Tucked along Route 23 in Sussex, New Jersey, Holland American Bakery is the kind of place that feels like a warm hug the moment you walk through the door. Since the 1950s, this family-owned gem has been serving authentic Dutch pastries, fresh-baked breads, and custom cakes that keep locals coming back week after week.
With a 4.8-star rating and hundreds of glowing reviews, it’s clear that this small bakery punches way above its weight. Whether you’re a first-time visitor or a longtime regular, here are 13 reasons why Holland American Bakery deserves a top spot on your must-visit list.
The Legendary Cronuts That Started a Local Obsession
Fair warning: you will not be able to eat just one. Holland American Bakery’s cronuts have developed a near-cult following among locals, and one bite tells you exactly why.
These gloriously flaky, perfectly fried pastries come in flavors like maple, glazed, cinnamon sugar, and chocolate — each one more irresistible than the last.
Reviewers consistently describe them as addictive, and many visitors make a special trip just for a dozen of these beauties. The maple variety seems to win the most hearts, though the glazed version has its loyal fans too.
If you’re visiting for the first time, grab a mixed box so you can try every flavor. The cronuts sell out fast, especially on weekends, so arriving early is strongly recommended.
Trust the crowd on this one — these are genuinely unforgettable.
Fresh Breakfast Sandwiches Worth the Drive From NYC
One visitor drove all the way from New York City and left completely blown away by a simple egg and cheese on a poppy seed roll. That says everything you need to know about Holland American Bakery’s breakfast sandwiches.
The rolls are baked fresh in-house, giving them a light, pillowy texture that store-bought bread simply cannot match.
The egg filling is described as fluffy and melt-in-your-mouth — the kind of breakfast that makes you close your eyes on the first bite. Paired with a cup of coffee (which, by the way, costs just 25 cents), this is one of the most satisfying and affordable breakfast experiences in all of Sussex County.
Morning hours fill up quickly, so plan to arrive when the bakery opens at 6 AM on weekdays. You’ll leave full, happy, and already planning your return visit.
Custom Cakes That Save the Day (Literally)
One mom’s cake maker got injured just days before her son’s first birthday party. In a panic, she called Holland American Bakery on a Tuesday — and by the weekend, she had a stunning half-sheet cake and a smash cake that looked exactly the way she had imagined.
That kind of fast, reliable, and talented service is rare.
The cakes here are light and airy, with frosting that customers describe as having a subtle sea salt quality that makes it uniquely delicious. Baby shower cakes, birthday cakes, and celebration cakes all get the same careful attention to detail and flavor.
Ordering a custom cake from a supermarket starts to feel like a real mistake once you’ve tasted what Holland American Bakery can do. Prices are reasonable, the quality is exceptional, and the staff genuinely cares about making your special event memorable.
Mocha Buttercream Cake That Stops Conversations
Somebody brought a mocha buttercream cake from Holland American Bakery to a party, and the guest who tasted it immediately declared it the best cake she had ever eaten in her life. Strong words — but completely believable once you understand how this bakery operates.
Every layer is crafted with care, and the buttercream is smooth, rich, and deeply flavored without being overpoweringly sweet.
This cake has a way of making people wish they lived closer to Sussex. One reviewer joked that she was actually relieved she didn’t live nearby, because she’d eat it every single day without hesitation.
Whether you’re picking up a full cake for a gathering or just a slice for yourself, the mocha buttercream is a must-try. It’s the kind of dessert that ruins you for ordinary cakes — in the very best possible way.
Old-Fashioned Donuts Done the Right Way
There’s something deeply comforting about a perfectly made old-fashioned donut. Holland American Bakery has been getting this right for decades, and their version has a crispy outer edge with a soft, cake-like interior that feels nostalgic in the best way.
No fancy toppings needed — just honest, classic baking at its finest.
Regulars who have been visiting since the 1980s and 1990s say the quality has never wavered. That kind of consistency is incredibly rare in any food business, and it speaks volumes about the dedication of the team behind the counter.
Pair one of these donuts with a cup of their famously affordable coffee, and you’ve got yourself a morning treat that costs almost nothing but delivers enormous satisfaction. Simple pleasures done exceptionally well are what Holland American Bakery has always been about, and the old-fashioned donut is a perfect example.
Crumb Cake So Good It Disappears Before You Can Share It
Word travels fast when something is truly special. Holland American Bakery’s crumb cake has spread by reputation alone — people hear about it from a friend, make the trip, and immediately understand the hype.
One reviewer arrived just in time to snag the very last small piece, and his wife devoured it before he even had a chance to try any.
That kind of enthusiastic response tells you everything. The crumb topping is thick and buttery, the cake underneath is tender and moist, and the whole thing has a homemade quality that store-bought versions can never replicate.
Crumb cake tends to sell out earlier in the day, especially on Saturdays. If this is on your must-try list — and it absolutely should be — arrive in the morning and ask the staff what’s freshest.
You won’t walk away disappointed, but you might walk away wishing you’d bought two pieces.
Authentic Rye Bread and Gingerbread Cookies From a True Dutch Tradition
Holland American Bakery isn’t just about sweets — the bread selection is equally impressive. Their rye bread earns consistent praise from customers who describe it as genuinely delicious and full of authentic flavor.
It’s the kind of loaf that makes a simple sandwich feel like a special occasion.
