Summer crowds leave Long Island after Labor Day, but the clams stay. Some of the best seafood shacks on the Island keep the steamer pots going well into September, October, and even November.
That means shorter lines, easier parking, and the same buckets of clams with melted butter and broth on the side. Here are seven spots, from the South Shore to the East End and the North Shore, where a fall steamer run still makes perfect sense.
1. Peter’s Clam Bar, Island Park, NY
Peter’s has been shucking and steaming in Island Park since the summer of 1940. That is a long run for any restaurant, and it shows in the old-fashioned raw bar setup.
The steamers come by the bucket, and one bucket is generous enough to share across a table of four with an appetizer like a crab cake on the side. Baked clams, fried clam strips, and a full clam bake round out the clam side of the menu.
Not everyone at the table has to want shellfish. Lobster mac and cheese, lobster rolls, Alaskan king crab legs, and New England clam chowder all show up here, along with burgers, chicken fingers, and a kids’ menu.
The outdoor seating faces the water, which makes a mild fall afternoon a smart time to visit. Hours run daily from 11 AM, with Friday and Saturday going until 10 PM.
Weekend evenings get busy, so a weekday lunch is the calmer play. Reservations are accepted, and there is usually plenty of parking.
2. Out of the Blue Seafood, Hampton Bays, NY
Half fish market, half counter-serve kitchen, Out of the Blue is the kind of place where you can buy fillets for dinner and eat steamers for lunch on the same stop.
The shop on East Montauk Highway specializes in fresh and smoked seafood, with a patio out front. A bucket of steamers paired with corn on the cob is a classic order, and the fried oysters have a loyal following too.
The staff know their fish and are happy to explain what came in fresh. That makes the market side especially handy if you want to cook at home.
Hours are easy to remember: 10 AM to 9 PM, seven days a week. Free parking is available in the lot and on the street, and delivery is an option.
I like this stop for a low-key Hamptons meal without the fuss.
3. Jordan Lobster Farms, Island Park, NY
Canal views and a nautical motif set the scene at Jordan Lobster Farms, a longtime Island Park seafood stop on Pettit Place.
The name says lobster, and the whole lobsters here are big. Still, the steamers earn plenty of attention, served in large portions and also available sauteed with butter, wine, and garlic.
The menu goes well beyond shellfish. Crispy whole striped bass, Chilean sea bass, swordfish steak, a fried fisherman’s platter, and a Maine lobster roll all appear, with sides like sweet potato fries, potato salad, coleslaw, and garlic bread.
It runs as a no-frills classic shack, with both counter and table service plus an outdoor patio. Doors open daily from 10 AM to 8 PM.
Weekdays are noticeably quieter than weekend afternoons. Dogs are welcome, and parking is usually easy.
4. Clam Bar at Napeague, Amagansett, NY
Bring cash. The Clam Bar at Napeague takes cash and traveler’s checks only, and that old-school rule fits the place perfectly.
This roadside fish shack sits on the Napeague stretch of Montauk Highway between Amagansett and Montauk. It opens in April and keeps going into November, which makes it one of the better late-season stops on the East End.
Food arrives on paper plates, and nobody minds. Lobster rolls, steamers, fried clam strips, fried calamari, tuna bites, and New England clam chowder are the big draws.
Seating includes tables, a counter, and room to stand. Live music adds to the energy on some days.
Fall hours are shorter on weekdays, running 11:30 AM to 4 PM Monday through Thursday. Friday through Sunday stretch to 8 PM.
5. Bostwick’s Chowder House, East Hampton, NY
Here is a handy date to remember: Bostwick’s typically closes for the season the Sunday after Thanksgiving. That gives steamer fans most of November to get one more bucket in.
The Pantigo Road spot has casual beachy digs with wainscoting, nautical decor, and patio tables. It is small and popular, so a wait is common, and reservations are not accepted.
Steamers here are known for being very fresh. The hot buttered lobster roll, fried oysters, fish and chips, and chowders are the other headliners.
Look for a few house signatures too, including lobster fritters, baked stuffed clams, and the famous oyster shooter. Families can lean on the kids’ fish and chips.
Plan around the schedule, since Bostwick’s is closed Tuesday and Wednesday. Other days run 11:30 AM to 9 PM.
6. The Steam Room, Port Jefferson, NY
With a name like The Steam Room, the steamers better be good. This longtime Port Jefferson fixture puts them right at the center of the menu.
The restaurant overlooks the harbor and the Long Island Sound, with a greenhouse-style dining area and a sunset deck. It is a good North Shore option when the South Fork feels far.
Whole lobster, steamers, mussels, clams, and corn make up the classic order, often paired with soup or salad. The menu also lists seafood paella, a fisherman’s platter, clams on the half shell, and frequent specials.
Prices stay friendly, generally around 20 to 30 dollars per person. Hours open early at 9 AM daily, and dogs are even allowed inside.
No reservations are taken, so arriving on a weekday afternoon helps. Pair the meal with a stroll through the village.
7. Point Lookout Clam Bar, Point Lookout, NY
Sunset over the bay is part of the menu at Point Lookout Clam Bar on Bayside Drive.
Fresh local steamers headline the shellfish lineup. The raw bar, New England clam chowder, lobster roll, shrimp cocktail, and seafood salad back them up.
It also covers fried favorites like calamari, clams, and fish sandwiches, plus halibut fish tacos and sushi. That range helps when a group cannot agree on dinner.
Waterfront tables and a back deck give the place its edge, and the spot can host private parties with deck access. There is a full bar and TVs for game days.
Hours run 11:30 AM to 9 PM every day, so a September or October weekday visit is easy to fit in. Reservations are not taken.
If one list stop doubles as a final beach-day ritual of the year, this is it.
Enjoyed this story?
Add Fast Food Club as a preferred source to see more of our reporting on Google.