Tucked into downtown Gainesville, Georgia, there is a little pie shop that has folks driving across county lines just for a single slice. Southern Baked Pie Company makes its pies by hand, and its buttery pecan pie has earned a loyal following of dessert lovers.
With a 4.5-star rating from 175 reviews, it has become something of a local treasure. Let me walk you through what makes this cozy spot worth a stop.
Finding the Shop on Broad Street
Right in the heart of downtown Gainesville, you will find Southern Baked Pie Company at 302 Broad St SE. It sits close to the walkable stretch of shops and restaurants that make this part of town so easy to explore on foot.
Plenty of folks discover it the way one visitor did, by stopping at a nearby restaurant for lunch and wandering over afterward. Others have passed it many times, assuming it was just a sweet little pie shop, only to be pleasantly surprised once they stepped inside.
The location works in its favor. Downtown parking, friendly neighbors, and steady foot traffic mean the shop stays busy with both curious first-timers and devoted regulars.
If you find yourself near downtown Gainesville, one guest put it simply: give it a look.
A Homemade Butter Crust Worth the Work
Ask the regulars what keeps them coming back, and the crust often comes up before the filling ever does. One longtime fan said you can literally eat the crust by itself, it is that good.
The butter really is the star here. More than one guest mentioned they could taste the butter right through the flaky layers, and several described the crust as buttery deliciousness that practically melts in your mouth.
A homemade butter crust is genuine work, and one visitor who bakes her own pies at home acknowledged as much. She figured the price was fair once she thought about the effort behind a proper handmade crust.
That kind of craftsmanship shows up in the finished product.
The Pecan Pie That Built the Reputation
If there is one pie that people cross town for, it is the pecan. It gets mentioned more than any other item, and the praise runs deep.
One self-described pecan pie connoisseur, who claims to eat around 25 pecan pies a year, called this one the benchmark he judges all others against. He admitted feeling a little sticker shock at nearly $40, but said the first bite won him over completely.
Another visitor marveled that the pecans were the biggest he had ever seen in a pecan pie. From casual snackers to serious fans, the verdict lines up again and again: this may be the best pecan pie around, homemade or store bought.
Caramel Pecan and Other Sweet Standouts
Beyond the classic pecan, the sweet lineup gives visitors plenty to explore. The caramel pecan pie earns its own following, often bought when the shop runs a buy-one-get-one deal.
The chocolate pie has its die-hard fans too. One guest stopped in on a whim, took a recommendation for the chocolate pie, and left calling it a 10 out of 10.
The chocolate chess pie is another favorite, singled out by a husband whose wife adores it.
Buttermilk pie, apple, cherry, and chocolate chess all get regular mentions. With so many flavors on rotation, it is easy to find a slice that suits your sweet tooth, whether you lean toward fruit fillings or rich custards.
Savory Pies for the Dinner Table
Not every pie here is dessert. The savory side of the menu has become a real draw, especially the famous chicken pot pie.
One guest described its crust as flaky and its filling as creamy, cooked to perfection. The pot roast pie also gets strong reviews, with a customer calling it very good quality even when another pie in the same order missed the mark.
These heartier pies make the shop more than a dessert stop. You can walk out with dinner and dessert both, which is exactly what several first-time visitors ended up doing after chatting with the staff.
Minis and Samples for the Curious
Feeling indecisive? The shop makes it easy to test the waters before committing to a full pie.
Minis let you try flavors like pecan and coconut in smaller portions.
Sampling is part of the experience here. One visitor got to taste the pecan pie before buying, and called that touch very nice.
Another raved about a strawberry pie sample she tried right there in the store, saying it was the best flavor of the day.
These little tastes have converted more than a few skeptics. Getting a bite before you buy takes the guesswork out, and it turns a quick errand into something more fun.
Gluten-Free Options You Might Not Expect
Here is a pleasant surprise many people miss. The shop offers gluten-free options, which caught one visitor completely off guard.
She had been passing by for years, assuming she could not eat anything there because she is gluten free. Then a friendly staffer named Eddie, handing out samples out front, let her know they had choices for her.
She ended up buying several, including a tomato pie and a pecan pie, and called them incredibly delicious. For anyone who usually has to skip the bakery, that kind of inclusion turns a passerby into a returning customer.
Walking Into a Warm Little Space
Step through the door and the mood changes fast. One regular described walking in as being like a big hug, a slice of pie heaven.
The displays are thoughtfully arranged, and visitors often note how good it looks and smells. Someone who bought five pies at once said the whole store was filled with the fragrance of deliciousness.
Cozy is the word that comes up over and over. It is the kind of small space that makes you want to linger, chat with whoever is behind the counter, and take your time deciding what to bring home.
The Friendly Faces Behind the Counter
Good pie is only half the story here. The people who serve it get nearly as much praise as the food itself.
Staff members like Abby and Diane are described as knowledgeable about the products, happy to guide first-timers through the menu. One guest summed it up by saying the staff is always helpful and smiling.
That warmth extends beyond the shop walls too. A team member named Jason went the extra mile helping with a catering order, even stopping by a customer’s nearby office with samples to introduce himself.
Small touches like that build the kind of loyalty this shop enjoys.
Catering and Community Deliveries
The shop’s reach goes well past its front counter. Catering has become a real strength, with one customer calling the service a 1000 out of 10 after Jason smoothed out an order and made sure it arrived on time.
There is a community-minded streak here too. Pies are personally delivered to The Beehive, a Gainesville assisted living residence, on a regular basis.
The residents love them and look forward to each visit.
Those kinds of gestures show a business that thinks about its neighbors. Whether it is an office event or a treat for seniors, the shop clearly values showing up in person.
Mail Order Pies Shipped Across the Country
Can’t make it to Gainesville? The shop ships nationwide, which is how plenty of folks get their fix from far away.
When packing goes right, the results impress. One customer who ordered five pies for mailing noted they shipped with plenty of dry ice and arrived in great shape.
Shipping does add cost, so a tip worth remembering: several reviewers suggest clicking the delivery insurance option when you order. It gives you peace of mind if a carrier takes the scenic route with your box, and it is a small step that can save a lot of frustration.
What You Can Expect to Pay
Let’s talk honestly about cost, because it comes up in nearly every conversation about this place. These are premium pies, with whole ones running around $39 and slices priced fairly for a quick treat.
Opinions split here. Some feel the prices are steep, and a few said they would rather bake at home to save money.
Others counter that a handmade butter crust is real work and the quality earns the price tag.
The pecan pie fans tend to land firmly in the worth-it camp. As one guest put it, he felt ripped off spending nearly $40 until the first bite changed his mind entirely.
Come knowing it is a splurge, and let the flavor make the case.
Hours, Location, and Planning Your Visit
Planning a trip is easy once you know the schedule. The shop is open Monday through Friday from 10 AM to 6 PM, with shorter Saturday hours of 10 AM to 3 PM.
It is closed on Sundays.
You will find it at 302 Broad St SE in downtown Gainesville, and you can call ahead at 678-971-2555 or browse the website at southernbakedpie.com. Around the holidays, one seasoned visitor offered smart advice: place an advance order, or you may be left picking from whatever is still on the shelf late in the day.
Getting there is simple thanks to the downtown setting. Pair your pie run with a stroll through the surrounding shops and eateries.
Is It Worth the Trip?
So where does all this leave you? With a shop that has earned devoted fans, a few honest critics, and a pecan pie that keeps drawing people back.
The prices are on the higher side, and a handful of mail order experiences have hit bumps, though the team has often worked to make things right afterward. What shines through most is the handmade care, the buttery crust, and the warm welcome that regulars describe as pure pie heaven.
If you love a proper Southern pecan pie and appreciate a cozy small business, this one belongs on your list. Bring your appetite, maybe grab a mini to sample first, and see why so many Georgia pie fans make the drive.
Enjoyed this story?
Add Fast Food Club as a preferred source to see more of our reporting on Google.