Tucked away on West Charleston Boulevard in Las Vegas, Brooklyn’s Best Pizza & Pasta is the kind of spot that feels like a well-kept secret — until you taste the food. With a 4.6-star rating from nearly 1,500 reviews, this cozy neighborhood pizzeria has quietly built one of the most loyal fan bases in all of Nevada.
From their legendary garlic knots to their award-winning Grandma’s Pie, every dish tells the story of a place that genuinely cares about quality. If you haven’t made the trip yet, here are 13 reasons why Brooklyn’s Best deserves a spot at the top of your must-visit list.
The Garlic Knots That Started It All
Ask almost anyone who has visited Brooklyn’s Best Pizza & Pasta what they ordered first, and the answer is almost always the garlic knots. Soft on the inside, golden on the outside, and loaded with buttery garlic flavor, these little twists of dough have become the restaurant’s most talked-about item.
Reviewers rave about them constantly, with one customer calling them a “must try” alongside the wings. The knots are available plain or with cheese on top, giving you a little extra indulgence if you’re feeling it.
Word spread fast across Las Vegas, and now people drive from all over Nevada just to grab an order. Fair warning: one basket probably won’t be enough.
Brooklyn’s Best garlic knots are the kind of snack that turns first-time visitors into regulars before the pizza even hits the table.
Grandma’s Pie — A Slice of Pure Heaven
If Brooklyn’s Best has a signature dish that makes people stop mid-bite and look up in amazement, it’s the Grandma’s Pie. Multiple reviewers describe it as “the best pizza we’ve ever had,” and that’s saying a lot in a city full of great food options.
The Grandma’s style Sicilian is thick, chewy, and perfectly balanced between sweet tomato sauce and savory, melted cheese. One customer wrote that the flavors hit “the sweet and the savory” in a way that felt like “the perfect slice of heaven.”
Another loyal fan listed Grandma’s Pie as their all-time favorite, calling it absolutely incredible after trying it for the first time. It’s the kind of pizza that makes you understand why people from New York get so passionate about their pies.
One bite and you’ll completely get it.
A Brooklyn Vibe Right in the Heart of Las Vegas
Walking into Brooklyn’s Best Pizza & Pasta feels like stepping onto a street in New York City without buying a plane ticket. The dining room is decked out with Brooklyn-themed decor that gives the whole place an authentic neighborhood feel.
One reviewer who actually grew up in Brooklyn said the experience brought them right back to eating pizza on Flatbush Avenue. Another customer from New York mentioned that the vibe, the food, and the energy all matched what they missed most about home.
The music adds to the atmosphere, keeping things lively without being overwhelming. It’s the kind of place where you settle in, look around, and feel like you belong.
For Las Vegas locals craving something real and unpretentious, this Brooklyn-inspired corner of West Charleston is a genuine escape from the glitter of the Strip.
Penne alla Vodka That Hits Every Note
Some pasta dishes play it safe. Brooklyn’s Best penne alla vodka is not one of them.
Reviewers consistently describe the pasta here as packed with flavor, and the penne alla vodka stands out as one of the most memorable items on the entire menu.
One family who visited for dinner ordered it alongside the Grandma’s Pie and fried zucchini, and they said each dish had its own unique personality that made it hard to pick a favorite. That’s the kind of cooking that keeps people coming back week after week.
The homemade pasta sauce at Brooklyn’s Best is something reviewers specifically mention, with one person noting it “tastes like it came straight from an Italian kitchen.” Rich, creamy, and deeply satisfying, the penne alla vodka is the kind of comfort food that makes a regular Tuesday night feel like a real occasion.
Wings Worth Raving About
Pizza gets most of the spotlight at Brooklyn’s Best, but the wings are quietly stealing hearts one order at a time. Customers describe them as “amazing” and have been mixing flavors in creative ways — one popular combo is butter garlic and hot honey together, which several reviewers say is “to die for.”
Another guest had their server Daisy recommend garlic and hot sauce mixed, and called the result “fire.” The blue cheese dipping sauce also gets its own shout-outs, with one reviewer saying it was so good alongside the wings that it deserved special recognition.
Brooklyn’s Best won Best of Las Vegas for 2025 in the pizza category, but honestly, the wings could compete for their own award. Whether you go mild, hot, or somewhere in between, the wings here are worth ordering every single visit.
Don’t sleep on them.
Butter Cake That Will Make You Forget Your Diet
You made it through the garlic knots, the pizza, and the pasta — now comes the part where dessert completely steals the show. Brooklyn’s Best butter cake is the kind of ending to a meal that people talk about on the drive home.
One longtime customer called it “hands down the best” and used all caps to describe it as AMAZING. Another reviewer admitted that the butter cake with ice cream was so good that the “10 pounds I gained was worth it.” That’s the highest compliment a dessert can possibly receive.
Warm, buttery, and slightly crisp on the outside with a soft center, this dessert pairs perfectly with a scoop of ice cream melting right over the top. If you somehow have room after everything else on the menu, ordering the butter cake is absolutely the right call.
You won’t regret it.
Tiramisu and Cannoli That Are the Real Deal
Not every Italian restaurant in Las Vegas can pull off a proper tiramisu or a cannoli that tastes authentic. Brooklyn’s Best does both, and customers are quick to point that out.
One reviewer described the tiramisu and cannoli as “the real deal” and gave the whole experience a glowing five-star rating.
There’s something special about finishing a meal with desserts that actually taste like they came from a family recipe rather than a commercial kitchen. Brooklyn’s Best clearly puts care into every course, not just the main dishes.
For anyone who grew up eating Italian food or who has traveled to New York City for a proper cannoli, these desserts will feel familiar in the best possible way. Order one, share it with someone at the table, and then probably order another one for yourself.
No judgment here — these are worth every bite.
Portions So Big You’ll Need a To-Go Box
One of the most consistent themes across Brooklyn’s Best reviews is portion size — and the message is clear: come hungry. One customer who ordered the lasagna said he could only eat half of it, and his wife had the same experience with her dish.
Both left with packed to-go boxes and huge smiles.
The specialty pizzas are also known for being generously sized, and the pasta portions are the kind that make you feel genuinely taken care of. In a city where some restaurants charge a lot for very little, Brooklyn’s Best feels refreshingly honest about giving customers real value.
A word of friendly warning from multiple reviewers: don’t make plans immediately after eating here. You’re going to want time to sit back, loosen your belt, and appreciate what just happened.
Leftovers the next day are practically guaranteed, and honestly, that’s a bonus worth celebrating.
Server Stars: Tyler, Daniella, Megan, and More
Great food only goes so far when the service doesn’t match. At Brooklyn’s Best, the staff is just as much a reason to visit as the menu itself.
Reviewers regularly name their servers by name, which says everything about the kind of personal connection this team builds with guests.
Tyler gets mentioned repeatedly for being knowledgeable, friendly, and attentive. Daniella earned a “6/5 stars” rating from one thrilled customer who called her funny and on-point.
Megan impressed a newly relocated couple enough that they came back specifically hoping to be seated in her section again.
Other staff members like Jason, Allison, Daisy, and Theresa have all received their own glowing mentions in reviews. One customer summed it up perfectly: if they owned a restaurant, they’d want this entire team working for them.
That kind of loyalty to the staff says everything about the culture Brooklyn’s Best has built.
Off the Strip and Proud of It
Brooklyn’s Best sits at 241 W Charleston Blvd, Suite 101 — which means it’s refreshingly removed from the chaos of the Las Vegas Strip. For locals and visitors alike, that’s actually a major selling point.
One reviewer specifically praised the location, calling it “very relaxing” compared to the nonstop energy of tourist-heavy areas.
The restaurant isn’t the easiest to spot on your first drive-by, which is partly why it feels like such a discovery. One couple even stumbled upon it by accident after getting directions mixed up, and they ended up calling it one of the best meals they’d had in Vegas.
Hidden gems have a way of earning deeper loyalty than flashier spots, and Brooklyn’s Best is proof of that. The neighborhood feel, the approachable vibe, and the absence of tourist-trap pricing all make this off-Strip location feel like a genuine find worth sharing with everyone you know.
Homemade Pasta Sauce That Tastes Like Family
There’s a moment in certain Italian restaurants when you take a bite of the sauce and immediately think, “someone’s grandmother made this.” That’s exactly the reaction Brooklyn’s Best pasta sauce gets from its customers. One reviewer described it as tasting like it “came straight from an Italian kitchen,” which is the gold standard for any red sauce.
The sauce shows up across multiple dishes — on the pizza, in the pasta, and layered into the lasagna — and it maintains that same rich, slow-cooked depth each time. Consistency like that doesn’t happen by accident; it comes from using quality ingredients and actually caring about the result.
For people who grew up eating Sunday gravy or who know what a proper marinara is supposed to taste like, the sauce at Brooklyn’s Best will feel like a genuine homecoming. It’s one of those quiet details that elevates the entire experience.
Best of Las Vegas 2025 — Pizza Category Winner
Winning an award in Las Vegas — a city absolutely packed with world-class restaurants — is no small thing. Brooklyn’s Best Pizza & Pasta took home the Best of Las Vegas 2025 honor in the pizza category, and based on the reviews, it’s hard to argue with that decision.
The restaurant has maintained a 4.6-star rating across nearly 1,500 reviews, which reflects years of consistent quality rather than a lucky streak. Awards like this tend to confirm what regulars already knew long before any official recognition came along.
For first-time visitors who might be on the fence, that award is a solid reason to make the trip. Brooklyn’s Best didn’t win by accident — they won because they put out great food, built a welcoming atmosphere, and treated their customers like neighbors.
In a competitive city, that kind of reputation is earned one pizza at a time.
A Spot That Feels Like Home for New Yorkers
Moving away from New York City means leaving behind a food culture that’s nearly impossible to replicate anywhere else. Brooklyn’s Best Pizza & Pasta comes closer than almost anywhere in Nevada, and former New Yorkers are vocal about it.
One transplant from Brooklyn wrote that eating here felt like being back on Flatbush Avenue — high praise that no marketing campaign could buy.
Another reviewer who moved from New York to Las Vegas said finding Brooklyn’s Best made missing home “a little better.” They even signed off their review with a New York City subway announcement, which perfectly captures how deeply this place resonates.
Even a self-described picky eater who grew up in New York called the pizza “absolutely delicious” and said the place “definitely delivers.” For anyone homesick for real New York-style food, Brooklyn’s Best isn’t just a restaurant — it’s a little piece of home hiding in plain sight on West Charleston.
Enjoyed this story?
Add Fast Food Club as a preferred source to see more of our reporting on Google.