Tucked away on Main Street in Farmingdale, New York, Back In Time Vintage Home Decor is the kind of place that makes you slow down and look twice at everything. With a 4.8-star rating and a loyal community of shoppers, this antique store has earned its reputation as a true hidden gem on Long Island.
What makes it extra special is that you can grab a fresh cup of coffee and a pastry while browsing through rooms filled with beautiful, one-of-a-kind finds. Whether you are a seasoned antique hunter or just curious, this store offers an experience that goes way beyond ordinary shopping.
A Coffee Shop Inside an Antique Store
Forget browsing on an empty stomach — Back In Time has its own cafe right inside the store, and customers absolutely love it. You can order a freshly brewed coffee and pick out a delicious pastry before wandering through the shelves of vintage treasures.
It turns a regular shopping trip into something that feels more like a relaxing afternoon adventure.
The cafe adds a warm, welcoming vibe that makes you want to linger longer. Reviewers have called the coffee excellent and the pastries perfect.
One visitor even mentioned sitting outside on the back patio, sipping a drink while soaking in the charming atmosphere.
Having a cafe inside a shop is rare and thoughtful. It shows that the owners, Laura and her team, truly want every visit to feel like an experience, not just a quick errand.
The Back Patio — A Hidden Outdoor Escape
Step past the vintage shelves and through the back of the store, and you will find something unexpected — a charming outdoor patio that feels like a little secret garden. Shoppers have raved about this cozy spot, with one reviewer describing it as simply “charming.” Another mentioned enjoying dessert and coffee outside while taking in the relaxed, pleasant atmosphere.
The patio also features a firepit, making it an especially magical spot during cooler months. Whether you are catching up with a friend or just taking a quiet break from browsing, this outdoor space delivers a sense of calm that is hard to find on a typical shopping trip.
Back In Time clearly put thought into every corner of the property. The patio is proof that this place is more than a store — it is a destination worth spending an entire afternoon at.
Vintage and Antique Treasures Around Every Corner
Walking through Back In Time feels like flipping through the pages of a history book — except you can actually take the items home. The store is packed with vintage and antique pieces that span different eras and styles.
From old furniture to quirky collectibles, there is always something surprising waiting around the next corner.
One reviewer shared that the rooms kept leading to more, both inside and outside, making every visit feel like a new discovery. Another customer found a rare, natural cedar closet that reminded her of her childhood farm days.
The variety here is genuinely impressive.
What sets this store apart is how well the items are preserved and displayed. Everything feels intentional and carefully curated, giving the space a museum-like quality while still feeling warm, lived-in, and completely approachable for shoppers of all ages.
Expertly Curated Home Decor Selection
Not everything at Back In Time is dusty and old in the traditional sense — the home decor collection feels fresh, stylish, and magazine-worthy. Reviewers have used phrases like “expertly curated” and “magazine quality pieces” to describe what they find here.
The owners clearly have a sharp eye for beautiful things that look great in a modern home.
You will find everything from decorative lanterns and repurposed antique furniture to elegant gift items that feel both timeless and current. One shopper even spotted an old ice chest that had been cleverly converted into a bar, which just goes to show how creative the curation really is.
Whether you are redecorating a living room or searching for a unique accent piece, this store delivers options that big-box retailers simply cannot match. Every item tells a story, and that is what makes shopping here so satisfying.
Unique and Thoughtful Gift Options
Stumped on what to buy for the person who seems to have everything? Back In Time is the answer.
Customers have specifically called this store out as the perfect place to shop for hard-to-buy-for people on their gift lists. The selection of one-of-a-kind items means you will never show up to a birthday or holiday with something generic.
Prices are reasonable too, with a fair number of gift items available under twenty dollars. That makes it easy to find something meaningful without breaking the bank.
One reviewer guaranteed that shoppers would walk out with something special — and based on the glowing feedback, that promise seems to hold up.
From holiday ornaments to home accessories and natural soaps, the gift options here cover a wide range of tastes. It is the kind of store where you go in for one person and end up buying something for yourself too.
Spectacular Christmas and Holiday Decor
Come the holiday season, Back In Time transforms into something truly magical. The Christmas decor selection has been singled out by multiple reviewers as a standout feature of the store.
One first-time visitor was so taken with the holiday display that she left with a couple of beautiful ornaments and could not stop talking about the experience.
Another reviewer pointed out that the store even hosts visits with Santa Claus, making it a fun outing for families with young children. The holiday atmosphere here goes beyond just putting up some tinsel — every corner is thoughtfully decorated to spark that warm, nostalgic feeling.
Whether you are looking for a special ornament, a wreath, or a statement piece for your mantle, the holiday inventory at Back In Time is worth the trip alone. Check the website for seasonal events and special holiday market dates before you visit.
Special Events Like Sip and Shop Nights
Back In Time is not just a store — it is a venue for memorable evenings. The popular Sip and Shop events bring together wine, appetizers, friends, and fabulous vintage finds in one festive package.
One reviewer described a Thursday evening event as simply wonderful, complete with great weather, beautiful decor pieces, and the company of good friends.
Another shopper recalled a holiday cocktail hour where there was a fire burning outside, cheese and crackers being passed around, and wine flowing freely. The line to check out was long, but she was thrilled to see a small family business doing so well.
These events turn a regular shopping trip into a social occasion worth planning around. Keep an eye on the Back In Time website at backintimedecor.com for upcoming event dates so you do not miss out on the next one.
Classes in Furniture Painting and Floral Arrangements
Here is something you probably did not expect from an antique store — hands-on creative workshops. Back In Time offers classes that range from furniture painting to floral arrangement, giving visitors a chance to learn new skills while surrounded by beautiful vintage inspiration.
It is the kind of activity that makes a great date idea or a fun afternoon with friends.
One reviewer highlighted these classes as a major reason why the store stands out as a truly exceptional destination. Learning how to refinish a piece of furniture or build a stunning floral display in such a creative environment makes the experience feel genuinely special.
Classes like these also connect shoppers to the deeper story behind vintage and antique items — understanding how things are made and restored gives you a whole new appreciation for the treasures lining the shelves. Check the website for current class schedules and registration details.
Friendly and Knowledgeable Staff
A great store experience almost always comes down to the people behind the counter, and Back In Time consistently earns praise for its warm, helpful team. Staff member Gia was specifically called out by one reviewer as an absolute gem who took the time to share information about the store and its events.
That personal touch makes a real difference.
Owner Laura clearly sets the tone for the whole operation. Her responses to customer reviews are filled with genuine warmth and gratitude, and she has built a team that reflects those same values.
Multiple reviewers have used words like personable, welcoming, and friendly to describe every interaction.
For shoppers who sometimes feel ignored or rushed in retail settings, Back In Time offers a refreshing change. The staff here actually seem happy to be there, and that energy is contagious from the moment you walk through the door.
Repurposed and Upcycled Furniture Finds
One of the most exciting things about shopping at Back In Time is stumbling across furniture that has been given a brand-new purpose. The store features cleverly upcycled pieces that blend history with modern functionality.
That old ice chest converted into a bar? Genius — and exactly the kind of thing you will not find at any ordinary furniture store.
Reviewers have praised the creativity behind these reimagined pieces, noting that they bring serious character to a home without requiring a huge budget. The owners have a genuine talent for seeing potential in old items and transforming them into something fresh and functional.
If you are someone who loves interior design with a story behind it, these upcycled finds are made for you. Each piece carries the charm of the past while fitting perfectly into a contemporary living space, making them conversation starters the moment guests walk in.
A Mix of New and Vintage Items
Back In Time walks a clever line between old and new. While vintage and antique pieces form the heart of the collection, the store also stocks new decorative items that complement the older finds beautifully.
This blend gives shoppers the best of both worlds — the charm of history with the freshness of something just made.
One reviewer described it as a “nice mix of new and vintage” that keeps the store feeling current and exciting no matter how often you visit. Another shopper found holiday-themed items for Valentine’s Day tucked among the vintage collectibles, proving that the inventory spans seasons and styles.
This thoughtful combination also makes the store more accessible to shoppers who might not be strictly antique enthusiasts. Whether your taste leans classic or contemporary, there is something at Back In Time that will catch your eye and earn a spot in your home.
Holiday Markets and Seasonal Pop-Up Events
Beyond the regular store hours, Back In Time comes alive with seasonal markets and pop-up events that draw crowds from across Long Island. One couple visited during a holiday market weekend and called it a lovely, memorable experience.
These events turn the already charming space into a full-on festive destination.
Past events have included outdoor gatherings with firepits, passed appetizers, live entertainment, and even wine and beer service. The energy at these markets is described as buzzing and joyful, with long checkout lines that the owner herself took as a sign of success for her small family business.
Planning a visit around one of these events is highly recommended. The combination of seasonal shopping, good food, great drinks, and a beautiful setting makes for an outing that feels more like a celebration than a shopping trip.
Visit backintimedecor.com to check upcoming event dates.
A True Community Gem in Farmingdale Village
Some stores just feel like they belong exactly where they are, and Back In Time is one of them. Located at 441 Main Street in Farmingdale Village, this shop has become a beloved part of the local community over its more than six years in business.
Residents have called it a store that Farmingdale is lucky to have.
With a 4.8-star rating across dozens of reviews, the feedback speaks for itself. Shoppers return again and again not just for the merchandise, but for the feeling the store gives them.
One reviewer put it simply: walking through the store just makes you feel terrific.
Open Tuesday through Saturday from 10 AM to 5 PM and Sunday from 10 AM to 4 PM, Back In Time is easy to fit into a weekend plan. Call ahead at 516-586-8443 or browse the website at backintimedecor.com before your visit.