Tucked away at 736 Northfield Rd in Westerville, Ohio, Just Pies Inc has earned a loyal following that stretches far beyond the neighborhood. This family-owned bakeshop is known for its wide variety of homemade pies, from classic fruit fillings to rich cream flavors and hearty savory pot pies.
With a 4.7-star rating and hundreds of glowing reviews, it is no surprise that people from all across Ohio make the drive just to get a taste. Whether you are a first-timer or a regular, Just Pies offers a warm, welcoming experience that keeps customers coming back again and again.
A Legacy Built on Homemade Goodness
Some places feel like home the moment you walk through the door, and Just Pies Inc is exactly that kind of spot. This mom-and-pop bakeshop has been crafting homemade pies with love and care for years, building a reputation that stretches across the entire state of Ohio.
Customers who once visited the original North High Street location followed the business to its current Westerville home without missing a beat. That kind of loyalty says everything about the quality and heart behind this bakery.
The family-owned model means every pie is made with personal pride, not mass-production shortcuts. Reviewers frequently mention the unmistakable homemade taste that sets Just Pies apart from grocery store options.
Walking in, you are greeted by the warm aroma of freshly baked pies, which many customers say is enough to sell them before they even reach the counter.
Triple Berry and Bumbleberry Pies Worth the Drive
Few things in life compare to biting into a perfectly balanced berry pie, and Just Pies delivers that experience with flying colors. The triple berry and bumbleberry pies have earned serious fan status among regular customers, with reviewers calling them “excellent options” that stand out even in a packed selection.
Bumbleberry pie is a fun, old-fashioned mix of several different fruits baked together, creating a bold, layered flavor that surprises first-timers in the best possible way. It is the kind of pie that makes you pause mid-bite and smile.
Both options are available in small, medium, and large sizes, so you can grab a personal treat or bring something impressive to a gathering. If berry pies are your weakness, these two are must-tries.
Many customers say they specifically make the trip just to pick up one of these crowd-pleasers.
The Chicken Pot Pie That Changes Minds
Chicken pot pie is one of those comfort foods that most people think they already know, until they try the one at Just Pies. Multiple reviewers have called it the best chicken pot pie they have ever eaten, and that is not a claim people make lightly.
One customer shared that after visiting Key West and dining all over Ohio, the pot pie here still ranked at the top. The flaky crust is a consistent highlight, praised for being golden, fresh, and perfectly baked.
The filling is thick and hearty, with generous chunks of chicken surrounded by a rich, savory gravy.
These pot pies come frozen so you can bake them at home, which makes them a convenient dinner option too. Just pop one in the oven and enjoy a restaurant-quality meal without the restaurant price tag.
It is comfort food done right.
Apple Crumb Pie That Keeps Fans Returning
Ask any regular at Just Pies about their go-to order, and there is a good chance the apple crumb pie comes up immediately. It has developed a devoted following, with customers describing it as a reliable, deeply satisfying classic that never disappoints.
The crumb topping adds a buttery, slightly crunchy contrast to the soft, spiced apple filling underneath. Unlike overly sweet commercial versions, this one strikes a balance that feels genuinely homemade.
One loyal customer mentioned it as her personal favorite after years of buying pies from the bakery.
Whether you enjoy it warm with a scoop of vanilla ice cream or straight from the box at room temperature, the apple crumb pie holds up beautifully. It is the kind of dessert that feels appropriate any time of year, not just in the fall.
This is a Just Pies staple for good reason.
Key Lime Pie That Rivals the Florida Original
Bold claim alert: the Key Lime Pie at Just Pies has been compared favorably to pies from the actual Florida Keys. One reviewer who had visited Key West multiple times said this version was just as good, if not better, than most he had tried down south.
The tart-to-cream balance is described as perfectly centered, neither too sharp nor too sweet. The whipped cream topping is light and airy, complementing the dense, smooth filling without overpowering it.
The crust is consistently praised for being fresh and flaky, which makes every bite feel complete.
For those who prefer meringue over whipped cream, the bakery can accommodate that preference with an advance order. That kind of flexibility shows real customer care.
If you have never considered driving to Westerville for a slice of citrus heaven, the Key Lime Pie alone might just change your mind.
Buckeye Pie: An Ohio Original Worth Celebrating
Ohio pride runs deep, and the Buckeye Pie at Just Pies is a sweet tribute to the state’s favorite candy. Combining the beloved chocolate and peanut butter flavor combo, this pie has developed a cult following among locals and visitors alike.
One reviewer offered a pro tip that sounds almost too good to be true: eat it semi-frozen. According to that customer, chilling the pie transforms the texture into something even more indulgent and satisfying.
It is the kind of insider advice that makes you feel like a regular even on your first visit.
Rich, creamy, and deeply flavorful, the Buckeye Pie is a standout even in a lineup full of impressive options. It makes an excellent gift, a party centerpiece, or a personal reward after a long week.
For anyone with a sweet tooth and Ohio pride, this is the pie to try first.
Banana Cream Pie Done the Right Way
Banana cream pie has a reputation for being either spectacular or forgettable, and Just Pies lands firmly in spectacular territory. What sets this version apart is the way the bananas are sliced: long, thick cuts instead of the typical thin coin slices you see everywhere else.
That small detail makes a big difference. Thicker banana slices mean more fruit flavor in every bite, and the ripeness is carefully managed so the banana tastes sweet without turning mushy.
