Most ice cream counters in Indiana hand over a short list of flavors and call it a day, but one small-town spot in Grant County hands over a menu with 100 shake and sundae options and dares guests to choose just one. The parking lot here can fill up before the doors even open, and families happily drive more than an hour for a single dessert.
Some locals have been coming for 40 years, and a few are still working their way through every flavor on the board. Keep reading to learn where it is, how the ordering works, which sizes to pick, and how to beat the crowds.
A Main Street Address Built on Ice Cream

Small towns rarely draw out-of-county traffic for dessert, yet Upland pulls it off every single week. The reason is Ivanhoes, an American restaurant and ice cream parlor at 979 S Main St, Upland, IN 46989, United States.
The building sits right on the town’s main road in Grant County, Indiana. Finding it is the easy part, and getting a parking spot is the real test.
At first glance, the place looks like a classic small-town diner. The menu is where things get wild, with 100 shake and sundae flavors listed for anyone brave enough to read them all.
Hearty American fare shares the spotlight, so a full meal followed by dessert is the common plan. Many guests treat the food as the warm-up act and the ice cream as the headliner.
That flavor count explains the buzz behind the headline. Plenty of Hoosiers will tell anyone who listens that no other shop in the state offers quite so many choices in one spot.
It is cozy, busy, and proudly local. The rest of this story explains why so many people keep coming back for round after round.
Four Decades of Sunday Night Tradition

Some families mark time with birthdays and holidays. In Upland, plenty of folks mark it with trips to Ivanhoes.
Loyal regulars have been stopping by for 40 years, and they report that the quality has held steady the whole time. That kind of consistency is rare for any restaurant.
For years, the spot served as the go-to Sunday night hangout after church for groups of friends. People who moved away decades ago still return when they are back in town for family occasions, such as Mother’s Day.
The menu has shifted a little over time, but the core idea has not. Good food, big desserts, and a long list of flavors remain the main attraction.
College life adds another layer to the story. The restaurant sits near both Taylor University and Indiana Wesleyan University, which helps keep the booths full year after year.
Parents who once came as students now bring their own kids. That cycle has turned a simple diner into a true community cornerstone.
Locals often say that if someone knows, they know. Newcomers tend to figure it out after one visit.
One Hundred Flavors and Counting

Here is a fun fact to share at the next family dinner. The shake and sundae list at Ivanhoes runs a full 100 flavors deep.
That number is not a marketing stretch. Each option has its own number, and regulars often order by digit, such as a quick request for a #13.
The variety is the main reason so many Hoosiers swear this spot beats every other parlor around. Few shops even try to match it.
Choosing can take a while, so it helps to have a plan before reaching the counter. Some people pick a favorite and stick with it forever, while others rotate through new numbers on each trip.
Kids especially love the long list, since there is almost no way to run out of options. Grown-ups tend to enjoy it just as much, even if they will not admit it.
The menu can be viewed online at ivanhoes.info before the trip. Browsing it at home saves time and keeps the line moving.
With 100 picks on the board, indecision is basically part of the experience. Nobody seems to mind.
The Strawberry Shortcake Craze

Ask locals about must-order desserts, and one answer comes up again and again. The strawberry shortcake is the most talked-about item on the entire menu.
It is especially popular in summer, when strawberry season is in full swing. Many people plan their visits around that window just to grab one.
Fans drive more than an hour for it and call it the best version they have ever had. Some even admit to thinking about it long after they leave.
A handy insider tip is to ask for extra juice. Regulars swear by that small request.
The dessert can be ordered with soft serve, and it arrives in a very generous portion. Sharing is a smart move, especially after a full meal.
It also tends to cost more than a typical dinner plate, which surprises first-timers. Given the size, most groups find it worth the splurge.
Plenty of folks consider the shortcake the true signature of the place. With so many fans, it has earned that title fair and square.
Hard Dip Cans and Soft Serve Swirls

