Fast Food Club Fast Food Club

Pastrami Fans Skip The Trip Downtown For The Sloppy Paul At This Illinois Jewish Deli

Lincoln Avery 12 min read
featured image 326aaac1d77a 1c2356f9a9c8
Pastrami Fans Skip The Trip Downtown For The Sloppy Paul At This Illinois Jewish Deli

Chicago has plenty of famous sandwiches, but some pastrami lovers have stopped driving into the city for theirs. They head west to the suburbs instead, to a deli where one sandwich has its own loyal following.

It is called the Sloppy Paul, and it stacks pastrami and corned beef together on rye. The deli behind it serves classic Jewish comfort food from morning until mid-afternoon, with bagels baked on site, big bowls of matzo ball soup, and free bagel chips at the table.

Families drop in for breakfast, coworkers squeeze in a quick lunch, and some out-of-state travelers make it their first stop after landing. Keep reading to learn where this spot is, what to order, when to go, and a few small tips that make the visit smoother, from the parking lot to the pickle choice.

A Deli Address Worth Writing Down

A Deli Address Worth Writing Down
© Schmaltz Delicatessen, Lisle, IL

Some of the best sandwiches in Illinois are not found under skyscrapers. They are found along a busy suburban road west of Chicago.

Schmaltz Delicatessen sits at 3011 Ogden Ave, Lisle, IL 60532, in DuPage County, Illinois. It is a daytime, counter-serve Jewish deli that also offers table service in its dining room.

The deli describes itself as a modern Jewish deli serving the classics. That means sandwiches, soups, and breakfasts sit alongside newer items like modern salads.

The menu is big enough to need a few minutes of study. Sandwiches, burgers, bagels, and baked goods all get space, and the deli meats are the main attraction.

For many diners in the western suburbs, this is the place that ended a long search. People who grew up with East Coast delis often say they had trouble finding a solid corned beef or pastrami sandwich close to home.

The location makes it easy to reach for people living in Lisle, Naperville, Downers Grove, and nearby towns. It also means no city parking fees and no traffic jams on the expressway into downtown.

So the first lesson is simple. The pastrami pilgrimage can end right here on Ogden Avenue.

A New Home on Ogden Avenue

A New Home on Ogden Avenue
© Schmaltz Delicatessen, Lisle, IL

Moving a beloved deli is a bit like moving a family recipe box. Everyone worries something might get lost along the way.

Schmaltz once operated at a different location before settling into its current spot on Ogden Avenue. Longtime fans have noticed the change and talk about it often.

The look and layout of the new space keep much of the same style as before. Some regulars feel the deli is still finding its full rhythm in the new building, while newer guests call it their new neighborhood deli.

That mix of opinions shows how attached people are to this place. Nobody gets that invested in a sandwich shop they do not care about.

The deli has also been around long enough to build a following. Some couples visiting from other states have made it a regular stop for years.

One pair from Las Vegas found it by accident and now visits it right after their airport stop. That kind of loyalty does not happen overnight.

The story here is still being written. The address may have changed, but the classic menu came along for the ride.

Two Sides of One Front Door

Two Sides of One Front Door
© Schmaltz Delicatessen, Lisle, IL

Turn left or turn right. That small choice shapes the whole visit at Schmaltz.

The left half of the building works as a to-go area and bagel bakery. Glass cases hold breads, bakery items, deli meats, cheeses, soups, and desserts.

The right side is the sit-down dining room. Guests get seated, handed a menu, and served at their table.

This setup works well for different moods. Someone grabbing bagels for the office can be in and out quickly, while a family can settle in for a full lunch.

The dining room is large and spacious, with a bright and comfortable feel. Some guests describe the setting as colorful and lively, with a classic New York-style deli look.

Others keep it simple and say the place is clean and welcoming. A few point out that the outside of the building is plain, so the inside comes as a nice surprise.

Either side, the goal stays the same. Good deli food, served with no fuss.

The Sloppy Paul Explained

The Sloppy Paul Explained
© Schmaltz Delicatessen, Lisle, IL

Every great deli has a sandwich people mention by name. At Schmaltz, that sandwich is the Sloppy Paul.

It combines pastrami and corned beef on rye bread. For people who cannot decide between the two meats, this sandwich solves the problem.

Fans call the pairing the ultimate sandwich combination. Even diners who order something else often sneak a bite from a friend and end up impressed.

The Sloppy Paul sits around the twenty-dollar mark. At that price, guests expect a generous stack of meat, and when it arrives piled high, it lives up to its name.

Consistency is the one thing longtime fans watch closely. Some have noted that on certain days the pastrami portion came out lighter than they expected.

That honest feedback actually shows how much people love this sandwich. They want it at its best every single time.

For a first visit, it makes sense to start here. It is the sandwich that draws pastrami fans off the expressway and into Lisle.

Pastrami and Corned Beef Done Right

Pastrami and Corned Beef Done Right
© Schmaltz Delicatessen, Lisle, IL

Talk to almost anyone leaving Schmaltz, and the conversation turns to meat. Corned beef and pastrami are the two most mentioned items on the menu.

The pastrami is often called juicy and tender, with a peppery, spicy edge. The corned beef is described as lean and tender.

Some cuts of pastrami come a little fatty. Guests who prefer leaner slices can ask for extra lean when ordering.

Many sandwiches let diners mix both meats. The #20 Old New Yorker and the #11 Adams are two popular choices that pair pastrami with corned beef.

The Old New Yorker comes with coleslaw and Russian dressing. The Adams brings Swiss cheese and spicy mustard on lightly toasted rye.

There is also an overstuffed option. Choosing it means the sandwich gets packed with even more meat, which is a feature fans love.

Staff are happy to help first-timers pick a sandwich. That guidance comes in handy when the menu is this long.

A House Dressing With a Story

A House Dressing With a Story
© Schmaltz Delicatessen, Lisle, IL

Small details can turn a good sandwich into a memorable one. At Schmaltz, the Russian dressing is one of those details.

The deli uses its own original mix. It blends Thousand Island and Russian dressing into one house recipe.

Family members connected to the deli sometimes stop by tables to chat. Questions about the dressing tend to come up, and the answer is always this homemade blend.

Guests who prefer dressing on the side can ask for it. Servers will also bring spicy mustard and yellow mustard for anyone who wants options.

Some diners notice a hint of garlic in the Reuben, either in the dressing or the kraut. It adds a little extra kick that makes that sandwich stand out.

For people who grew up eating homemade dressings at family tables, this one often brings back memories. That personal touch is part of what keeps people loyal.

It is proof that a deli can be about more than meat. The extras matter here too.

Free Bagel Chips Before the Main Event

Free Bagel Chips Before the Main Event
© Schmaltz Delicatessen, Lisle, IL

Nobody complains about free food. At Schmaltz, the meal starts before anyone even orders.

Sit-down guests get a bowl of baked bagel chips as a starter. They are made from toasted, horizontally sliced bagel pieces.

The chips often come with parmesan. Some guests like them so much they take extras home.

Bagel chips rank among the most talked-about items here. Repeat visitors list them right alongside the latkes as must-haves.

Sandwich plates also come with little touches. A mini cucumber and bite-size fried pieces of different breads sometimes join the main dish.

Freshness is something fans pay attention to. When the chips taste just made, people rave, and on slower days a few have wished for a fresher batch.

It is a small gesture that sets the tone. The deli wants guests to feel welcome from the first minute.

Matzo Ball Soup in a Generous Cup

Matzo Ball Soup in a Generous Cup
© Schmaltz Delicatessen, Lisle, IL

Soup lovers, take note. The cup size at Schmaltz is what many restaurants would call a bowl.

The matzo ball soup is a favorite. It comes with tender white chicken, carrots, celery, and one large matzo ball.

The broth tastes homemade, which is exactly what people want from a Jewish deli. The matzo ball is soft on the outside and a little firmer in the center.

Families have strong opinions about matzo balls. Some like them firm, others fluffy, and this version lands nicely in between.

A half sandwich and soup combo is also available. It is a smart pick for people who want to try both without overdoing it.

The chicken soup earns praise on its own too. Self-described matzo ball soup addicts say this one satisfies their cravings.

On a cold Illinois day, this bowl makes a strong case for the trip.

Bagels, Latkes and Morning Plates

Bagels, Latkes and Morning Plates
© Schmaltz Delicatessen, Lisle, IL

Bagels are the single most mentioned item at this deli. That says a lot in a place famous for pastrami.

The bakery side offers several kinds, including garlic, everything, pumpernickel, pretzel, and cheddar jalapeño. The garlic bagel gets the strongest praise.

Breakfast runs from the 7 AM opening. The Schmaltz bagel sandwich combines eggs, pastrami, and cheese, and it pairs nicely with a cheddar jalapeño bagel.

The Atlantic special is another morning pick, and lox shows up on many tables. Beef salami also makes an appearance.