The cream filling is described as light, fluffy, and deeply flavorful, striking the right balance between rich and airy.
One customer who shared a detailed review of multiple pies singled out the banana cream as a genuine highlight of their visit. For a dessert that could easily be done lazily, Just Pies clearly puts thought and care into every layer.
Banana cream fans should not skip this one.
Blueberry Pie That Wins Over the Whole Family
Sometimes the simplest flavors make the biggest impression, and the blueberry pie at Just Pies is proof of that. Families keep coming back for this one, with at least one customer noting that it is her daughter’s absolute favorite pie in the entire lineup.
There is something deeply comforting about a well-made blueberry pie, with its deep purple filling bubbling up through a golden crust. Just Pies nails the balance between sweet and tart, making sure the blueberry flavor shines without being masked by excess sugar or artificial additives.
Available in small, medium, and large sizes, it works perfectly as a family dessert or a personal treat. Picking one up for a birthday, a Sunday dinner, or just because it is Tuesday are all equally valid reasons.
Once you have tried this blueberry pie, it is hard to settle for anything less next time.
Turkey Pot Pie: A Savory Surprise That Earns Repeat Orders
While the fruit and cream pies often steal the spotlight, the turkey pot pie quietly earns some of the most devoted repeat customers at Just Pies. Reviewers who tried multiple savory options consistently came back to the turkey version as their favorite of the bunch.
The homemade taste is the first thing people mention, with the filling described as hearty and satisfying in the way only scratch-made recipes can achieve. Tender turkey, vegetables, and a thick, flavorful gravy come together inside that signature flaky crust the bakery is known for.
One family noted that while opinions were split on the chicken version, everyone agreed the turkey pot pie was a winner. These pies come frozen for home baking, making them an easy and impressive dinner option any night of the week.
Grabbing a couple to keep in the freezer is a smart move.
No Sugar Added Pies for Every Kind of Sweet Tooth
Just Pies understands that not everyone can enjoy a traditional sugar-filled dessert, and they have made sure nobody feels left out. The bakery offers a thoughtful selection of no-sugar-added pies that do not sacrifice flavor or quality to fit a dietary need.
For people managing diabetes or simply watching their sugar intake, finding a genuinely delicious pie option can feel like a small miracle. Customers rave about these options, noting that the taste holds up impressively well without the added sweetness.
The same care and craftsmanship that goes into every other pie applies here too.
One enthusiastic reviewer mentioned the no-sugar-added selection as one of the standout features of the bakery, calling the overall experience amazing. Knowing that a treat is both delicious and mindful of your health makes enjoying it even better.
Just Pies makes sure the whole community can share in the joy of a great pie.
The Pre-Thanksgiving Rush: A Westerville Tradition
Every year, as Thanksgiving approaches, something remarkable happens outside a small bakery on Northfield Road in Westerville. Lines form before the doors even open, stretching out into the cold morning air, filled with people who have driven from all over Ohio just to secure their holiday pies.
One reviewer described arriving before 8 AM and still waiting 30 minutes in freezing temperatures, cheerfully noting that the pies were absolutely worth every shivering minute. The bakery sometimes adjusts its hours for the holiday week, so checking the website ahead of time is a smart move.
This kind of crowd is not manufactured by marketing. It is earned through years of consistent quality and genuine community connection.
If you plan to join the Thanksgiving rush, dress warmly, arrive early, and bring patience. The reward waiting inside more than makes up for the wait outside.
Small Pies: Big Flavor Without the Commitment
Not everyone needs to bring home a full-sized pie, and Just Pies gets that completely. The bakery offers pies in small, medium, and large sizes, giving customers the freedom to sample multiple flavors without overcommitting to one giant dessert.
The small size option has been specifically praised by reviewers who appreciate the chance to try several varieties in one visit. Imagine picking up a small key lime, a small buckeye, and a small blueberry all in one trip and turning dessert into a tasting experience.
That is genuinely fun and a great way to find your new favorite flavor.
One reviewer even mentioned that they especially appreciate the small pie option as a feature that sets Just Pies apart from other bakeries. For solo eaters, couples, or anyone who just wants a little taste of something special, the small pie format is a thoughtful and delicious solution.
Fresh or Frozen: Flexibility That Makes Life Easier
One of the most practical and underrated features of Just Pies is the option to buy pies either fresh or frozen. That flexibility opens up a world of convenience for customers who want to plan ahead or stock their freezer with something far better than anything from a grocery store.
The frozen pies bake up beautifully at home, making them a fantastic option for weeknight dinners or last-minute entertaining. A couple of reviewers shared tips about baking times and oven adjustments, which shows just how engaged and invested the customer community is around these pies.
One family described popping a frozen beef pie into a convection oven and having a delicious, no-prep dinner ready within 90 minutes. That kind of ease, combined with genuine homemade quality, is hard to beat.
Grabbing a few extra pies to freeze on your next visit is advice worth taking seriously.
How to Find Us
Finding Just Pies Inc is easier than you might think, and the trip is absolutely worth every mile. The shop is located in Westerville, Ohio, a cozy suburb just northeast of Columbus that is simple to reach from most major highways in the state.
Plug the address into your GPS and you will be pulling into the parking lot before you know it. The storefront is charming and easy to spot, with a warm, welcoming look that practically waves you inside.
Hours can change around busy seasons like Thanksgiving, so checking their Facebook page before you head out is always a smart move.