Tucked away in Lewisville, Texas, Motor City Pizza has been quietly earning a massive reputation as one of the best pizza spots in the entire state. With a 4.8-star rating from nearly 900 reviews, this Detroit-style pizza joint is clearly doing something right.
Locals and out-of-towners alike are making hour-long drives just to get a taste, and once you hear what they have to say, you will completely understand why.
Detroit-Style Deep Dish Pizza That Hits Different
Some pizzas are good. Motor City Pizza’s Detroit-style deep dish is the kind that makes people drive an hour without a single complaint.
The square-shaped pies come out with crispy, buttery edges and a thick yet surprisingly airy crust that never feels heavy or doughy.
Reviewers rave about the balance of flavors — the sauce is not too sweet, not too acidic, and the cheese is noticeably high quality. One customer described it as the closest thing to authentic Detroit pizza outside of Michigan itself.
Whether you order the classic pepperoni or something more adventurous, the deep dish at Motor City delivers a satisfying experience every single time. For anyone who has never tried this style before, prepare to have your pizza world turned upside down in the best possible way.
The Detroiter — A Signature Worth the Drive
Ask almost any regular at Motor City Pizza what to order on your first visit and they will point you straight to The Detroiter. This flagship pizza comes in several sizes — including the popular 8-Cylinder — and showcases everything that makes Detroit-style pizza legendary.
The crust is crisp and buttery on the outside while staying pillowy and tender inside. Topped with premium pepperoni and a perfectly seasoned sauce, every bite feels intentional and crafted with care.
One reviewer said the cheese and pepperoni were “noticeably of high quality,” which is exactly the kind of detail that separates great pizza from unforgettable pizza.
If you are visiting for the first time, The Detroiter is your starting point. It sets the standard and makes a compelling case for why locals consider this place the best pizza destination in all of Texas.
Motown Supreme — Loaded and Legendary
When you want a pizza that feels like a full celebration on a plate, the Motown Supreme is calling your name. This deep dish monster is piled with toppings and built on that signature Motor City crust that locals cannot stop talking about.
One family who visited after seeing the restaurant featured on local news ordered the Motown Supreme and could not stop raving about it. They said it was “an absolute delight” — high praise from people who were already impressed just by walking through the door.
The combination of toppings is bold and satisfying, making it a crowd-pleaser for groups with different tastes. Motor City Pizza does not cut corners on ingredients, and the Motown Supreme is proof of that commitment.
It is the kind of pizza that makes the whole table go quiet for a few glorious minutes.
Gluten-Free Crust That Actually Tastes Amazing
Gluten-free pizza has a reputation for being a sad compromise — cardboard-like crusts and textures that disappoint. Motor City Pizza completely flips that script with a gluten-free crust that has customers genuinely shocked by how good it is.
One reviewer who tried the Gluten Free Detroiter said he had never had a gluten-free crust taste that good, adding that the texture was truly impressive. With over 12 gluten-free pizza options on the menu, Motor City makes it easy for guests with dietary restrictions to enjoy the full experience without feeling like they are settling.
Another visitor from Chicago called the gluten-free crust “perfect — crispy, not soggy or dense.” That is a serious compliment from someone who grew up around legendary pizza culture. Motor City Pizza proves that eating gluten-free does not mean missing out on the real deal.
Wings That Steal the Show
Pizza might be the main attraction, but the wings at Motor City Pizza are quietly becoming a star in their own right. From the Tikka Masala Wings to the Cajun Dusted Wings and the Huli Huli variety, there is something on the wings menu for every kind of flavor lover.
One customer ordered the Tikka Masala Wings and described the flavor as “incredible and definitely unique” — not something you expect to find at a pizza restaurant in a Texas suburb. Another reviewer praised the Cajun Dusted Wings so much that they posted about them on Facebook to spread the word.
The wings come out with crunchy skin and moist, well-seasoned meat that holds up bite after bite. If you are planning a visit to Motor City Pizza, adding a wing order to your table is not optional — it is essential.
You will thank yourself later.
Specialty Pizzas That Push the Boundaries
Motor City Pizza is not afraid to get creative. Beyond the classics, the menu features specialty pies that turn heads and challenge what you think pizza can be.
The Frito Chili Pie Pizza, the B6 with smoked brisket and bacon, the Birria Pizza with chipotle cream, and the Texas Sweet Heat are just a few examples of the kitchen thinking outside the box.
One reviewer drove out specifically because she saw the Frito Chili Pie Pizza advertised on Facebook. Her verdict?
The food absolutely did not disappoint. Another customer called the B6 with smoked brisket and bacon one of the best pizzas he had ever eaten in his life.
These specialty options show that Motor City Pizza is not just riding on its Detroit-style reputation. The team is constantly pushing flavor boundaries, giving regulars new reasons to keep coming back and newcomers a reason to stay curious.
Fresh, House-Made Sauces and Ingredients
There is a reason the food at Motor City Pizza tastes noticeably different from your average pizza chain — everything is made in-house and with real care. The signature Boss Sauce marinara is a customer favorite, rich and deeply flavored in a way that store-bought sauce simply cannot replicate.
The restaurant also offers a roasted garlic and onion dipping sauce that reviewers describe as completely addictive. One longtime customer mentioned that the kitchen even grows their own fresh basil on-site, a small detail that speaks volumes about the restaurant’s commitment to quality.
Fresh ingredients show up in every layer of the pizza, from the ricotta on top of the Eastern Market to the perfectly balanced sauce underneath the cheese. When a kitchen cares this much about what goes into its food, you can taste the difference from the very first bite.
That is Motor City’s quiet superpower.
Warm Detroit Sports Bar Atmosphere
Walking into Motor City Pizza feels like stepping into a little slice of Detroit right in the heart of Texas. The Joe Louis Arena sign greets you near the entrance, and Michigan State and Red Wings memorabilia decorate the walls, giving the space a genuine sense of identity and personality.
Warm lighting, exposed wood accents, and a full bar setup create a relaxed and inviting atmosphere that works equally well for a casual weeknight dinner or a lively weekend outing with friends. Sports play on the TVs, making it a natural spot to catch a game while enjoying great food.
One reviewer noted that every detail of the decor gives the place “real character” — and that is exactly the right word for it. Motor City Pizza is not trying to be a generic restaurant.
It has a soul, a story, and an atmosphere that makes you want to linger a little longer.
Exceptional Staff That Make Every Visit Special
Great food can bring you in once, but great service is what turns a first visit into a lifetime habit. At Motor City Pizza, the staff consistently earn praise that rivals the compliments given to the pizza itself.
Servers like Jojo, Brad, and Amber come up repeatedly in reviews, each one described with real warmth and gratitude.
Brad kept a customer’s sweet tea topped off throughout his entire meal and made him feel like a welcomed regular on his very first visit. Jojo has been described as “the sweetest” by multiple reviewers who felt genuinely cared for.
Amber made a family celebrating a 16th birthday feel so comfortable that the staff sang happy birthday without being rushed.
That kind of hospitality is not something you can train into someone overnight. The team at Motor City Pizza clearly loves what they do, and it shows in every interaction from the moment you walk in.
Fried Calamari and Standout Appetizers
Before the pizza even arrives, Motor City Pizza gives you plenty of reasons to be excited about the meal ahead. The appetizer menu is stacked with options that reviewers consistently call the hidden highlights of the dining experience.
The fried calamari with sauce gets high marks for being light, crispy, and perfectly seasoned. The potato skin chicken strips paired with a French onion dipping sauce had one table ordering three separate servings of the sauce alone.
Fried mushrooms also earned enthusiastic praise, with reviewers noting that the batter is full of flavor rather than just being a bland coating.
One customer put it plainly: “The appetizers were where the real winner was.” For a pizza restaurant, having apps this good is almost unfair to the competition. Motor City Pizza treats every course of the meal as an opportunity to impress, and the appetizers deliver on that promise every time.
A Lunch Special That Offers Real Value
Not every visit to Motor City Pizza has to be a full sit-down dinner event. The restaurant offers a lunch special on select days that includes a salad, a slice, and a drink — a combination that gives you a genuine taste of what the kitchen does best at a price that feels fair.
The dinner garden salad has also received its own share of praise, described by one reviewer as “crisp, fresh, and a nice balance to the meal.” It is the kind of side dish that does not feel like an afterthought but rather a thoughtful addition to the overall dining experience.
Motor City Pizza is open for lunch Wednesday through Saturday starting at 11 AM, making it a solid midday destination for local workers and families alike. Getting there early also means beating the crowds, which tend to build up quickly — especially on weekends when the wait can get long.
Desserts Worth Saving Room For
Most people do not associate pizza restaurants with must-try desserts, but Motor City Pizza is here to change that assumption. The cannoli options on the dessert menu have been turning heads, with the S’mores Cannoli earning the title of “absolute favorite” from at least one very satisfied reviewer.
The Reese’s Cannoli brings a peanut butter twist that is bold and indulgent, though some guests prefer the lighter sweetness of the s’mores version. Either way, both options show that the kitchen applies the same creativity and quality to its desserts as it does to its pizzas.
Ending a meal at Motor City with one of these cannolis feels like a natural and rewarding conclusion to an already impressive dining experience. The next time you visit and feel tempted to skip dessert, do yourself a favor and order the S’mores Cannoli.
It is the kind of sweet finish that sticks with you long after the meal is done.
Why Locals and Out-of-Towners Keep Coming Back
A 4.8-star rating from nearly 900 reviews is not an accident — it is the result of consistently delivering excellent food, genuine hospitality, and a dining experience that feels special every single time. Motor City Pizza has built something rare in Lewisville, Texas: a local restaurant with a loyal following that stretches well beyond city limits.
People are making hour-long drives, bringing their families, celebrating birthdays, and returning again and again not just for the pizza but for the way the whole place makes them feel. That combination of quality ingredients, creative menus, and a staff that genuinely cares is what separates Motor City Pizza from every other pizza spot in the state.
Motor City Pizza is located at 1425 FM 407, Ste 600, Lewisville, TX 75077. They are open Thursday through Saturday from 11 AM to 9 PM, Sunday from 11 AM to 8 PM, and Wednesday from 11 AM to 3 PM.
Call ahead at 972-654-6276 or visit motorcitypizzatx.com to plan your visit.
Enjoyed this story?
Add Fast Food Club as a preferred source to see more of our reporting on Google.