Fast Food Club Fast Food Club

Old-Timers In Essex Still Order Pizza By The Square At Squire’s Italian Restaurant

Chase Chesapeake 10 min read
featured image 5b4200658363 e5b96d233e78
Old-Timers In Essex Still Order Pizza By The Square At Squire's Italian Restaurant

Some families in eastern Baltimore County never argue about where to get pizza. The only debate is who has to drive over and pick it up.

That habit has been passed down for generations at one Italian spot that first opened its doors back in 1952. Grandparents ordered from here, their kids grew up on it, and now the grandkids are placing orders online.

The menu stretches well past pizza, with pasta specials, subs, meatballs, and a cream of crab soup that people carry home by the quart from out of state. There is a party room upstairs, a bar in the back, and a catering crew that keeps working even when the power goes out.

Keep reading to learn how this neighborhood favorite has lasted more than seventy years, what to order, and how to plan a visit.

A Holabird Avenue Address With Deep Roots

A Holabird Avenue Address With Deep Roots
© Squire’s Italian Restaurant and Catering, Baltimore, MD

Squire’s Italian Restaurant and Catering sits at 6723 Holabird Ave, Baltimore, MD 21222, in the Dundalk area just outside the city. The listing calls it a pizza restaurant, but the menu reaches far beyond one dish.

Locals in nearby communities like Essex, North Point, and Dundalk treat it as a default choice. It is the kind of place people mention when someone asks where to eat on the east side.

The restaurant describes itself as a long-running hub for pizza and pasta. It serves a lineup of Italian staples, along with a three-course pasta special that keeps regulars coming back on weeknights.

Its location is part of the appeal. Folks looking for a break from crowded downtown spots find this stretch of Holabird Avenue a calmer option, with room to park and no need to circle the block.

The building holds a main dining room, a bar area in the back, a carryout counter near the entrance, and a private room upstairs for gatherings. That layout lets it serve a quick pickup crowd and a sit-down dinner crowd at the same time.

With thousands of people sharing their thoughts online and an average of 4.5 stars, the place clearly has a loyal following. The address may be simple, but the story behind it goes back a long way.

Seventy Years Of Neighborhood Habit

Seventy Years Of Neighborhood Habit
© Squire’s Italian Restaurant and Catering, Baltimore, MD

Back in 1952, a casual Italian joint opened in this corner of Baltimore County. More than seven decades later, it is still feeding the same neighborhoods.

Longevity like that does not come from luck. It comes from families who keep showing up, year after year, and teaching their kids to do the same.

Some people grew up on the pizza their entire childhood. In those households, the question was never where to order from, only who was going to go pick it up.

Others first heard the name from a parent who got the tip from a coworker years ago. Decades later, they finally stopped in for Sunday brunch and understood the fuss.

Family ownership is part of the story too. Guests who come in for the first time often mention feeling welcomed right away, and that small-business spirit shows up in how the place runs.

There is also something to be said for staying power in a world of chains. People who moved away still choose to support this spot when they need food for friends and family back home.

The fact that it remains busy is a point of pride for many longtime fans. Seeing the lot full is, for them, proof that the old neighborhood still has its anchor.

Pizza By The Square, Pie After Pie

Pizza By The Square, Pie After Pie
© Squire’s Italian Restaurant and Catering, Baltimore, MD

Ask an old-timer from Essex what to order, and the answer will almost always start with pizza. It is the dish that built the reputation, cut and shared the way regulars have eaten it for years.

The meat sauce pizza is one of the most talked-about pies on the menu. It shows up again and again when fans explain why they keep returning.

Seafood pizza has its own following, topped with pieces of crab and shrimp over red sauce. Some diners call it the star of the table.

The meat lovers pizza earns plenty of affection as well. One hungry guest finished an entire medium alone in the parking lot, which says a lot about how hard it is to wait.

Plenty of people call it the best pizza in Dundalk, and some go further and claim all of Baltimore. Even folks who have tried many places across Maryland put it at the top.

Consistency is a big reason for that loyalty. Regulars say they know exactly what they are getting each time, and that is exactly what keeps the boxes stacking up at the pickup counter.

Not every pie is a home run for everyone, and a few specialty options get mixed opinions. Still, the classics are where this kitchen shines brightest.

Beyond The Crust: Soup, Subs, And Meatballs

Beyond The Crust: Soup, Subs, And Meatballs
© Squire’s Italian Restaurant and Catering, Baltimore, MD

Pizza may be the headliner, but the supporting cast deserves its own applause. The menu is packed with Italian staples and Maryland favorites that draw their own fans.

Cream of crab soup is a big one. Former locals who now live in Delaware stop in to grab a quart every time they pass through, and many call it the best they have had.

Subs come up more than almost anything else on the menu. The cheesesteak sub runs about 11 or 12 dollars, and it can be customized with toppings like provolone, hot peppers, fried onions, and mayo.

Meatballs are another regular request, often paired with the house Italian bread. Chicken parm and dishes in alfredo sauce round out the comfort-food options.

Crab cake fans have reasons to visit too. The crab cake dinner is known for big chunks of backfin with just enough filler to hold it together.

Portions tend to be generous, so splitting a side like onion rings is a smart move. Many diners end up taking leftovers home.

Seasonal specials pop up now and then, such as a Valentine’s dish of chicken stuffed with gouda in a creamy red pepper sauce. Leave room for cannoli if dessert is on the agenda.

Weekend Brunch At A Pizza Place

Weekend Brunch At A Pizza Place
© Squire’s Italian Restaurant and Catering, Baltimore, MD

Here is a fun surprise for newcomers: a pizza spot that opens early for breakfast on weekends. Saturday and Sunday doors open at 10 AM, an hour earlier than the rest of the week.

Sunday brunch has become a tradition for some after church. The western omelette with cheesy grits and wheat toast is one combination that earns strong praise.

Those cheesy grits in particular get a lot of love. Even people who make grits at home admit these come out ahead.

French toast has also built a bit of buzz. Word travels among regulars that it is worth trying, so it may be the next thing to order after a pizza night.

The brunch crowd is varied. It works for a family meal, a catch-up with friends, or a quiet solo morning with a plate and a coffee.

Staff members are often credited with pointing guests toward house favorites. Asking the server what is best that morning can lead to a great choice.

Breakfast at a place famous for pizza might sound unusual. Once people try it, though, the weekend morning visit tends to become its own habit.

Catering That Keeps Its Promises

Catering That Keeps Its Promises
© Squire’s Italian Restaurant and Catering, Baltimore, MD

When a power outage hit on the morning of a big catering delivery, the team called and texted the customer with updates all morning. The power came back in the early afternoon, and the food arrived right on time.

That story sums up why so many families trust this kitchen with their events. Catering is right there in the full name, and it is a serious part of the business.

Ordering is simple. Customers call in, place the order, and a manager often follows up with final pricing and helpful reminders about utensils and paper goods.

Spreads can include salad, bread, a chicken dish, and a pasta dish, enough to feed a dozen people or more. Pizza can be added for larger gatherings.

People have used the service for local events, family get-togethers, and difficult times when friends needed a warm meal. Pickup is easy, and delivery drivers are known for being friendly.

Some former residents who no longer live nearby still choose this kitchen to support a small business instead of a chain. That loyalty speaks volumes.

For anyone planning a party in the area, this team has decades of practice. They handle the food so the host can focus on the guests.

Booths, A Back Bar, And An Upstairs Party Room

Booths, A Back Bar, And An Upstairs Party Room
© Squire’s Italian Restaurant and Catering, Baltimore, MD

Space is one thing this restaurant does not lack. The dining room is large enough that big groups and Friday night families can usually be seated without a long wait.

Guests enter near the kitchen and carryout area, then head to the right to be seated. A host greets diners and shows them to their table.

Bread often arrives before the meal, a small touch that regulars appreciate. A children’s menu is posted for families with little ones.

A bar sits in the back for those who want appetizers and a relaxed seat. Happy hour gets a few mentions from people who like stopping in after work.

Upstairs, a private area hosts family events and celebrations. Many locals remember birthdays and gatherings held in that room over the years.

The atmosphere is clean, cozy, and unpretentious. It is not trying to be a fancy gourmet restaurant, and fans like it that way.

Some guests even bring a laptop and get work done during a quiet afternoon meal. The setting fits a solo lunch just as easily as a crowded family dinner.

Hours, Parking, And Budget Notes

Hours, Parking, And Budget Notes
© Squire’s Italian Restaurant and Catering, Baltimore, MD

Timing a visit is easy thanks to long hours. Monday through Thursday, the doors are open from 11 AM to 9:30 PM.

Friday runs later, from 11 AM to 11 PM. Saturday opens early at 10 AM and also stays open until 11 PM.

Sunday hours are 10 AM to 9:30 PM, which makes it a handy brunch stop. Friday evenings tend to fill up as families trickle in.

Parking is plentiful, with a large lot in the rear. There are accessible spaces, a wheelchair ramp, and dedicated spots for carryout customers.

On cost, opinions vary. Some find the prices quite reasonable for the big portions, while others feel they have crept up over time.

Expect prices in the average to higher range for a casual spot. Splitting sides and taking leftovers home can help stretch the budget.

Delivery and online ordering are available for those who prefer to eat at home. Many longtime fans order this way most of the time and report quick arrivals.

Why The Old-Timers Keep Coming Back

Why The Old-Timers Keep Coming Back
© Squire’s Italian Restaurant and Catering, Baltimore, MD

Seventy-plus years in business is no small slice of history. It takes steady food, friendly faces, and a community that keeps saying yes.

That is the formula at work on Holabird Avenue. Regulars praise the staff by name, from helpful counter workers to attentive servers who check in without hovering.

Like any busy spot, it has an off day now and then. A drink might come out wrong, or a pickup might feel rushed.

Still, the overall picture is a well-run, well-loved neighborhood restaurant. It takes its food seriously without putting on airs.

For first-timers, starting with a classic pizza and a cup of cream of crab soup is a safe bet. Return trips can explore subs, meatballs, brunch, or a crab cake dinner.

For old-timers, there is nothing to figure out. They already know their order, their table, and who is driving to pick it up.

Some places feed a town for a season. This one has fed generations, and it seems ready to serve plenty more.

Enjoyed this story?

Add Fast Food Club as a preferred source to see more of our reporting on Google.

Follow us on Google

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *