In Indiana, a proper pork tenderloin sandwich is judged by one simple test: does the meat hang way past the edges of the bun? The best ones are pounded thin, breaded, fried, and served so wide you have to plan your first bite.
Hoosiers take this sandwich seriously, and taverns are where it tends to shine brightest. Some of these spots sit inside buildings older than most towns out west, while others are neighborhood hangouts in small villages and busy city corners.
This list covers six taverns across the state where the tenderloin is the main event, from a German-style stop in a tiny village to a Broad Ripple bar covered in basketball history. Each one has its own personality, its own crowd, and its own take on the classic.
Bring an appetite, and maybe a friend to split the onion rings.
1. The Willard, Franklin, IN
Few sandwiches in Indiana come with a backstory as old as the building they are served in. The Willard sits inside an 1860s structure at 99 N Main St in downtown Franklin, and it has been a tavern stop for a long time.
The star here is an award-winning breaded pork tenderloin. It arrives thick and juicy, with seasoning that holds its own against the crispy breading.
Pair it with the onion rings, which get almost as much attention as the sandwich.
The rest of the menu leans into pub comfort. Pizza is a big draw, along with a patty melt, Reuben, loaded fries, and fried pickles.
The steak salad is large enough that a take-home box is pretty likely.
Inside, the space has a cozy, British pub kind of style, and there is a patio for warmer days. Families are welcome too, with high chairs and a kids menu available.
Hours run 11 a.m. to 9 p.m. most days, stretching to 10 p.m. on Friday and Saturday. Friday nights and Saturdays get busy, and parking downtown can take a lap or two, so a weekday lunch is the easier play.
2. The Friendly Tavern, Zionsville, IN
Expect a wait, and consider it part of the deal. The Friendly Tavern does not take reservations, and on Friday evenings and Saturdays the line is a sign the kitchen is doing something right.
Located at 290 S Main St, the tavern sits along Zionsville’s charming brick-street downtown. It runs as a bustling neighborhood pub with classic American food and daily specials.
The pork tenderloin sandwich is the headliner, and it often goes out with a side of coleslaw. I like that pairing because the cool slaw balances all that fried crunch.
Wings carry the house name as Friendly’s Famous Wings, and the menu also includes walleye, catfish, and chili. It is classic tavern food without a lot of fuss.
One thing to plan around: this is an adults-only spot, so no kids allowed. It is closed on Sundays, open 11 a.m. to 10 p.m.
Monday through Thursday, and until 11 p.m. on Friday and Saturday. Parking is usually easy, which helps after the walk around downtown shops.
3. TC’s Restaurant & Tavern, Battle Ground, IN
Battle Ground is home to around 1,800 people, and a good number of them seem to know exactly where to eat. TC’s Restaurant and Tavern, at 109 N Railroad St, is a no-frills local favorite known for large portions.
The breaded tenderloin sandwich fits that reputation well. It is a big, classic Hoosier version, the kind where the bun looks a little outmatched.
Prime rib is the other name that comes up often on the menu, so it makes a good backup if someone in your group wants a knife-and-fork dinner.
This is an easy road trip stop from Lafayette and West Lafayette, just a short drive northeast. The setting is casual, with a bar onsite and room for families, including high chairs and a kids menu.
Timing matters here. TC’s opens at 4 p.m. on Monday, runs 11 a.m. to 9 p.m.
Tuesday through Saturday, and is closed Sunday. Dinner reservations are recommended, especially Thursday through Saturday evenings.
4. The Brau Haus, Oldenburg, IN
Oldenburg goes by the nickname Village of Spires, and with fewer than 700 residents, its German roots are easy to spot. The Brau Haus at 22170 Water St fits right in with a traditional German menu.
It is also a stop on the Tenderloin Trail. The breaded tenderloin here is noticeably thick and hearty, a bit different from the thinner, wider styles found at many Indiana taverns, and a grilled version is on the menu too.
Sauerkraut balls with Dusseldorf mustard are the side order to get. The Bavarian pretzel with beer cheese, a Reuben, a roast beef Manhattan, and a fried chicken dinner for two round things out.
The vibe is family-friendly, with high chairs, a kids menu, outdoor seating, and dogs allowed. There is even a private dining room and catering.
Hours are 11 a.m. to 8 p.m. Tuesday through Sunday, and it is closed Monday.
Saturday evenings get the biggest crowds, so arrive early if you are driving in from Cincinnati or Indianapolis.
5. Plump’s Last Shot, Indianapolis, IN
Basketball fans will recognize the name right away. The walls at Plump’s Last Shot are covered in Indiana basketball memorabilia, making it as much a hoops shrine as a place to eat.
The bar sits at 6416 Cornell Ave in Broad Ripple, one of the most walkable neighborhoods in Indianapolis. It has a spacious patio, bar games, and plenty of screens for game days.
The menu stays short and to the point. The breaded pork tenderloin sandwich is the headline order, with burgers and onion rings filling in around it.
Late hours set this one apart from the rest of the list. It opens at noon every day and stays open until 3 a.m., so it works for a lazy afternoon or a late bite.
Reservations are not accepted, and Saturday nights get packed. Dogs are allowed, and parking nearby can be tight, so walking or biking in from elsewhere in Broad Ripple is a smart move.
6. Aristocrat Pub & Oxford Room, Indianapolis, IN
A pub that opened in 1933 has had plenty of time to perfect its signature sandwich. Aristocrat Pub and Oxford Room, at 5212 N College Ave, operates inside a restored space with walls covered in vintage finds.
On the menu, the sandwich goes by The Hoosier Tenderloin, and the name says a lot. It is an oversized, state-pride kind of order.
The kitchen ranges wider than most taverns. German schnitzel makes a fun pick for anyone who loves the tenderloin idea in a different form, and there is also fish and chips, fish tacos, baked brie, and a fried green tomato caprese.
Beyond the food, the pub hosts trivia nights and live music, and there is outdoor seating plus a private dining room. Sunday hours start at 10 a.m., which makes it an easy weekend brunch-time stop.
It is closed Mondays and open until 9 or 10 p.m. the rest of the week. Expect a slightly higher bill than other spots here, typically $20 to $30 per person, and leave a few extra minutes for parking along College Avenue.
Enjoyed this story?
Add Fast Food Club as a preferred source to see more of our reporting on Google.