Tucked beneath street level in Carbondale, Illinois, Underground Public House is the kind of place you almost walk right past — and then never stop thinking about. This laid-back gastropub at 717 S University Ave has earned a loyal following among locals who rave about its rotating craft beers, locally sourced food, and genuinely welcoming atmosphere.
With a 4.4-star rating from over 630 reviews, it’s clear this spot is doing something very right. Whether you’re a first-timer or a regular, here are 13 reasons why people just can’t stop talking about Underground Public House.
A Hidden Gem Literally Below Street Level
Walking past 717 S University Ave, most people would never guess what’s waiting below. Underground Public House is literally underground — once you step through the street-level entrance, you descend into a cozy, dimly lit world that feels completely separate from the everyday bustle of Carbondale.
One traveler passing through town wrote that finding it was “a little challenging” but “worth the hunt.” That sense of discovery is part of what makes this place so memorable. There’s something exciting about stumbling onto a spot that feels like a secret only locals know.
The moody, intimate setting immediately signals that this isn’t your average bar or restaurant. Dark tones, warm lighting, and a vibey atmosphere greet you the moment you arrive.
It’s the kind of place that makes you feel like you’ve found something truly special — because you have.
Craft Beer Selection That Keeps Rotating
Beer lovers, take note — the tap list at Underground Public House is never boring. The rotating craft beer selection means something new is always waiting for you, and regulars often return just to see what’s on draft this week.
One reviewer described the beer selection as “out of this world,” while another mentioned a green-colored beer called Nerdy Dancing that apparently tastes like a Nerds rope candy. That’s the kind of fun, unexpected experience this place delivers consistently.
Whether you’re a hophead, a sour fan, or someone who just wants something cold and interesting, the bar team has you covered. The staff is knowledgeable and happy to help you find the perfect pour.
Did you know? Rotating tap lists are a hallmark of serious craft beer bars — and Underground Public House takes that reputation seriously every single week.
Scotch Eggs Worth Every Single Bite
If there’s one appetizer that comes up again and again in reviews of Underground Public House, it’s the Scotch eggs. Multiple guests have given them a perfect 10 out of 10, and once you try them, you’ll completely understand why.
These aren’t your average Scotch eggs. The Underground version wraps Oktoberfest house sausage and smoked Gouda in an Oktoberfest pretzel crust — a combination that sounds almost too creative to work, and yet somehow nails it every single time.
One reviewer said simply: “Scotch eggs, perfect.”
Appetizers like this show what sets Underground apart from typical bar food. There’s genuine thought and craft behind each dish, and the kitchen clearly takes pride in its creations.
If you’re visiting for the first time, ordering the Scotch eggs is basically a requirement. Don’t skip them — you’d seriously regret it.
The Pork Belly Reuben Is Pure Magic
Nicknamed the P.B.R. on the menu, the Pork Belly Reuben at Underground Public House has developed a near-legendary reputation among regulars. Built on scratch brewery rye bread and layered with kimchi kraut, local cheese, and house-made dressing, this sandwich is a full-on flavor experience.
One guest raved that the pork belly was “amazing quality, loaded with flavor, so tender” — and that description barely scratches the surface. The combination of smoky pork belly with tangy kimchi and rich rye bread is the kind of thing food dreams are made of.
Portions here are generous, so don’t be surprised if you’re taking half home for tomorrow’s lunch. The P.B.R. is a great example of how Underground takes familiar comfort food and elevates it into something genuinely memorable.
Order it once, and it’ll become your go-to every single visit.
Filet Mignon That Rivals Big-City Steakhouses
Ordering a filet mignon at a gastropub might seem unexpected, but Underground Public House makes it work beautifully. Reviewers have praised the steak quality repeatedly, with one guest calling the ribeye “the best steak either of us have ever eaten” — a bold claim that plenty of others seem to back up.
Another diner raved about the filet mignon specifically, noting it was exceptional alongside one of the restaurant’s creative cocktails. When a small-town Illinois gastropub earns that kind of praise for its steakhouse-caliber cuts, you know something special is happening in that kitchen.
The steaks here are clearly sourced with care, cooked with precision, and plated with intention. Whether you’re celebrating an anniversary or just treating yourself on a Friday night, ordering the filet mignon at Underground is a decision you’ll feel very good about.
Bring your appetite — and maybe a date.
Cocktails That Are Creative and On Point
Underground Public House doesn’t just take its beer seriously — the cocktail menu is equally impressive. From whiskey sours that one guest called “awesome” to creative concoctions like the Black and Blue Daily, the drink program here is thoughtful and well-executed.
The bartenders clearly know their craft. Whether you’re sipping something classic or adventuring into the more inventive offerings, the drinks are consistently well-balanced and satisfying.
One reviewer noted spending more than expected on cocktails — and said it was absolutely worth every penny.
Seasonal and rotating specials keep things exciting, so even frequent visitors have something new to look forward to. If you’re a cocktail enthusiast who also loves great food, Underground Public House checks every single box.
Pro tip: arrive with a curious mindset and let the staff guide you toward something you’ve never tried before. You probably won’t be disappointed.
Locally Sourced Ingredients Make a Real Difference
One thing that sets Underground Public House apart from typical bar-and-grill spots is its commitment to using locally sourced ingredients. From scratch brewery rye bread to regional cheeses and fresh produce, the kitchen leans on local suppliers to build its menu — and you can taste the difference.
Reviewers frequently mention how fresh everything feels. One guest described the beet salad as “so fresh it’s outrageous,” which is the kind of compliment that speaks directly to ingredient quality.
When a restaurant cares about where its food comes from, the entire dining experience feels more intentional and honest.
Supporting local also means the menu can shift with the seasons, keeping things dynamic and interesting visit after visit. Underground’s approach to sourcing reflects a broader community spirit — one that values Carbondale’s local economy and food culture.
That kind of philosophy resonates deeply with guests who care about more than just what’s on their plate.
Atmosphere That Feels Like a Cool City Spot
“Underground Public House makes you feel like you’ve stumbled into a cool city spot without leaving town.” That’s how one reviewer summed up the vibe — and honestly, it’s hard to say it better. The dark, moody interior creates an atmosphere that feels both sophisticated and completely relaxed at the same time.
It’s the kind of place where date night feels effortlessly special, but you’d also be comfortable grabbing a casual beer after work. The balance between chic and welcoming is rare, and Underground nails it.
String lights, dim lamps, and intimate seating arrangements all contribute to the overall mood.
Whether you’re seated inside at a cozy table or enjoying the outdoor seating area on a gorgeous evening, the setting enhances every bite and every sip. Atmosphere matters more than people realize, and this place understands that completely.
Come for the food, stay for the feeling.
Service That Guests Actually Rave About
Good food matters, but great service is what turns a dinner into a memory. At Underground Public House, the staff consistently earns high praise from guests across dozens of reviews.
Words like “excellent,” “attentive,” “friendly,” and “knowledgeable” pop up again and again when people describe their experience with the team.
One guest gave the service a perfect ten stars — separate from the already glowing food review. Another mentioned that the waiter was “awesome” and made the entire meal feel special from start to finish.
That kind of consistent human warmth is something no algorithm can replicate.
There’s also a tip jar specifically for the kitchen staff, which the restaurant encourages guests to notice. That small detail says a lot about the culture here — one that values every person behind the experience.
When a restaurant’s front-of-house and back-of-house both shine, the whole visit becomes something worth talking about.
Generous Portions That Feed You Twice
At Underground Public House, nobody leaves hungry. Reviewers consistently mention being surprised — and delighted — by how large the portions are.
One guest noted that the pork schnitzel sandwich was “about the size of my head,” and even admitted taking three-quarters of it home after a full meal.
Another diner pointed out that a single entree could easily stretch into two meals, making the mid-range price point feel even more reasonable. When you’re getting restaurant-quality food in portions that generous, the value becomes hard to argue with.
This isn’t a place where you leave still thinking about food. You leave full, satisfied, and already planning your next visit.
The kitchen doesn’t cut corners on quantity or quality, which is a combination that keeps people coming back. Pack your appetite, and maybe plan to skip breakfast the next morning — leftovers from Underground are worth waking up to.
Perfect for Date Night or Special Celebrations
From anniversaries to birthdays to first dates, Underground Public House has become Carbondale’s go-to destination for special evenings. The intimate atmosphere, creative menu, and attentive service create a combination that feels genuinely celebratory without being stuffy or overly formal.
Multiple reviewers have specifically called it “perfect for date night,” and it’s easy to see why. The dim lighting, cozy seating, and impressive drink menu all set the stage for a memorable evening.
One guest even said they left wondering “why every night out isn’t like this” — which is about the highest compliment a restaurant can receive.
The restaurant also runs rotating weekend specials that give returning couples something new to look forward to each visit. If you’re planning something special, making a reservation in advance is strongly recommended — this place fills up fast, especially on weekends.
A little planning goes a long way here.
Make a Reservation — Seriously, Don’t Skip This Step
Here’s a piece of advice that shows up in nearly every glowing review of Underground Public House: make a reservation before you go. This spot is small, popular, and fills up quickly — especially on weekends.
Showing up without one is a gamble that doesn’t always pay off.
One group of reviewers used four exclamation points to drive the point home: “Remember to make a reservation!!!!” Another couple made their booking in advance specifically because they knew how busy it gets. The restaurant is open Wednesday through Saturday evenings, and Sunday afternoons — so plan accordingly.
Calling ahead at +1 618-490-1586 or visiting undergroundpublichouse.net takes just a few minutes and saves a lot of disappointment. Think of it less as a chore and more as an investment in a great night out.
The people who plan ahead are the ones who get to enjoy every single thing this place has to offer.
A Community-Minded Spot That Gives Back
Underground Public House isn’t just a restaurant — it’s a community institution. Regulars frequently mention how much the spot supports local suppliers, small businesses, and the broader Carbondale community.
One longtime fan wrote that they were “highly impressed” by the restaurant’s commitment to building something meaningful in their town.
That community spirit shows up in small but meaningful ways: locally sourced bread from Scratch Brewery, regional cheeses, and a kitchen tip jar that reminds guests the whole team makes the magic happen. These aren’t just marketing moves — they reflect a genuine philosophy about what a neighborhood restaurant should be.
When a business earns the label “diamond in the rough” from its own regulars, you know it’s doing something right beyond just cooking good food. Underground Public House has built real loyalty in Carbondale by being authentic, consistent, and genuinely invested in the people it serves every single week.
Enjoyed this story?
Add Fast Food Club as a preferred source to see more of our reporting on Google.