Tucked away at 2109 New Garden Road in Greensboro, North Carolina, Giacomo’s Italian Market is a small but mighty gem that has been winning hearts for over two decades. With a near-perfect 4.8-star rating from more than a thousand loyal customers, this cozy shop brings the authentic flavors of Italy straight to the Piedmont Triad.
From house-made subs and fresh mozzarella to imported pastas and homemade sauces, there is something here for every Italian food lover. Whether you are a longtime local or just passing through on a road trip, Giacomo’s is the kind of place that keeps people coming back again and again.
A Market That Feels Like a Trip to Italy
Walking through the door at Giacomo’s Italian Market is like stepping onto a cobblestone street in a small Italian village. The aromas hit you first — cured meats, fresh bread, and rich sauces all mingling together in the most welcoming way possible.
Customers consistently say the place does not feel like North Carolina at all. One reviewer put it simply: it felt more like Italy.
That kind of atmosphere is hard to manufacture, and at Giacomo’s, it is completely genuine.
The shop is small, which only adds to its charm. Every corner is packed with something delicious to discover, from imported pantry staples to freshly prepared foods made right in-house.
It is the kind of market that reminds you food is more than fuel — it is culture, memory, and community all rolled into one unforgettable experience.
More Than Two Decades of Authentic Flavor
Twenty-plus years in the restaurant and market business is no small achievement, especially when you are committed to keeping things genuinely authentic. Giacomo’s Italian Market has earned its longevity the old-fashioned way — by never cutting corners on quality.
One reviewer from Raleigh mentioned making the 90-minute round trip close to 30 or 40 times over a decade, which says everything about the consistency of this place. When food is this good, distance stops being a reason to stay away.
Staying true to traditional Italian recipes while also building a loyal local following is a balancing act that Giacomo’s has clearly mastered. The market has grown its reputation one satisfied customer at a time, proving that great food really does speak for itself.
Two decades in, the passion behind every product here is just as strong as ever.
Signature Subs That Rival New York Delis
Ask any regular at Giacomo’s what to order first and the answer will almost always involve a sub. The sandwich menu here is legendary, loaded with options like the Italian Stallion, the Meatball, the Dino, the Phillipo, the Frankie, and the Giuseppe — each one packed with premium ingredients.
One customer who grew up in Connecticut said the subs took them straight back to their favorite New York deli. That kind of compliment carries real weight, especially in a state not exactly known for Italian delis.
The bread deserves its own shoutout — crispy on the outside, perfectly soft inside, and sturdy enough to hold all those glorious fillings together. House oil and vinegar finish everything off beautifully.
Whether you go hot or cold, spicy or mild, these sandwiches are built to impress from the very first bite to the very last crumb.
House-Made Deli Meats Worth the Drive
Not many markets can say they make their own deli meats in-house, but Giacomo’s is proud to be one of them. Hot sopressata, hot capicola, and other house-crafted cuts line the deli counter, each one sliced fresh and bursting with old-world flavor.
One first-time visitor described how a staff member prepared a sampling tray of in-house meats, explaining each one with genuine enthusiasm. That kind of personal touch transforms a simple shopping trip into a real culinary education.
The quality of these meats is something customers rave about consistently across hundreds of reviews. They are not just toppings for sandwiches — they are the main event.
Buying a few slices to take home means you can recreate that Giacomo’s magic in your own kitchen. For anyone serious about charcuterie or Italian cooking, this deli counter alone makes the trip completely worthwhile.
Fresh Mozzarella Made Daily
Fresh mozzarella at Giacomo’s is not the rubbery, plastic-wrapped kind you find at a chain grocery store. Made daily, it is soft, milky, and rich in a way that reminds you what this cheese is actually supposed to taste like.
Multiple reviewers have called it out specifically, with one customer raving about the fresh tomato and mozzarella pairing alongside homemade bread. Another drove all the way from Pittsburgh just to grab some, and the staff had it ready and waiting when he arrived.
Paired with a drizzle of good olive oil and a sprinkle of sea salt, Giacomo’s fresh mozzarella is a simple pleasure that hits on every level. It is one of those products that makes you wonder how you ever settled for less.
Once you try it fresh, going back to the store-bought version simply is not an option anymore.
Homemade Sauces That Taste Like Nonna Made Them
Some sauces come from a factory. Giacomo’s sauces come from the heart.
The homemade vodka sauce, spaghetti sauce, and other prepared options here are the kind of recipes that take time, care, and a deep respect for Italian culinary tradition.
One reviewer picked up frozen homemade spaghetti sauce and described it as wonderful, saying it completely changed the feeling of being in North Carolina. Another customer bought sauce and sausage to cook for the whole family at home — a smart move by anyone’s standards.
Having access to a truly homemade sauce is a game-changer for home cooks who want authentic flavor without spending hours at the stove. Giacomo’s makes it easy to bring restaurant-quality Italian cooking into your own kitchen any night of the week.
Stock up when you visit, because these jars disappear fast from kitchen shelves.
Cannoli and Sweets That End Every Meal Right
Every great Italian meal deserves a great Italian ending, and Giacomo’s delivers on that front with cannoli and other traditional sweets that are hard to find anywhere else in the Greensboro area. One reviewer described the cannoli as the perfect ending to lunch — and honestly, that is hard to argue with.
The fried, seasoned, and breaded ricotta balls are another crowd favorite that have earned their own fan club among regular visitors. One customer said they were blown away by the sample they received during their very first visit.
Giacomo’s also carries authentic Italian cakes and imported treats that round out the dessert selection beautifully. For anyone with a sweet tooth and an appreciation for the real thing, skipping the dessert section here would be a serious mistake.
Treat yourself — you absolutely earned it after navigating that incredible deli counter.
Imported Goods You Cannot Find Anywhere Else Nearby
Part of what makes Giacomo’s such a special destination is its curated selection of imported Italian products that simply cannot be found at your average supermarket. From specialty pastas and olive oils to hard-to-source pantry staples, the shelves here read like a love letter to Italy.
One reviewer specifically noted the “plethora of hard to find imported items you cannot get anywhere else nearby” after browsing the market for the first time. That sense of discovery is part of what keeps people coming back.
For home cooks who take their Italian recipes seriously, having access to authentic imported ingredients makes all the difference in the final dish. Giacomo’s essentially removes the need to track down specialty online retailers or drive to a major city.
Everything you need to cook a genuinely Italian meal from scratch is right here on those shelves, waiting for you.
Frozen Take-Home Dinners for Busy Nights
Life gets busy, but that is no reason to give up on a delicious homemade-style Italian dinner. Giacomo’s offers a selection of frozen take-home meals that make weeknight cooking feel effortless and exciting at the same time.
One reviewer watched the customer in front of them pick up a frozen dinner and rave about how incredible it was. That kind of spontaneous endorsement from a stranger in line is about as honest a review as you can get.
From pasta dishes to meatballs and beyond, these frozen options are made with the same quality ingredients and care that go into everything else at the market. They heat up beautifully and taste far better than anything you would pull from a supermarket freezer aisle.
Stocking your freezer with a few Giacomo’s meals means you are never more than 20 minutes away from an amazing Italian dinner.
Staff That Treats You Like Family
Nick and the team at Giacomo’s have built something rare in today’s food service world — a place where staff actually remembers your name. Multiple reviewers mentioned being greeted warmly, treated with genuine hospitality, and feeling like regulars even on their very first visit.
One customer described how a staff member, upon learning they were first-timers, immediately prepared a sampling tray of house-made deli meats and walked them through each one with enthusiasm and personal recommendations. That is the kind of service most restaurants only dream about offering.
The warm, neighborhood feeling at Giacomo’s is not accidental — it is clearly a core part of the experience the team works to create every single day. When people feel welcomed and appreciated, they come back.
And at Giacomo’s, they do come back, often driving from cities as far away as Raleigh and Pittsburgh just to feel that warmth again.
A Cheese Counter Worth Every Calorie
Cheese lovers, consider this your official heads-up. The cheese selection at Giacomo’s is the kind of spread that makes you want to clear your afternoon schedule and spend some quality time making decisions.
Provolone, fresh mozzarella, and a rotating cast of imported Italian varieties are all available here.
Reviewers have praised the cheeses repeatedly, often mentioning how well they pair with the house-made meats and fresh bread available at the same counter. Putting together a proper Italian antipasto spread from this one market is genuinely easy and extremely rewarding.
Whether you are building a charcuterie board for a dinner party or simply treating yourself to a quality snack, the cheese counter at Giacomo’s has you covered. The freshness and authenticity of what is on offer here sets it apart from anything you would find at a big-box grocery store.
Bring a cooler — you will want to take extras home.
A Neighborhood Gem With a 4.8-Star Reputation
Earning a 4.8-star rating from over a thousand reviewers is not luck — it is the result of years of consistent quality, genuine hospitality, and an unwavering commitment to authentic Italian food. Giacomo’s has achieved exactly that, standing as one of the highest-rated specialty markets in the entire Greensboro area.
Customers from Virginia, Pittsburgh, Raleigh, and beyond have made special detours just to visit, and nearly all of them leave glowing five-star feedback. That kind of word-of-mouth reputation is more powerful than any advertisement money could buy.
For locals who have not yet stopped in, the numbers alone should be enough to convince you. Over a thousand people took the time to write a review, and the overwhelming majority called it outstanding.
That is not a coincidence — that is a market doing everything right, day after day, year after year, for more than two decades running.
Hours, Location, and Everything You Need to Plan Your Visit
Planning a trip to Giacomo’s is easy once you know the schedule. The market is open Wednesday through Friday from 11 AM to 7 PM, Saturday from 10 AM to 6 PM, and Sunday from noon to 5 PM.
It is closed on Mondays and Tuesdays, so plan accordingly.
The address is 2109 New Garden Road, Greensboro, NC 27410, and free parking is available on-site. You can also reach the team by phone at 336-282-2855 — and yes, they actually answer.
One reviewer called ahead from Pittsburgh and had his order ready by the time he arrived in town.
For the freshest experience, grab your sandwich and enjoy it nearby right after it is made. A small outdoor table is available when weather allows.
Check the website at giacomositalianmarket.godaddysites.com for any updates before heading out. This little market is absolutely worth building your day around.
Enjoyed this story?
Add Fast Food Club as a preferred source to see more of our reporting on Google.