Behind the counter, the freezer case tells its own story. There are usually no fewer than 12 cans of hard dip ice cream ready to go.
That selection works alongside the soft serve, giving each order a solid base. Between the two styles, the 100-flavor list suddenly makes a lot of sense.
Hand-dipped creations get plenty of love. One favorite pairs butter pecan ice cream with pecans and butterscotch topping, sold under the name Butternut.
Hot fudge sundaes are another classic that families order time after time. They show up on plenty of tables, especially on busy weekends.
The soft serve earns praise too, especially from kids who want something simple. Parents often mix and match so everyone at the table gets a different style.
Having both options means picky eaters and adventurous ones can share a booth without arguments. That is a small win for any family outing.
Next time the line slows down, take a peek at those hard dip cans. They are the quiet heroes of the whole operation.
Milkshakes That Keep the Booths Full

Some guests never even look at the food menu. They come for one thing, and that thing is a milkshake.
Shake fans call the results great, time after time. Even people who have never tried the meals say the ice cream side never lets them down.
Every flavor on that famous list can be turned into a shake. That opens the door to dozens of combinations a typical shop could never offer.
Groups of siblings, parents, and friends often order different flavors and pass them around. It is a fun way to sample more of the list in one trip.
The staff behind the shake counter tend to be polite and quick, even when the room is packed. A friendly order-taker can make a long wait feel a lot shorter.
Shakes are also easier to handle than sundaes for anyone heading back to the car. They make a solid choice for road-trippers on the move.
For many Hoosiers, the shake is the whole reason for the drive. It is hard to argue with that logic.
The Quest to Join the 100 Club

Most diners hand out loyalty punch cards. Ivanhoes has something that sounds far more ambitious, known around town as the 100 club.
The idea is simple. Work through the flavor list and earn a spot among the fans who have tried them all.
Young guests talk about it like a dream goal. It gives kids a fun reason to keep coming back and checking new numbers off the list.
Families often turn it into a long-term project. Each visit becomes a chance to pick a flavor nobody has tried yet.
The challenge also explains why so many people refuse to stick with just one favorite. There is always another number waiting.
Of course, nobody has to finish in a single summer. With portions this big, pacing is the wise approach.
Details about the club are best confirmed with the staff or the website. Either way, it adds a playful goal to an already fun outing.
Plenty of people are still chasing that final flavor. The finish line keeps them loyal.
Why Mini Is the Smart Size

Here is the most useful tip in this entire article. Order the mini.
The regular size is huge, and plenty of first-timers learn that the hard way. Groups who order regular often cannot finish their ice cream.
Even the mini is described as pretty big. It is more than enough for most people, especially after a meal.
Sundaes come out large enough that a whole family may need to team up on just two of them. Sharing keeps the bill down and prevents a sugar overload.
Desserts can cost more than a single dinner plate, so size matters for the budget too. Picking mini helps keep the outing affordable.
Regulars have a joke about unbuttoning their pants before digging in. That says plenty about the portions.
Kids may want the biggest option on the board. Parents can steer them toward mini without anyone feeling shortchanged.
Going small here still means going big by most standards. It is the kind of math that works in everyone’s favor.
Two Counters and a Little Strategy

First-timers often stand in the wrong spot. That is because the ordering system here works a bit differently than most diners.
Ice cream is ordered at one counter, and food is ordered at another. Food pickup can be a little confusing, so it helps to pay close attention to where orders come out.
Paper menus are not always available at the counter. Instead, QR codes on the wall link to the menu online.
The catch is that cell signal inside can be weak. Pulling up the menu at home before leaving is the safest plan.
Food is made fresh, which means waits can stretch during busy times. Some groups have waited quite a while, so patience is part of the deal.
If an order seems to be taking too long, checking in at the counter is perfectly fine. Staff usually sort things out quickly.
Splitting the group can speed things up. One person handles the food line while another tackles the ice cream line.
A little strategy goes a long way here. Teamwork turns the shuffle into a smooth routine.
Old Flags in the Back Room

