Some sandwiches are lunch, and some are a full afternoon commitment. On a busy stretch of North Avenue in Milwaukee, one old-school counter has been stacking corned beef high since 1955.
Families have passed the habit down from parents to kids, and plenty of people still drive across town just for one order. The portions are so generous that a single sandwich usually ends the conversation about seconds.
Some folks even joke that once a week is the safe limit. This article covers the story behind the counter, the menu stars beyond corned beef, the honest ups and downs, and the practical details you need before you go.
Bring an appetite and maybe a friend to split things with.
A North Avenue Address With Decades Behind It
Milwaukee has its share of famous lunch counters, but few have stayed on the same street as long as Jake’s Delicatessen. The deli sits at 1634 W North Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53205, in the United States.
It is a deli in the most traditional sense. The focus is hot corned beef, pastrami, and other sandwiches, plus a handful of sides.
The place has been open since 1955. That makes it one of the longer-running sandwich stops in the city, and its name carries real weight with locals.
Some people call it the king of corned beef in Milwaukee. Others say a person does not truly know the city until they have eaten here.
That is a big claim for a sandwich shop. Still, the loyalty is easy to find, and it often stretches across generations.
The building itself is described as venerable, which fits a business with this much history. Nothing here tries to be trendy or flashy.
The approach is simple. Slice the meat, pile it on bread, and hand it over the counter.
For first-timers, that straightforward setup is part of the appeal. The rest of the story explains why so many people keep coming back.
Seventy Years of Slicing
Back in 1955, Milwaukee got a new deli on North Avenue, and it never really left. Seven decades later, Jake’s still works the same basic formula.
A long run like that builds memories. Many people first tasted the corned beef as kids, when their parents brought sandwiches home from the counter.
Now some of those same kids are adults bringing their own families. One regular mentions a father who has been coming for more than twenty years.
The deli has seen changes along the way. It came under new management on February 1, 2022, and the team has said it reads feedback and takes it into consideration.
Longtime fans sometimes feel the sandwiches are not exactly as they remember. Others insist the quality of the brining and cooking keeps it at number one.
That debate is part of what happens when a place lasts this long. Everyone has a version of Jake’s they grew up with.
What has stayed steady is the identity. It remains an old-school delicatessen built around hot cured meats and big sandwiches.
History alone does not fill a plate, though. The next part is about what actually lands on it.
The Corned Beef Mountain
Corned beef is the headline act here, and it is not even close. It is the single most talked-about item on the menu.
The sandwiches come loaded. Portions are often called very generous and very filling, which is exactly what the article title promises.
Many people call it the best corned beef in Wisconsin. Others go further and say it is the best corned beef sandwich they have ever had.
One common joke is about pacing yourself. A sandwich this hefty might be a once-a-week treat, not a daily habit.
The meat is described as tender. Some orders come out fattier than expected, so asking for lean cuts is a smart move if that matters to you.
Toppings can be customized. Cheese, pickles, and paprika show up on some orders, and mustard is a standard choice.
A word of advice: speak up about how you want it. Asking for toasting, extra cheese melt, or a lighter hand with the mustard helps the sandwich match your taste.
Plenty of people walk in planning to order two. Most leave realizing one was plenty after all.
Pastrami Gets Its Own Fan Club
Corned beef may be the star, but pastrami is a close second in conversation. It earns plenty of loyal fans of its own.
The pastrami sandwich has been described as tender, flavorful, and huge. One fan put it simply: this is what a pastrami sandwich should look like.
Some say it is worth the drive all by itself. People compare it to other delis and keep coming back here.
There is one practical tip worth passing along. Untoasted, the sandwich can be so stacked that it turns into a knife-and-fork situation.
Getting it toasted helps the bread hold together better. That small request can save a lot of napkins.
Not every visit has been perfect. Some have found the meat less seasoned than expected, and pastrami has occasionally been unavailable despite the neon sign over the counter.
A turkey pastrami option also appears on the menu. It gives a lighter path for those who want the style without the beef.
Between the two cured meats, picking a favorite becomes a fun little argument. Settling it may require more than one trip.
Reuben Season Never Really Ends
Ask a regular what to order and the Reuben comes up fast. It is one of the most mentioned sandwiches on the menu.
The build stays classic. Corned beef, Swiss cheese, and dressing like Thousand Island come together on a sandwich packed with meat.
People call it satisfying and well worth the price. Some say it is the best Reuben you will find for a long way around Milwaukee.
Family recommendations play a big role here. Dads introducing their kids to the Reuben is a recurring theme.
Mid-March is when things get intense. St. Patrick’s Day is the biggest Reuben day of the year, and crowds line up before the doors open at 10 AM.
That rush has caused trouble before. Long outdoor waits on that day have frustrated some guests, so planning ahead is wise.
Calling in an order early, arriving with patience, or picking a quieter day can make a big difference. Cold Wisconsin mornings are no fun for standing in line.
On any regular weekday, though, the Reuben is right there waiting. No holiday required.
Egg Rolls at a Deli Counter
Here is a surprise for first-timers: egg rolls. Yes, at a classic corned beef deli.
Corned beef-filled egg rolls show up on the menu. They take the house specialty and wrap it into a handheld snack.
Fans call the egg rolls awesome. Some people say they would return just for those and the fries.
The fries get love too. They make an easy partner for a sandwich that already takes up most of the table.
The menu goes past the expected in other ways as well. Chicken wings, a burnt ends sandwich, a corned beef Philly, and even catfish come up in conversation.
A Philly cheesesteak has been offered too. Ingredient swaps sometimes happen when an item like peppers runs out.
One fan summed it up neatly: anything with corned beef is delicious. That rule seems to apply to the egg rolls as well.
Ordering a sandwich plus a side of egg rolls for the table is a fun way to sample. Sharing is optional, but strongly advised.
Sides Worth a Spot on the Tray
Every big sandwich needs a sidekick. At Jake’s, the classic deli sides fill that role.
Potato salad and coleslaw are regular companions. Some diners say neither one disappoints.
Taste is personal, of course. The potato salad has struck at least one person as needing more pickles, which is the kind of preference that varies from table to table.
Fries are another dependable option. They show up alongside sandwiches and egg rolls in many orders.
Pickles also appear as a topping choice for some sandwiches. They add a nice balance to all that meat.
Since the sandwiches are already so large, sides can easily become leftovers. Grabbing one side to share is often enough.
That approach also keeps the bill friendlier. Most meals land in the ten to twenty dollar range per person.
The sides are not the reason people drive across town. They are the supporting cast that makes the main event feel complete.
Old-School Digs, No Frills Attached
Nobody comes here for designer decor. The setting is old-school and unfussy, and that is part of its character.
A neon sign hangs above the deli counter. It is the kind of detail that signals a place with a long past.
Some people describe the vibe as unique and authentic. Others find the energy flatter than it used to be.
Cleanliness gets solid credit. The deli has been called really clean, which matters a lot at a busy counter.
The dining room can run cool in colder months. Some guests choose takeout for that reason.
Takeout is popular in general. Calling ahead is common, though a short wait after arriving is still possible.
The neighborhood setting on North Avenue comes with its own realities. Being aware of your surroundings when coming and going is sensible, as on any city street.
For people who love tradition, the setting is honest and familiar. It is a deli first and a dining room second.
Who Fits at the Counter
Some places are built for everyone. Jake’s is built especially for people who love a serious sandwich.
Families with long ties to Milwaukee fit right in. Parents and grown kids often share the tradition together.
Food-minded folks show up too. The deli has been recommended by a chef and his restaurant friends, which says something about its reputation.
Big appetites are well served here. One sandwich can easily cover a meal, and sometimes a second one later.
Picky eaters should come ready to customize. Requests like lean meat, toasted bread, or less mustard help a lot.
The staff is often described as friendly and polite. A manager has stepped in before to fix an order and keep things on track.
Service is not always smooth, though. Slow moments and brusque exchanges have happened, especially during rushes.
Patience pays off here. Those who arrive relaxed and hungry tend to leave happiest.
Hours, Costs, and Timing Tips
Timing matters at a deli that closes in the late afternoon. Jake’s keeps daytime hours only.
The doors open at 10 AM and close at 5 PM, Monday through Saturday. Sunday is a day off, so plan weekend cravings around Saturday.
Expect to spend about ten to twenty dollars per person. A loaded sandwich alone can approach the top of that range.
Costs have climbed in recent years. The owners have pointed to rising prices for quality ingredients as the reason.
Calling ahead is a handy move for takeout. Even so, a short wait at pickup is common.
Busy days call for extra planning. St. Patrick’s Day brings huge lines, and early arrival does not always mean quick service.
Online info is available through the deli’s website. It is worth checking before heading over.
A little planning keeps the visit easy. After all, the only thing that should feel heavy is the sandwich.
The Verdict on a Milwaukee Classic
Seventy years is a long time to keep slicing the same meats. Jake’s has done it with stubborn devotion to the classics.
Not every sandwich wins every heart. Some find the meat too fatty or the flavor milder than they recall.
Many others call it the best corned beef in the state. They point to the brining, the cooking, and the sheer size of each order.
That mix of praise and critique is honest. It reflects a place with deep roots and high expectations.
For first-timers, the move is clear. Order the corned beef or the Reuben, ask for it how you like it, and add egg rolls if you are curious.
Plan around the hours and avoid peak holiday rushes if lines are not your thing. Bring patience and a healthy appetite.
Jake’s is less about polish and more about tradition. It is a piece of Milwaukee history served on bread.
One sandwich really is plenty. The hard part is deciding when to come back for the next one.
Enjoyed this story?
Add Fast Food Club as a preferred source to see more of our reporting on Google.