Some neighborhood spots get a quick look and a shrug. This one gets decades of loyalty, kids who grow up and bring their own families back, and a grandmother from New York who reportedly trusted no other pizza in Minnesota.
The setup is simple: step up to the counter, place an order, grab a seat if one is open, and let the staff bring the food over. The menu leans on homemade pasta, big hoagies, pizza by the slice, and a market stocked with cheeses and Italian imports.
It has been family owned and operated since 1982, which is a rare run for any small business. Keep reading to learn where it is, what locals order, when to go, and a few honest tips that will make the first trip feel like the tenth.
A Corner of Southwest Minneapolis Worth Finding

Broders’ Cucina Italiana sits at 2308 W 50th St, Minneapolis, MN 55410, in the southwest corner of the city. It is part Italian deli, part takeout counter, and part market, all rolled into one compact storefront.
The description is short and sweet. This is a longtime family Italian market and deli offering homemade pasta, classic dishes, and bakery goods.
Locals tend to call it a neighborhood favorite, and that label fits. Plenty of people first came here as kids and still return as adults.
The business holds a 4.5-star standing from more than 850 people who have weighed in, which says a lot for a counter-service spot. That kind of number does not happen by accident.
Getting oriented is easy once inside. Order at the counter, find a table or head home with a bag, and the staff handles the rest.
It is not fancy, and it does not try to be. The appeal is steady Italian cooking served in a format that works for a quick lunch, a family dinner, or a stop to stock the home pantry.
So where did all of this begin, and who set the standards that still guide the counter today?
Family Roots Dating Back to 1982

Some businesses change hands every few years. This one has stayed in the family since 1982, and the team proudly points out how impressive that is these days.
The founders, Molly and Tom Broder, set the standards that still shape the place. Longtime fans credit the current management and staff with carrying those standards forward.
A neighborhood pizza chef even calls it a cornerstone of Italian food in the community. That is high praise coming from someone who makes pizza for a living.
The multigenerational story shows up in small ways. One longtime fan remembers meeting Tom Broder Sr. at age nine while ordering a cheese slice before heading to the Edina Theatre with a friend.
Others talk about walking here as kids. Now they come back with partners, children, and out-of-town relatives.
That kind of loyalty builds slowly, one order at a time. It is the quiet engine behind the busy counter.
History is nice, but the building itself recently got a refresh worth knowing about.
A New Space With a Familiar Setup

Regulars who knew the old layout will notice a twist. The newer location keeps a very similar setup, but the deli and dine-in areas have switched sides.
The good news is that the food quality stayed the same through the move. Familiar favorites still come out of the kitchen the way regulars expect.
There was also expansion work going on in the seating area at one point. The goal seemed clear: more room for people who want to eat on site.
That neighborhood pizza chef describes the dining room as feeling like it was always meant to be there. It blends in rather than shouting for attention.
Even so, seating is still on the small side. Expect a modest dining room rather than a sprawling hall.
The staff notes that tables turn over quickly. Waits for a seat tend to be short, even when the counter is busy.
Once a spot opens up, the next question is simple. What should land on the tray?
The South Jersey Hoagie Legacy

Sandwiches come up more than almost anything else when people talk about this deli. The hoagie is the headline act.
The South Jersey hoagie on a French baguette is a longtime pick for families who have been coming for over 20 years. Some of them call it the best Italian-style sandwich in the city.
That is a bold title in a big town. Still, the hoagie keeps earning its fan club year after year.
The sandwich menu goes beyond one star, though. A chicken parm sandwich also gets warm praise from regulars.
Eggplant parm shows up in conversations too. It gives non-meat eaters a solid sandwich-friendly option.
There is also a handy special that pairs soup with half a sandwich for $13. It works well for anyone who cannot pick just one thing.
During a past restaurant week, a soup, half sandwich, and sweet treat deal ran for $15. The small cookie added was the main difference.
Hoagies are only half the story, of course. The other half is made from flour and eggs and comes out of this kitchen daily.
Homemade Pasta, Plate or Package

Fresh pasta is a big reason people make the trip. Some regulars call it the main selling point.
Fettuccine noodles get plenty of attention. The menu also spans a large selection of pasta dishes, including lasagna variations like Lasagna Siciliana, pesto lasagna, spinach lasagna, and meat lasagna.
Kids are covered as well. Spaghetti and meatballs on the kids menu even works for adults who want a smaller portion.
Farfalle with pesto is a favorite for younger diners in long-loyal families. Seasonal specials, such as a beet pasta, have also won fans.
One of the best parts is that the pasta does not have to stay in the restaurant. Plenty of people buy fresh pasta to cook at home and come away happy.
Out-of-town guests have taken homemade, ready-to-go ingredients back with them too. A Chicago couple planned to pack some for the trip home.
There are a lot of meat dishes, but several without meat as well. That balance helps groups with mixed preferences order without fuss.
Pasta keeps the counter busy, yet the pizza case might be the real crowd-pleaser.
Slices, Pies, and Stromboli

Pizza by the slice has a loyal following here. The team proudly calls it a New York style slice.
That style has passed a tough test. A New York grandmother living in Minnesota reportedly ate pizza only from this spot.
The whole pies are generous. Two 12-inch pizzas can leave enough leftovers for dinner the next night, which makes the value easy to like.
Topping choices go beyond plain cheese. Mushroom speck, Italian sausage, and an eggplant and caramelized onion pie have all drawn praise.
The crust gets credit for being done right. That matters on a pizza big enough to need two hands.
Stromboli also appears on the radar for many regulars. It is a good pick when a slice feels too ordinary.
A slice paired with a can of Orangina or a Siciliana soda is a simple combo that longtime fans swear by. Sparkling water on tap is another nice touch.
Even with a pizza in hand, it is hard to skip the bakery case by the register.
Cannoli, Cookies, and the Bakery Case

Dessert lovers, take note. The bakery goods are part of the official description, not an afterthought.
Cannoli are among the sweets that people bring up most. Italian cookies, including almond horns and rainbow cookies, also have a following.
A strawberry rhubarb bar has won over at least a few meat lasagna fans. Pastries in general get solid praise.
Fair warning on the costs. Cookies have been priced at $1.95 each, and a small piece of tiramisu has cost $9.
Shoppers used to buying Italian cookies by the pound may find that steep. It helps to know before reaching the register.
The tiramisu in the case may come out as a prepackaged piece from the back. That is worth knowing for anyone expecting a fresh-cut slice.
Treats here are best seen as a small splurge rather than a bargain. A single cannoli can be a nice finish without overdoing it.
Sweets aside, the shelves just steps away hold something for the home kitchen.
Inside the Italian Market

Groceries and a hoagie in one stop is a pretty good errand. The market side makes that possible.
The team says it carries fine cheeses, meats, pasta, and imports from Italy. The cheese selection is especially large for a shop this size.
Many shoppers find the market well curated. Others note it is small, so it is not a giant specialty grocery.
Homemade, ready-to-go ingredients are a highlight. They make it easy to put together an Italian dinner without starting from scratch.
French baguettes also come up often. They pair naturally with deli meats and cheeses for a home spread.
Expectations matter here. Come for a focused selection of quality items, not endless aisles.
Staff members are known for helping with suggestions and product questions. They can guide a first-timer through the shelves without fuss.
That helpful attitude carries over into how the whole room runs.
Counter Service With a Friendly Crew

Order, sit, relax. The routine is that simple.
Guests place orders at the counter, find a seat, and staff bring the food out. Takeout works just as smoothly.
The team gets regular praise for being responsive and attentive. Patience with first-timers studying the menu is a common theme.
Service tends to stay fast even when it is busy. That counts for a lot on a crowded weeknight.
The atmosphere is casual and welcoming. It suits a quick bite, a low-key date, or a family meal.
Anniversary takeout, childhood traditions, and family reunions all happen here. The spot handles big moments without fuss.
Not every visit is perfect. Some diners have mentioned small portions, dry or salty pasta, or uneven quality on certain days.
The owners respond to concerns and invite people to email info@broders.com. That openness is a good sign for a long-running family shop.
Knowing the flow helps, and so does knowing when to show up.
Hours, Timing, and Parking Tips

Early birds and late diners both get a fair shot. The doors open at 8 am and close at 9 pm every day of the week.
That schedule is the same Sunday through Saturday. No need to memorize a complicated calendar.
Timing makes a real difference with the small dining room. Before 5 pm is usually calm, while 6 to 8 pm tends to be the busy stretch.
Anyone hoping for a table should aim for an afternoon visit. Takeout is a smart move during the dinner rush.
Parking takes a little planning. There is no big lot, so drivers rely on street parking in the surrounding neighborhood.
Spots can be limited at peak times. Giving a few extra minutes to circle the block is a good idea.
The area is described as safe and pleasant. Walking from nearby blocks is easy, which is how many longtime fans first found the place.
Costs are generally seen as reasonable, though extras like added chicken run close to $5.
With the logistics sorted, there is just one question left.
Why the Counter Keeps Calling Locals Back

Four decades of family ownership is no small feat. Neither is keeping kids, parents, and grandparents coming back to the same counter.
The formula is simple. Homemade pasta, big hoagies, New York style slices, and a tidy Italian market all live under one roof.
It is not flawless. Seating is tight, parking is street-only, and a few treats carry premium prices.
Still, the steady crowd says plenty. Many locals treat it as a weekly habit rather than a special trip.
First-timers do well to start with the South Jersey hoagie or a fresh pasta dish. A slice of pizza is a safe bet for a quick visit.
Grabbing a package of fresh pasta to cook at home stretches the experience into the next night. It is a tasty souvenir that does not need a suitcase.
For a casual Italian meal in southwest Minneapolis, this family deli delivers a dependable, friendly stop. The counter is waiting, and the line usually moves fast.
Enjoyed this story?
Add Fast Food Club as a preferred source to see more of our reporting on Google.