Most people focus on the menu board, but the walls deserve a look too. The back dining room holds a collection of older United States flags.
It is an easy detail to miss when the line is long and everyone is hungry. Once seated, though, it makes for a fun conversation starter.
Kids can try to spot differences between the designs. History fans may enjoy guessing which eras the flags come from.
The back room also offers extra seating when the front fills up. Even on packed days, there tends to be space somewhere for both solo diners and large families.
Tables there can occasionally need a wipe during busy stretches. It is a small thing, and staff can help if needed.
The room adds a touch of small-town pride to the whole place. It fits the classic American parlor style that so many people love.
Next time, grab a booth in the back and take a moment to look around. The decor tells a quiet story while dessert does the talking.
A Famous Cat Guarding the Lot

Not every ice cream shop has a celebrity standing outside. Ivanhoes has Garfield.
A statue of the famous orange cat sits at the edge of the parking lot. It is part of the Garfield Trail, a series of statues spread around the area.
Trail followers can check off this stop and grab a sundae in the same trip. That is a pretty sweet deal.
Kids tend to love posing with the statue while the grown-ups wait for a spot in line. It is a handy distraction on busy days.
The statue also makes a fun landmark for anyone meeting friends there. Saying meet by Garfield is about as easy as directions get.
Grant County makes a nice day trip, and plenty of people end their outings right here. A full day of exploring pairs well with a big dessert.
Families can snap photos, chat about the trail, and plan their next stop. Garfield is famous for loving food, so the location feels fitting.
Even the parking lot has personality here. Not many restaurants can say that.
Crowds, Chatter, and Family Fun

Quiet dinners are not really the point here. The room tends to buzz with families, students, and friends all at once.
It gets loud thanks to the sheer number of people inside. Still, conversations are easy enough to carry on at the table.
The vibe is very kid-friendly, and families come from far and wide. It feels cozy, even when every seat seems taken.
One note for parents is that highchairs are not available. Planning ahead for little ones makes the visit smoother.
Outdoor seating is also an option, which helps on nice days. Eating outside can be a relaxing break from the busy dining room.
Saturdays can get especially chaotic, with long ticket lines at the ice cream counter. Some people decide to come back another day instead.
Food portions are large and prices are friendly on the wallet. A few salads are on hand, but this is clearly a place for treating yourself.
The crowd is part of the charm. Everyone is there for the same happy reason.
Hours, Lines, and Timing the Visit

Timing is everything at a place this popular. Knowing the schedule can save a lot of waiting.
Ivanhoes opens at 10 AM Monday through Thursday and stays open until 10 PM. On Friday and Saturday, hours run from 10 AM to 11 PM.
Sunday is the outlier, with doors opening at 2 PM and closing at 10 PM. Plan accordingly for weekend trips.
The parking lot often fills up about 15 minutes before opening. A wait of around 30 minutes is typical once inside.
Parking itself tends to be easier to navigate than it looks. A packed lot does not always mean a packed table.
Late evenings stay busy too, even about half an hour before closing. Service at that hour can still move quickly.
Weekday visits are usually calmer than Saturdays. Anyone hoping to dodge the biggest crowds should aim for a Monday through Thursday trip.
The menu is online at ivanhoes.info for planning ahead. A little homework turns a long wait into a quick order.
Worth the Drive to Upland

So, does Ivanhoes really have more shake flavors than anywhere else? Plenty of Hoosiers certainly believe it, and 100 options make a strong case.
The appeal goes beyond the numbers. Four decades of loyal fans, the strawberry shortcake craze, and the 100 club all add up to something special.
No place is perfect, of course. Lines can be long, the room gets loud, and busy Saturdays can test anyone’s patience.
Food can take a while because it is made fresh. Experiences with the meals vary, while the ice cream side stays the main draw.
Still, the friendly prices, generous portions, and fun atmosphere keep families returning. Many folks happily drive more than an hour for one dessert.
For the best trip, check the menu online, aim for a weekday, and order the mini. Saying hello to Garfield on the way in is optional but highly encouraged.
Upland may be a small town, but its ice cream reputation is anything but small. One visit is usually enough to start planning the next flavor.
Enjoyed this story?
Add Fast Food Club as a preferred source to see more of our reporting on Google.