Some guests wish the breakfast sandwiches had a sauce. Even so, breakfast prices are fair and portions are generous.

Latkes and knishes round out the classic options. Regulars order the latkes almost every visit.

Tuna salad on a pretzel bagel is another quiet winner. Plenty of guests leave with a bag of bagels for later.

Beyond the Deli Classics

Beyond the Deli Classics
© Schmaltz Delicatessen, Lisle, IL

Not everyone in a group wants pastrami. Schmaltz plans for that.

The menu includes burgers and other sandwiches. A crispy cauliflower steak burger offers a meatless choice.

The Nashville sandwich and the loaded fries both get strong praise. Portions are big enough that many people take half home.

A turkey pretzel sandwich comes with schmacon, the deli’s beef bacon. It is a fun twist for people curious about something different.

Modern salads are also part of the lineup. They give lighter eaters a solid option.

Some specialty items may take longer to arrive than a standard sandwich. On busy days, a cauliflower burger once took around 25 minutes, while sandwiches arrived in under ten.

The takeaway is simple. The menu stretches well past the deli case.

Pickles, Pastries and Sweet Finishes

Pickles, Pastries and Sweet Finishes
© Schmaltz Delicatessen, Lisle, IL

Here is a tip worth remembering. The pickle you get is not the only pickle available.

Sandwiches come with a full half-sour pickle by default. Guests who prefer a classic dill or kosher pickle can simply ask.

Many people love the half-sour, calling it an authentic East Coast touch. Others find it not to their taste, so the swap is handy.

Dessert deserves its own planning. The monster eclair is a favorite, and some regulars even order dessert first.

Hand pies are another standout, praised for their flaky crust. They travel well, so taking one to go is a smart move.

Cookies and other pastries also fill the cases. For drinks, Dr. Brown’s Cel-Ray soda is a classic deli pairing.

Saving room is hard here. Planning ahead helps.

Friendly Faces and Who Feels at Home

Friendly Faces and Who Feels at Home
© Schmaltz Delicatessen, Lisle, IL

Great food gets people in the door. Kind people bring them back.

The staff at Schmaltz earn steady praise for being friendly, attentive, and quick. Servers often offer recommendations without being asked.

Out-of-town guests appreciate that help. Some have named specific servers who guided them toward dishes they ended up loving.

The vibe is relaxed and casual. Some say they are not there for decorations, they are there for the food and comfortable service.

The deli suits many kinds of diners. Coworkers on lunch breaks, couples, families, and travelers all fit in easily.

Sandwiches can come out fast, often within five to seven minutes even when busy. To-go orders can be ready in under five minutes.

That speed and warmth together make a strong pair.

Hours, Parking and Catering Know-How

Hours, Parking and Catering Know-How
© Schmaltz Delicatessen, Lisle, IL

A little planning goes a long way. Schmaltz keeps daytime hours only.

The deli opens at 7 AM Tuesday through Sunday. It closes at 3 PM most days and at 4 PM on Saturday, and it is closed on Monday.

Prices run on the higher side for lunch, though many say the value matches the portions. Breakfast prices feel more affordable.

The parking lot can be confusing. Cars enter from the side where the drive-thru line forms, and signs say not to enter through the exit.

Catering is a big part of the business. Box lunches for team meetings arrive on time, and ordering and invoicing go smoothly.

The catering team has even fixed customer mistakes, delivering an order a day early when needed. Sandwiches arrive well stuffed.

The website, schmaltzdeli.com, is the best place to check details before heading out.

Is the Drive Worth It

Is the Drive Worth It
© Schmaltz Delicatessen, Lisle, IL

So, should pastrami fans skip downtown? For a lot of people in the western suburbs, the answer is yes.

Schmaltz delivers the classics people crave. Corned beef, pastrami, matzo ball soup, and fresh bagels anchor the menu.

The Sloppy Paul is the headliner for good reason. Two meats on rye make the choice easy for indecisive diners.

No place is perfect every day. Some longtime fans hope to see the deli’s old spark fully return at the new location.

Still, the overall picture is very positive. With a 4.4-star average from more than 1,800 people, the deli has clearly built a loyal crowd.

Friendly staff, generous portions, and thoughtful extras like free bagel chips all add up. It feels like a neighborhood deli with big ambitions.

Bring an appetite and maybe a to-go bag. Leftovers are part of the plan here.

Enjoyed this story?

Add Fast Food Club as a preferred source to see more of our reporting on Google.

Follow us on Google

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *