Fast Food Club Fast Food Club

Snowbirds Driving South This Winter Will Find Seven Old Florida Fish Camps Still Serving Gator Tail

David Coleman 5 min read
featured image 95ff18eb916b 1ee9b6e765d7
Snowbirds Driving South This Winter Will Find Seven Old Florida Fish Camps Still Serving Gator Tail

Some of the best meals in Florida are not found near the theme parks or the high-rise beach hotels. They are found at old fish camps on rivers, creeks, and lakes, where the menus still list frog legs, catfish, and fried gator tail.

If you are heading south this winter, these seven spots make easy stops off the main roads. Each one has its own setting and its own style, so pick the one that fits your route.

1. Whitey’s Fish Camp, Fleming Island, FL

Whitey's Fish Camp, Fleming Island, FL
© Whitey’s Fish Camp, Fleming Island, FL

Gator bites come with their own gator sauce here, which tells you this kitchen takes the dish seriously. Whitey’s sits on County Road 220 in Fleming Island, south of Jacksonville, with outdoor seating and water views.

The menu leans Southern. Alligator tail shares space with shrimp and grits, buffalo shrimp, fried pickles, seafood queso, blackened catfish, and a fried oyster platter.

Live music and a casual, historic feel give the place a lively edge, especially on weekend nights. Fridays and Saturdays run until 11 PM, while Monday service starts at 3 PM.

Families are well covered with high chairs and a kids’ menu, and dogs are welcome outside. Reservations are not accepted, so a weekday lunch is the calmer choice for snowbirds who prefer a quieter table.

2. Lone Cabbage Fish Camp, Cocoa, FL

Lone Cabbage Fish Camp, Cocoa, FL
© Lone Cabbage Fish Camp, Cocoa, FL

Lunch and an airboat ride in one stop is a hard combo to beat. Lone Cabbage Fish Camp sits on the St. Johns River west of Cocoa, and its website doubles as the home of Twister Airboat Rides.

The food is pure Old Florida. Look for the fried frog legs, catfish, and gator bites plate, plus hush puppies, fried okra, clam strips, fish tacos, and cheeseburgers.

Prices run about $10 to $20 per person, among the friendliest on this list. Country music, a roomy patio, and river views set a low-key pace.

Doors open at 10 AM every day. Sunday afternoon draws the biggest crowd, and dogs are allowed.

3. Jolly Gator Fish Camp, Geneva, FL

Jolly Gator Fish Camp, Geneva, FL
© Jolly Gator Fish Camp, Geneva, FL

With a name like Jolly Gator, skipping the gator would feel rude. This rustic riverfront stop on State Road 46 in Geneva serves gator bites fried or grilled, plus gator burgers for anyone wanting a sandwich.

The setting is calm St. Johns River country, with an airboat launch right on site. It feels far from the Orlando traffic just to the south.

Other menu picks include fried shrimp baskets, frog legs, mahi mahi, grouper sandwiches, corn fritters, and key lime pie. Karaoke and live music add some fun.

Plan ahead on timing. It opens Wednesday through Sunday from 11 AM to 8 PM and stays closed Monday and Tuesday.

4. Palms Fish Camp Restaurant, Jacksonville, FL

Palms Fish Camp Restaurant, Jacksonville, FL
© Palms Fish Camp Restaurant, Jacksonville, FL

A little Louisiana flair shows up in north Jacksonville at Palms Fish Camp. Crawfish and huge frog legs sit right beside the gator tail on the menu.

The restaurant overlooks Clapboard Creek along Heckscher Drive, near the route toward the Mayport ferry and the beaches. A waterfront deck and boat slips keep things close to the water.

Local flavor runs deep. Mayport peel and eat shrimp, oysters on the half shell, shrimp and grits, and pork rinds with smoked fish dip are all standouts, with bread pudding for dessert.

Unlike several stops here, Palms accepts reservations. That helps on weekend afternoons, the busiest stretch, and dogs are welcome.

5. Fish Camp Lake Eustis, Tavares, FL

Fish Camp Lake Eustis, Tavares, FL
© Fish Camp Lake Eustis, Tavares, FL

Boaters can pull right up to the dock for lunch, which fits Tavares and its nickname as America’s Seaplane City. Fish Camp sits on the shore of Lake Eustis with an open-air deck.

The gator gets a slightly fancier touch here, with fresh-cut alligator served with grain mustard. Fried gator bites are on the menu too.

Fish arrives from the Atlantic, the Gulf, and fresh water sources. The Seafood Trio Tavares, fish camp tacos, all you can eat catfish, clam chowder, and key lime pie round out the options.

Reservations are accepted, and delivery is available. Weekend afternoons fill up fastest.

6. Fat Willie’s Fish Camp, Valrico, FL

Fat Willie's Fish Camp, Valrico, FL
© Fat Willie’s Fish Camp, Valrico, FL

No river view at this one, and that is fine. Fat Willie’s on Main Street in Valrico, east of Tampa, wins on food and its homey, supper club feel.

Gator comes as a po’boy, in baskets, or as bites. Cajun hush puppies, popcorn crawfish, clam strips, scallops, and fried pickles fill out the menu, and fish can be fried, grilled, or blackened.

Mississippi mud pie is the dessert to save room for. Kids get their own catfish and shrimp baskets.

Hours are short, so check before you go. It opens Thursday through Saturday from 4:30 to 9 PM and Sunday from 12:30 to 7:30 PM, and parking can be tight.

7. St. Augustine Fish Camp, St. Augustine, FL

St. Augustine Fish Camp, St. Augustine, FL
© St. Augustine Fish Camp, St. Augustine, FL

History buffs touring the nation’s oldest city can trade the cobblestones for crispy gator tail. St. Augustine Fish Camp sits on Riberia Street along the San Sebastian River, with a marina and terrace dining.

The menu pays tribute to fish camp roots with a polished touch. Fried gator tail joins Abaco conch fritters, fried green tomatoes with herbed goat cheese, smoked fish spread, and snow crab legs.

Dessert is a strength, especially the white chocolate bread pudding and key lime pie. There is also a broiled seafood platter and clam chowder.

Expect a wait, so reservations are wise for lunch, dinner, or brunch. Monday service starts at 4 PM, and valet parking is available.

Seven fish camps, seven different moods, and one shared tradition. Save this list for the drive down.

Enjoyed this story?

Add Fast Food Club as a preferred source to see more of our reporting on Google.

Follow us on Google

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *