockwise Coffee, Yemassee, SC

Not every great pie stop calls itself a pie shop. Carolina Cider Company and Clockwise Coffee is a roadside market at 81 Charleston Hwy in Yemassee, SC 29945.

The store sits along Highway 17 in the South Carolina Lowcountry. It runs as a multi-generational country store with a step-back-in-time feel.

Ciders are the heart of the place, including apple, peach, cherry, and seasonal varieties. The pie selection holds its own right beside them.

Pecan, key lime, and cherry pies are regulars in the case. Apple cider donuts, scones, and banana bread fill out the bakery side, and gluten-free options are available.

Flowers and other food items are sold here too. That mix makes it a fun place to browse for a few extra minutes.

Doors open every day from 8 AM to 6 PM, which is great news for weekend drivers. Weekends get busy, while Monday and Tuesday are usually quieter.

Parking options are plentiful, and restrooms include a gender-neutral one. It is an easy break on a coastal drive.

Take home a pie and a jug of cider, and the trip will be remembered long after the last slice.

Enjoyed this story?

Add Fast Food Club as a preferred source to see more of our reporting on Google.

Follow us on Google

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *