Tucked away at 3800 Rhodes Ave in New Boston, Ohio, Hickies Hamburger Inn has been serving up old-school comfort food since 1975. With a 4.7-star rating from over a thousand happy customers, this little diner has earned a serious reputation across the region.
People drive from Columbus and beyond just to get a taste of those legendary slider-style burgers and gravy-drenched fries. Once you stop in, you will completely understand why locals keep coming back year after year.
The Slider-Style Burgers That Started It All
Some burgers are just food. The ones at Hickies Hamburger Inn are an experience you carry home with you.
These slider-style cheeseburgers come loaded with mustard, onions, cheese, and pickles, and they are cooked to a tender, juicy perfection that keeps people talking for days.
First-timers often describe that initial bite as a genuine surprise. The flavors are simple but balanced in a way that feels almost old-fashioned in the best possible sense.
Nothing is overdone or overly fancy.
One loyal customer even mentioned ordering four double cheeseburgers and asking the staff to “dip the buns,” a technique where the center of the bun lightly touches the grill to soak up extra flavor. Little tricks like that show just how much care goes into every single order at this beloved Ohio diner.
Fries and Gravy: A Regional Treasure Worth Knowing About
Not every diner does fries and gravy, but Hickies Hamburger Inn does it better than almost anyone else in Ohio. Regulars describe these fries as something you simply cannot replicate on the other side of the state.
The brown gravy is rich, warm, and poured generously over perfectly cooked fries.
One longtime customer recalled their very first taste of this combination during their freshman year of college, and returned 20 years later just to experience it again. That kind of loyalty speaks volumes about how good this side dish really is.
Visitors often call it a Cincinnati-style poutine alternative, though fans of Hickies would argue their version stands completely on its own. If you have never tried fries with brown gravy at a diner setting, this is absolutely the place to start your journey.
Bean Soup That People Genuinely Rave About
Bean soup does not usually steal the spotlight, but at Hickies Hamburger Inn, it has its own fan club. Customers describe it as the best bean soup on the planet, and that is not an exaggeration they throw around lightly.
Homemade and hearty, this soup has a depth of flavor that reminds people of their grandmother’s kitchen.
Multiple reviews specifically single out the bean soup as a must-order item, which is saying something at a place famous for its burgers. The recipe has remained consistent over the decades, giving long-time visitors the comfort of knowing exactly what to expect.
Soup beans are a regional staple in southern Ohio, and Hickies honors that tradition with quiet confidence. Whether you pair it with a burger or enjoy it on its own, a bowl of this soup is one of the most satisfying things on the entire menu.
Hot Dogs and Foot-Longs Done the Local Way
Hot dogs might seem simple, but Hickies Hamburger Inn brings a local twist that makes them unforgettable. The foot-long chili dog is a crowd favorite, and customers get to choose between traditional chili with beans or the local specialty known as hot dog sauce, which is a refined chili without beans.
Staff and regulars strongly recommend trying the sauce version if it is your first time. It is a regional flavor that you just do not find everywhere, and it pairs perfectly with mustard and onions on a warm, soft bun.
One reviewer who has been visiting since the diner opened in 1975 described the footers with sauce as excellent, placing them right alongside the famous double cheeseburgers. When a dish earns that kind of praise from a decades-long regular, you know it has truly earned its place on the menu.
A History That Goes Back to 1975
Hickies Hamburger Inn opened its doors in 1975, and the building itself carries a history even older than that. Before the Hickman family took it over, the space served as an old gas station and ice cream joint.
That layered past gives the place a character that modern restaurants simply cannot manufacture.
Walking in feels like stepping into a living time capsule. The walls are covered with local high school memorabilia, Glenwood High School sports decorations, and photos of city council members and basketball teams from decades past.
It is a place where community history is literally on display.
For many visitors, stopping at Hickies is about more than food. It is about reconnecting with a version of small-town Ohio that still exists, still smells like burgers on a grill, and still greets you like you belong there.
Nearly 50 years of history will do that to a place.
Prices So Low They Make You Do a Double Take
Spending less than $20 on a full meal including burgers, fries, and a drink sounds like something from a different era, but at Hickies Hamburger Inn, it is just a regular Tuesday. Multiple reviewers have pointed out how shocking the value is, with one person noting they ate more than they should have and still paid well under $20 even after tipping.
Another visitor grabbed three cheeseburgers, fries, and drinks for their group and walked out with change from a $20 bill. In a time when fast food alone can cost that much, Hickies feels like a genuine gift to anyone watching their budget.
The low prices are not a reflection of low quality. Every item is made with care and served fresh.
It is simply the Hickies way of keeping good food accessible to the community that has supported them for nearly five decades.
The Counter Seating Experience That Feels Genuinely Nostalgic
Sitting at the counter at Hickies Hamburger Inn is one of those simple pleasures that feels rare in today’s world. You watch the crew work together in a tight space, passing plates and refilling drinks like a well-rehearsed team.
The energy is lively, warm, and completely unpretentious.
Seating is a mix of counter spots and small tables, and neither option is particularly fancy. But that is exactly the point.
The focus here is on the food and the people, not the furniture. Menu boards hang on the walls, and the decor tells the story of the community around it.
One reviewer described the atmosphere as a place that was “hopping,” packed to the gills with loyal regulars and curious first-timers. That kind of buzzing, communal energy is something you just cannot find at a chain restaurant, no matter how hard they try to recreate it.
A Staff That Works Together Like a Well-Oiled Machine
Running a busy diner in a small space with a big crowd is no easy task, but the team at Hickies Hamburger Inn makes it look effortless. Reviewers consistently praise the staff for their teamwork, noting how multiple servers pitch in to refill drinks, deliver food, and offer smiles without anyone being asked.
One customer who returned after a 20-year absence was genuinely impressed by how smoothly the crew operated during a packed lunch rush. Despite the chaos of a busy service, every table was looked after and every customer felt welcomed.
That kind of collaborative spirit is rare and worth celebrating. It is not just about getting orders right.
It is about creating an environment where people feel taken care of. At Hickies, the staff clearly takes pride in their work, and that attitude shows up in every interaction from the moment you walk through the door.
Veggie Soup and Coleslaw for the Non-Burger Crowd
Hickies Hamburger Inn is famous for its burgers, but the menu has more to offer than most people expect. The veggie soup earns high marks from customers who were not even planning to order it, and the coleslaw is described as a genuinely good side that complements the heavier items beautifully.
One reviewer ordered the veggie soup, fries with gravy, and a cheeseburger, and reported eating every single bite. That kind of clean-plate satisfaction says a lot about the quality and flavor of even the supporting menu items.
For anyone dining with someone who prefers lighter fare, Hickies is more accommodating than its burger-centric reputation might suggest. The soups and sides are made with the same care as everything else on the menu.
You do not have to love burgers to love this place, though it certainly helps to at least appreciate them.
Generations of Families Keep Coming Back Together
Few restaurants can honestly say they have served multiple generations of the same family, but Hickies Hamburger Inn is one of them. Parents who grew up eating sliders at the counter now bring their own kids in for the same experience, and that generational thread is something the community deeply values.
One reviewer put it beautifully, saying they love that their children are getting the same experience they had at that age. There are not many places left where a parent can honestly say that, and it makes Hickies feel like something worth protecting.
Another customer mentioned visiting since the diner first opened in 1975, returning every single time they come home to see family. That kind of loyalty is not built on gimmicks or viral moments.
It is built on consistent food, warm service, and a genuine sense of belonging that keeps people coming home.
People Drive Hours Just to Eat Here
When someone drives from Columbus to New Boston just for a burger, you know the food must be extraordinary. Hickies Hamburger Inn has that kind of pull.
Customers from across Ohio make the trip regularly, and some even do it monthly, packing up their families for what has become a beloved road trip tradition.
One reviewer casually mentioned making the Columbus drive once a month with their kids, treating it like a routine outing rather than a special occasion. That says everything about how deeply this place has worked its way into people’s lives.
For 50 years, people have been traveling from all over to sit at that counter and enjoy a simple, satisfying meal. There is no flashy marketing behind it, no celebrity endorsement.
Just incredibly consistent food and an atmosphere that reminds you why small, locally owned restaurants matter so much to the fabric of American culture.
The Big Yogi and Other Menu Surprises Worth Exploring
Beyond the sliders and foot-longs, Hickies Hamburger Inn has a few menu surprises that reward adventurous eaters. The Big Yogi is one of them, mentioned by a long-time regular as an absolute must-try for anyone with extra time to explore the full menu.
Details are sparse, which only makes it more intriguing.
Part of the fun of visiting a place like Hickies is discovering items you did not know existed. The menu board on the wall does not give you a novel to read through.
It keeps things simple and lets the food speak for itself.
Regulars tend to have their personal favorites locked in, but they also love steering newcomers toward hidden gems. Ask your server what they recommend beyond the basics, and you might walk away with a new favorite that you will be thinking about on the drive home and every visit after.
A Landmark That Proves Small Towns Still Have Big Flavor
New Boston, Ohio is a small community, but Hickies Hamburger Inn gives it a culinary identity that extends far beyond its borders. Since 1975, this diner has been a gathering point, a comfort zone, and a source of genuine local pride for everyone who has ever walked through its door.
The building is modest. The parking is tight.
The seating is simple. And none of that matters even a little once you take your first bite.
What Hickies offers is proof that great food does not require a big budget, a trendy concept, or a prime location in a major city.
With a 4.7-star rating from over a thousand reviews, the numbers back up what locals have always known. This is the kind of place that defines a community and reminds visitors that the best food stops are often the ones you almost drove right past without stopping.
Enjoyed this story?
Add Fast Food Club as a preferred source to see more of our reporting on Google.