The gingerbread cookies are another standout. Reviewers call them the very best they’ve ever had, with a spiced warmth and satisfying texture that keeps people coming back for more.
These aren’t your average holiday cookies — they’re a year-round treat made with real skill and traditional Dutch recipes.
The bakery has been open since the 1950s, which means these recipes have been refined over generations. That depth of experience shows in every bite.
If you’re unsure where to start on your first visit, the staff often recommends the cinnamon bread as a crowd-pleasing introduction to the full lineup.
Chocolate-Covered Croissants That Convert Non-Believers
A contractor once brought a box of Holland American Bakery’s croissants to a job site, and one of the workers had never tried a croissant before in his life. One bite of the chocolate-covered version later, and he was ready to drive all the way to Sussex himself.
That’s the power of a truly excellent croissant.
The layers are shatteringly flaky on the outside and tender on the inside, with a rich chocolate coating that adds just the right amount of sweetness. These aren’t the dry, bland croissants you find pre-packaged at gas stations — they’re the real deal, made fresh with care and expertise.
Holland American Bakery’s croissants work as a breakfast treat, an afternoon snack, or even a dessert. Once you’ve had one, the idea of settling for anything less feels genuinely disappointing.
Grab a few — you’ll want extras for the ride home.
Dutch Gifts and Imported Treats That Make It a Destination Shop
Walking into Holland American Bakery feels like stepping into a little corner of the Netherlands. Beyond the pastries and breads, the shop carries Dutch figurines, imported candies, decorative items, and a surprisingly extensive selection of black licorice — including the sour and salty European varieties that are nearly impossible to find anywhere else in New Jersey.
For anyone with Dutch heritage or a love of European culture, this shop is genuinely exciting. The gift items make wonderful souvenirs or presents, and the imported sweets offer flavors that most American candy stores simply don’t carry.
Reviewers describe the shop as a charming, old-time experience that transports you somewhere special the moment you walk in. It’s been operating since the 1950s and still carries that warm, family-run character throughout every corner.
Plan to browse — there are interesting things to discover tucked all around the store.
The Friday Fish Fry Food Truck That Locals Look Forward To All Week
Every Friday during Lent, something special happens in the parking lot of Holland American Bakery. A food truck rolls out and starts serving fresh fried fish to a crowd of regulars who have been looking forward to it all week.
It’s become a beloved local tradition that pairs perfectly with the bakery’s already warm, community-centered atmosphere.
The fish is consistently praised for being delicious and priced very reasonably — two qualities that are increasingly hard to find together. Longtime customers describe it as one of their favorite seasonal rituals, something they genuinely anticipate each year.
The food truck also reflects the bakery’s values as a Christian-owned business, often sharing a Bible verse alongside the meal. Whether or not that’s your tradition, the food itself is worth showing up for.
Arrive early on Fridays during the Lenten season, because the line tends to grow quickly.
Friendly Staff Who Make Every Visit Feel Personal
Great food alone doesn’t build a loyal following that spans decades — the people behind the counter matter just as much. At Holland American Bakery, the staff is consistently described as warm, attentive, and genuinely happy to be there.
Customers mention specific team members by name in their reviews, which is a rare and telling sign of just how much the human connection means here.
One visitor from New York City mentioned that a staff member named Leah was a vibrant, welcoming presence who made the whole experience even more enjoyable. Others mention Jane and Kelsey with equal affection.
These aren’t just employees going through the motions — they’re people who clearly take pride in representing the bakery.
That consistent friendliness, visit after visit and year after year, is a big part of why so many customers describe Holland American Bakery as a true gem in Sussex County.
Unbeatable Prices That Make Quality Accessible to Everyone
A 25-cent cup of coffee. Cronuts and pastries at prices that feel almost too good to be true.
Custom cakes that cost a fraction of what a big-city bakery would charge. Holland American Bakery has built a reputation not just for exceptional quality but for making that quality accessible to everyone who walks through the door.
Reviewers repeatedly express surprise at how much they get for their money. One customer described everything as insanely good and super cheap, especially considering that every item is freshly made from scratch using traditional Dutch recipes.
That combination of authenticity and affordability is genuinely rare.
For families, day-trippers, or anyone who wants to treat themselves without breaking the bank, this bakery delivers outstanding value. It’s the kind of place where you can walk in with a modest budget and walk out with a box full of incredible things.
That’s a gift worth celebrating.
A Bakery With Decades of History and Heart in Sussex County
Some businesses feel like they’ve always been part of a community — because they actually have been. Holland American Bakery has been a Sussex County institution since the 1950s, serving generations of families with the same authentic Dutch recipes and genuine hospitality that made it famous in the first place.
That kind of staying power doesn’t happen by accident.
Open Tuesday through Saturday from 6 AM to 6 PM, the bakery keeps a schedule that rewards early risers and dedicated fans willing to make the trip. Located at 246 Route 23 in Sussex, it’s a manageable drive from many parts of northern New Jersey and even parts of New York.
With a 4.8-star rating built on nearly 700 reviews, the numbers back up what locals have always known. Holland American Bakery isn’t just a place to buy bread — it’s a place to feel at home, one delicious bite at a time.
Enjoyed this story?
Add Fast Food Club as a preferred source to see more of our reporting on Google.