Tucked away at 1673 Two Rod Rd in Marilla, New York, the Marilla Country Store is the kind of place that makes you feel like you’ve stepped back in time the moment you walk through the door. This charming two-story building is packed from floor to ceiling with homemade sweets, specialty foods, unique gifts, and so much more.
With a near-perfect 4.8-star rating from over a thousand happy visitors, it’s clear that this hidden gem has won the hearts of locals and travelers alike. Whether you’re hunting for old-fashioned candy, fresh deli food, or one-of-a-kind souvenirs, Marilla Country Store has something special waiting just for you.
The Legendary Orange Chocolate Sponge Candy
Some sweets have a way of stopping you in your tracks, and the orange chocolate sponge candy at Marilla Country Store is exactly that kind of treat. Customers rave about it so passionately that one reviewer called it “to die for” — high praise for a confection that’s already become the store’s most talked-about item.
Sponge candy has deep roots in the Buffalo, New York area, and Marilla Country Store honors that tradition beautifully. The airy, honeycomb-like center melts on your tongue while the rich chocolate coating adds a satisfying snap.
Add a hint of orange, and you’ve got something truly unforgettable.
Many visitors say they make the trip to Marilla just for this candy alone. Grab a box to share — or keep it all to yourself.
Nobody will judge you for it.
The Homemade Gingersnaps That Keep Visitors Coming Back
Forget store-bought cookies — the homemade gingersnaps at Marilla Country Store are in a league of their own. One enthusiastic reviewer specifically called them out as the highlight of their visit, saying the gingersnaps “garner my prize and warrant more visits.” That’s the kind of compliment that speaks volumes.
Baked with that perfect balance of spice and sweetness, these cookies have a satisfying crunch that makes it nearly impossible to eat just one. The warm ginger aroma alone is enough to draw you toward the baked goods section the moment you walk in.
Even the store owners seem proud of their gingersnaps, personally responding to reviews with excitement about them. Whether you pair them with a hot drink or snack on them during the drive home, these little cookies deliver big on flavor and nostalgia.
Dozens of Old-Fashioned Hard-to-Find Candies
Walking into the candy section of Marilla Country Store feels like opening a time capsule. Rows of glass jars and bins overflow with hard-to-find treats that most people haven’t seen since childhood — the kind of candies your grandparents used to buy for a penny at the corner store.
From wax bottles and root beer barrels to licorice twists and candy buttons, the selection is genuinely impressive. One reviewer mentioned spotting candy their mother used to buy for them, which shows just how deep the nostalgia runs here.
It’s not just candy — it’s a memory wrapped in cellophane.
Kids and adults alike spend serious time browsing this section. With so many rare and retro options, it’s easy to fill a bag quickly.
Budget a little extra time — and a little extra cash — for this irresistible corner of the store.
The Two-Story Building With a Fascinating Layout
At first glance, Marilla Country Store looks like a beautifully converted red and white house — because that’s exactly what it is. But don’t let the cozy exterior fool you.
Inside, the space expands in ways that seem almost impossible, with room after room packed with treasures waiting to be discovered.
The two-story layout adds to the adventure. The ground floor handles groceries, deli items, gifts, and specialty foods, while the second floor holds a museum that transports visitors straight to the past.
Navigating the tight, winding rooms is part of the charm, even if it means squeezing past other excited shoppers.
One reviewer noted that the store is not handicap accessible due to its historic layout, so it’s worth keeping that in mind when planning your visit. For everyone else, the exploration is half the fun.
The Upstairs Museum — A True Hidden Treasure
Hidden above the bustling shop floor lies one of the most unexpected surprises at Marilla Country Store — a genuine museum. Multiple reviewers mentioned the second-floor museum as a highlight of their visit, with one calling it a “True Treasure” and another saying it transports you straight back to yesteryear.
The museum features antique displays, historical artifacts, and vintage collectibles that tell the story of a simpler time. It’s thoughtfully curated and genuinely interesting, making it feel less like a storage room and more like a lovingly preserved exhibit.
Many visitors almost miss it because they get so caught up shopping on the ground floor. Make sure you head upstairs before you leave — you won’t regret it.
The museum alone makes Marilla Country Store worth the drive, turning a shopping trip into a mini history lesson you’ll actually enjoy.
A Deli Counter Worth Stopping For
Hungry after a long drive to Marilla? The in-store deli counter has you covered.
Reviewers consistently praise the generous portion sizes and fair pricing, making it a reliable lunch stop whether you’re passing through or spending the whole afternoon exploring the store.
The deli offers fresh-made sandwiches and other prepared items that hit the spot after working up an appetite browsing two floors of amazing products. It’s the kind of no-fuss, satisfying food that pairs perfectly with the store’s laid-back, old-fashioned atmosphere.
Pair your deli order with one of the store’s specialty sodas — the soda selection alone gets its own rave reviews — and you’ve got yourself a pretty solid lunch. Several visitors recommend grabbing food first before shopping, so you’re not distracted by hunger while you browse.
Smart strategy, honestly.
Specialty Foods, Local Cheeses, and Unique Sodas
Foodies, rejoice. Marilla Country Store is stocked with an impressive lineup of specialty foods that goes way beyond your average grocery run.
Local and regional cheeses sit alongside artisan jams, pickles, honey, and an enormous variety of spices that one reviewer described with a simple but enthusiastic “So many spices!”
The soda selection deserves its own mention. Unusual flavors and hard-to-find brands line the shelves, making it a fun browsing experience even if you’re not particularly thirsty.
Pair a specialty soda with a locally made cheese and some crackers, and you’ve accidentally put together a fantastic snack spread.
Fresh roasted nuts also make a popular pick-up item, with reviewers mentioning them alongside jams and pickles as must-buys. The food section alone could keep a curious shopper busy for a solid half hour, and that’s before you even touch the candy aisle.
Home Decor, Polish Pottery, and Unique Gifts
Beyond the food and sweets, Marilla Country Store doubles as a seriously impressive gift shop. Polish pottery — known for its bold patterns and high quality — shares shelf space with local jewelry, candles, soaps, and a wide range of home decor items that range from rustic to refined.
Reviewers have spotted items from local brands like Rustic Buffalo and 716, giving the store a strong sense of regional pride. Whether you’re shopping for yourself or hunting for the perfect gift, the variety here is genuinely hard to beat.
One shopper noted they always find “things they didn’t know they needed” — a feeling most visitors seem to share.
Gift wrapping is available, which makes holiday shopping here especially convenient. The store’s atmosphere alone makes gift-giving feel more personal and thoughtful, like you’re sharing a little piece of Marilla with someone you care about.
Seasonal Decorations and Christmas Festival Magic
If you think Marilla Country Store is charming on a regular day, wait until the holiday season rolls around. The store transforms into a wonderland of seasonal decorations, Christmas ornaments, and festive gifts that make it nearly impossible to leave empty-handed.
The annual Marilla Christmas Festival is a community event that draws visitors from across the region, and the store plays a central role in the celebration. One reviewer called it “a must” and said the holiday atmosphere takes the already-magical store to a whole new level.
Year-round, the seasonal decor section rotates to match whatever time of year you visit. From fall harvest displays to spring-themed gifts, there’s always something fresh and fitting on the shelves.
Planning your visit around a seasonal event or holiday weekend turns a regular shopping trip into a full-on festive experience worth marking on your calendar.
Clothing, Winter Wear, and Buffalo Bills Gear
Sports fans and fashion lovers both find something to love in the apparel section of Marilla Country Store. Buffalo Bills gear — jerseys, hats, and other fan merchandise — sits proudly alongside cozy winter wear that’s perfect for surviving those brutal Western New York winters.
Reviewers have mentioned finding warm scarves, winter clothing, and “things for winter cuddling” among the store’s clothing offerings. It’s the kind of practical yet charming selection that fits perfectly in a country store setting, where comfort and function go hand in hand.
Whether you’re a die-hard Bills fan looking to rep your team or just someone who needs a warm layer before heading back outside, the clothing section delivers. It’s a reminder that Marilla Country Store isn’t just a novelty stop — it’s a genuinely useful place to shop for everyday needs with a local twist.
Old-Fashioned Toys and Novelty Items for All Ages
Remember the toys that came before screens took over? Marilla Country Store keeps that spirit alive with a delightful collection of old-fashioned toys and novelty items that spark joy in kids and grown-ups alike.
Wooden puzzles, classic games, and quirky knick-knacks fill the shelves with a sense of playful wonder.
Parents shopping with kids will appreciate having a section that encourages imagination over technology. The novelty gifts and fun trinkets also make fantastic stocking stuffers or birthday presents that stand out from the usual store-bought options.
One reviewer mentioned going “a little crazy” in the store — and the toy section is probably partly to blame.
Even if you don’t have kids, browsing the toys and novelty section is genuinely fun. You’ll likely stumble across something that brings back a fond memory or makes you laugh out loud.
That’s the Marilla magic at work.
Natural Soaps, Candles, and Personal Care Finds
Tucked among the food and gifts, Marilla Country Store also carries a lovely selection of natural soaps, hand-poured candles, and personal care items that feel a world away from the generic stuff you’d find at a big-box store. The scents alone make this section worth a slow browse.
Reviewers have mentioned the candles and soaps as standout items, with one visitor describing them as “amazing” and another noting they made great gifts. Many of the products come from local or small-batch makers, which gives each item a story and a quality that mass-produced goods simply can’t match.
Picking out a candle or a bar of artisan soap here feels like a small act of self-care wrapped in a bigger experience. It’s the kind of find that makes you feel good about your purchase long after you’ve left the store and headed home.
A Friendly Staff and Welcoming Small-Business Atmosphere
Great products are only part of what makes Marilla Country Store special. The people behind the counter play a huge role in the experience, and reviewers consistently highlight the staff as friendly, helpful, and genuinely warm.
One visitor said the workers are “so nice,” while the store owners regularly respond to reviews with heartfelt gratitude — a small but telling sign of how much they care.
Shopping here feels personal in a way that big retail chains simply can’t replicate. You’re supporting a small business rooted in its community, staffed by people who actually love what they do.
That energy is contagious and makes every visit feel like catching up with old friends.
Open seven days a week from 10 AM to 5 PM, the store is easy to work into a weekend day trip. Call ahead at 716-655-1031 or visit marillacountrystore.com to plan your visit.
Enjoyed this story?
Add Fast Food Club as a preferred source to see more of our reporting on Google.