Tucked along Route 664 in Logan, Ohio, Olde Dutch has been winning hearts with its warm, home-cooked comfort food for years. This family-friendly Amish-inspired restaurant sits right in the heart of Hocking Hills country, making it a natural stop for travelers and locals alike.
With a buffet packed full of traditional favorites, fresh-baked pies, and a welcoming atmosphere, it is easy to see why so many people keep coming back. Whether you are a first-time visitor or a longtime regular, Olde Dutch offers something truly special on every plate.
The Legendary Buffet Spread
Some buffets play it safe. Olde Dutch goes all in.
The buffet at this Logan, Ohio gem is the kind of spread that makes you wish you had skipped breakfast just so you could fit more on your plate.
Guests rave about dishes like roasted chicken, pot roast, turkey, sweet potato casserole, broccoli cheddar bake, and green bean casserole. It feels like a Thanksgiving feast available every single day of the week.
Priced around $17 to $18 per person, the buffet offers serious value for the sheer volume and variety of food you get. The kitchen team works hard to keep everything fresh and replenished throughout service.
For anyone who loves hearty, home-style cooking served in generous portions, this buffet is genuinely hard to beat anywhere in the state of Ohio.
Famous Broaster Chicken
Crispy on the outside, juicy on the inside, and clearly breaded fresh right on-site – the Broaster Chicken at Olde Dutch has earned its own fan club. Guests consistently mention it as one of the first things they load onto their plates.
Several reviewers noted that you can actually tell the chicken is hand-breaded in-house because the coating varies slightly from piece to piece. That kind of hands-on preparation is exactly what sets this place apart from chain restaurants trying to mimic homestyle cooking.
One loyal customer called it her absolute favorite item on the entire buffet. Whether you grab a breast, a thigh, or a drumstick, the flavor delivers every time.
If you visit Olde Dutch and skip the chicken, you are genuinely missing the star of the show. Go back for seconds – no judgment here.
Homemade Mashed Potatoes
There is something almost magical about a truly great mashed potato. Olde Dutch seems to understand this deeply.
Multiple reviewers have gone out of their way to specifically praise the mashed potatoes, calling them some of the best they have ever had anywhere.
Made in-house with a creamy, buttery finish, these are not the instant flakes or powder mix variety. You can taste the difference immediately.
Paired with roasted chicken or pot roast and a ladle of gravy, they become the kind of comfort food that makes you feel like you are sitting at grandma’s table on a Sunday afternoon.
The kitchen takes real pride in getting this classic dish right. For many visitors, the mashed potatoes alone are worth the trip to Logan.
Simple, honest, and deeply satisfying – this is home cooking done exactly the way it should be done.
Roasted Garlic Brussels Sprouts
Not everyone walks into a buffet expecting to fall in love with a vegetable. But the roasted garlic Brussels sprouts at Olde Dutch have converted more than a few skeptics.
Reviewers describe them as the best they have ever tasted – and that is saying something for a dish that many people usually pass right by.
The caramelized edges and garlic-forward flavor make these sprouts genuinely addictive. Multiple guests mentioned going back for second and even third helpings.
One reviewer joked that the staff must take Brussels sprouts very seriously, and honestly, the kitchen team takes that as a compliment.
Even the restaurant owner acknowledged the praise and passed it along to the kitchen crew. If you have always been on the fence about Brussels sprouts, this is the plate that might just change your mind permanently.
Order a big scoop and thank yourself later.
The Pie Selection
Pie is serious business at Olde Dutch. Walk up to the dessert section and you will find a full lineup of options that changes regularly.
Chocolate pie, blueberry, apple, and more are typically on display, and dessert is included with the cost of your buffet – no sneaky upcharge waiting for you at the end.
For just $1.99 extra, the staff will top your slice with a scoop of ice cream. That is one of the easiest upgrade decisions you will ever make at a restaurant.
Guests have been raving about the pie selection for years, and it remains one of the most talked-about parts of the entire dining experience at Olde Dutch.
Opinions on individual pies do vary among reviewers, but the chocolate variety earns the most consistent praise. Come with a sweet tooth and plan to linger at the dessert table a little longer than you intended.
The Salad Bar
Before you even get to the hot food, the salad bar at Olde Dutch earns its own round of applause. Guests describe it as fresh, generously stocked, and loaded with enough topping options to build exactly the salad you are craving that day.
Crisp greens, a wide variety of vegetables, and multiple dressing choices make this far more than just a side note to the main buffet. One reviewer specifically praised how fresh and well-organized everything was, noting that the salad bar alone was a highlight of the meal.
For guests who prefer lighter fare or want to balance out a plate of fried chicken and mashed potatoes, the salad bar offers a genuinely satisfying alternative. Olde Dutch also provides hand sanitizer and gloves near the food stations, which shows real thoughtfulness about keeping the dining experience clean and comfortable for everyone.
Soup Options
Picking just one soup at Olde Dutch might be the hardest decision you face all day. The restaurant typically offers several varieties alongside the main buffet, including crowd favorites like potato soup, beef stew, and enchilada soup.
Yes, enchilada soup – because even an Amish-inspired buffet can surprise you.
One enthusiastic reviewer called all three options “decisions” – meaning every single one was good enough to be the obvious choice. That kind of consistency across multiple soup varieties is genuinely impressive, especially in a buffet setting where soups can sometimes sit too long and lose their appeal.
Served warm and packed with flavor, these soups pair beautifully with the fresh dinner rolls that also come with the buffet. On a chilly day after hiking through Hocking Hills, a bowl of hearty beef stew from Olde Dutch hits differently.
Warm, filling, and worth every spoonful.
Fresh-Baked Dinner Rolls
Ask almost any regular at Olde Dutch what they never skip, and the dinner rolls will come up fast. Soft, warm, and baked to a golden finish, these rolls are the kind that disappear from the buffet table quickly – so grab them while you can.
One reviewer called them outright “perfection.” Another specifically mentioned that the rolls were a highlight in an already impressive spread. When a simple bread roll earns that kind of praise at a buffet packed with roasted meats and casseroles, you know the kitchen is doing something right.
They pair well with just about everything on the buffet – use them to scoop up mashed potatoes, soak up gravy, or just enjoy them plain with a little butter. These rolls are a small thing that makes a big impression, and they reflect the care that goes into every item Olde Dutch puts out.
Breakfast Buffet on Weekends
Saturday and Sunday mornings at Olde Dutch open at 8 AM with a breakfast buffet that has been turning heads among Hocking Hills visitors. Guests who have tried it describe the experience as fresh, delicious, and well worth waking up early for before a day of hiking or exploring.
One of the standout features is a staff member cooking pancakes and omelets to order right at the buffet station. That kind of made-to-order touch inside a buffet format feels genuinely special and adds a personal element that most breakfast spots simply do not offer.
One reviewer was so impressed after the breakfast buffet that they came back the very next day for the dinner service. That kind of repeat visit speaks volumes.
If your weekend plans include the Hocking Hills area, building a stop at Olde Dutch breakfast into your itinerary is an easy decision to make.
The Friendly and Attentive Staff
Walk into Olde Dutch on most days and you will be greeted with genuine warmth. The staff here has earned consistent praise across hundreds of reviews, with guests calling servers friendly, kind, attentive, and welcoming in nearly every positive account shared online.
One reviewer gave a heartfelt shoutout to a server named Kayleigh, saying her smile made everyone feel welcome before she even introduced herself. Another praised a buffet attendant who spent the entire evening keeping food fresh and the station spotless without missing a beat.
Good service can make or break a meal out, and at Olde Dutch, the team clearly understands that. Plates get cleared quickly, refills are offered, and the staff carries a genuine cheerfulness that adds to the whole experience.
When the food is already this good, having a warm and attentive team serving it makes every visit feel even more worthwhile.
The Gift Shop and Goat Pen
Olde Dutch is more than just a meal – it is a whole little experience. After finishing up at the buffet, guests can browse a charming gift shop near the checkout area, stocked with knick-knacks, trinkets, and country-style souvenirs that make for fun browsing after a big plate of food.
Step outside and you might find yourself face-to-face with the restaurant’s resident goats in a small pen on the property. Families with kids especially love this unexpected bonus.
One reviewer fondly mentioned always requesting a window seat so they could watch the petting zoo next door while eating.
These little extras give Olde Dutch a personality that goes beyond the typical restaurant visit. It is the kind of place where you come for the food and leave with a smile, a small souvenir, and maybe a new appreciation for goats.
That is a solid afternoon by any standard.
Convenient Location Near Hocking Hills
Location matters, and Olde Dutch absolutely nails it. Sitting right along Route 664 in Logan, Ohio, the restaurant is perfectly positioned for anyone spending time in the Hocking Hills area.
After a full day of hiking gorges and waterfalls, pulling into the Olde Dutch parking lot feels like a well-earned reward.
The parking lot is large enough to handle big crowds without the stress of circling for a spot. Nearby attractions include an antique mall right next door, Weavers Market across the street, and all the natural beauty of Hocking County just minutes away in every direction.
Travelers passing through on road trips often mention Olde Dutch as a convenient and satisfying stop right off the main route. Whether you are coming from Columbus, Athens, or anywhere in between, the restaurant is easy to find and well worth the detour.
Few places combine accessibility and quality this effortlessly.
A True Community Staple
For the people of Logan and the surrounding Hocking Hills community, Olde Dutch is not just a restaurant – it is a tradition. One longtime local reviewer shared that after dozens of visits over many years, the place still feels consistent, orderly, and genuinely welcoming every single time.
That kind of reliability is rare and worth celebrating. Families celebrate birthdays here.
Couples stop in after Sunday church. Hikers refuel before heading home.
Solo diners come for a quiet lunch without feeling out of place. Olde Dutch accommodates everyone with equal warmth and a dining room large enough to seat any size group comfortably.
With over 6,000 reviews and a 4.4-star rating on Google, the numbers back up what regulars already know. Good food, fair prices, kind people, and a cozy atmosphere make this place something the whole community can be proud of.
That is the real Olde Dutch difference.
Enjoyed this story?
Add Fast Food Club as a preferred source to see more of our reporting on Google.