Fast Food Club Fast Food Club

Wisconsin Locals Still Swear By These 6 Pizza Joints With Tavern-Cut Thin Crust

Ethan Mueller 5 min read
featured image ad04dc022073 2fccc1f03575
Wisconsin Locals Still Swear By These 6 Pizza Joints With Tavern-Cut Thin Crust

In Wisconsin, a pizza cut into little squares is not a mistake, it is a tradition. Tavern-cut thin crust is crisp, cracker-thin, and made for grabbing one more piece while the conversation keeps going.

Some of the best versions come from family parlors that have been at it since the 1920s and 1950s, long before chain pizza took over. Here are six places across the state where the square-cut slice is still treated with real respect.

1. Wells Brothers Italian Restaurant, Mt Pleasant, WI

Wells Brothers Italian Restaurant, Mt Pleasant, WI
© Wells Brothers Italian Restaurant, Mt Pleasant, WI

Back in 1921, Wells Brothers started serving pizza in the Racine area, and the place still carries that history proudly. The menu itself includes the story of the restaurant and the family behind it, so you can read up while you wait.

The crust here is the main event. It is cracker thin and crisp, cut into squares, and it has been a take-home treat for Racine families for generations.

Round out the table with an Italian or Caesar salad, a homemade soup, garlic bread with cheese, or cheese curds. Tiramisu closes things out nicely if you saved room.

The dining room is cozy and historic, with a bar on site and a kids’ menu for younger diners. Dinner reservations are recommended, especially on Friday and Saturday evenings.

Plan around the schedule, since it is closed Sunday and Monday. Hours run 11 AM to 8 PM Tuesday through Thursday and until 9 PM on Friday and Saturday, with a free lot at 2148 Mead St.

2. Zaffiro’s Pizza The Original, Milwaukee, WI

Zaffiro's Pizza The Original, Milwaukee, WI
© Zaffiro’s Pizza The Original, Milwaukee, WI

Toppings run all the way to the edge at Zaffiro’s, which means there is no naked crust left behind. That detail has kept Milwaukee’s East Side coming back since 1954.

This family-owned spot on Farwell Avenue serves a cracker-thin crust cut into tavern squares. Sausage and pepperoni is the classic order, and the Pepperoni Special is right there on the menu for anyone who wants to keep it simple.

Inside, there is a separate dining room and a bar, with an old-school Italian look and a lively crowd that mixes college students and longtime regulars. Pasta and other Italian dishes fill out the menu, and you can even buy a bottle of the house Italian dressing.

Hours are generous, 11 AM to 10 PM every day. Street parking can be tight, so delivery or takeout is a handy backup.

3. Cranky Pat’s Pizza, Neenah, WI

Cranky Pat's Pizza, Neenah, WI
© Cranky Pat’s Pizza, Neenah, WI

Despite the name, nobody seems grumpy about the pizza. Pat Vandewalle, known as Cranky Pat, opened this Neenah spot in 1955, and his family has carried it on across generations.

The crust is super thin and baked crispy with steady consistency, then loaded with generous toppings. Some fans have been ordering it for decades, even grabbing extra pies to carry home after visits.

A budget-friendly salad bar and a soup of the day add easy sides, along with cheese curds. Live music, sports on TV, and a bar make the room busy and fun.

It also runs late on weekends, until midnight Friday and Saturday. Weekday hours are 11 AM to 10 PM, and it is closed Sunday.

4. Bill’s Pizza Shop, Stevens Point, WI

Bill's Pizza Shop, Stevens Point, WI
© Bill’s Pizza Shop, Stevens Point, WI

Main Street in downtown Stevens Point has had Bill’s since 1956, and the shop still leans into its old-school roots. It is a quiet, historic kind of place built around very thin, crispy pies.

The crust comes with a wide range of toppings and a cheesy, stringy finish. A medium gluten-free pizza is available too, which is a nice surprise at a parlor this traditional.

Beyond pizza, the Italian roast beef sandwich has a loyal following, and onion rings make a solid side. Families and college students share the space easily.

Group planners should know about the upstairs meeting area, and calling ahead is smart. Hours run 11 AM to 9 PM most weekdays, 10 PM on Friday and Saturday, and noon to 9 PM on Sunday.

5. Sammy’s Pizza & Italian Restaurant, Green Bay, WI

Sammy's Pizza & Italian Restaurant, Green Bay, WI
© Sammy’s Pizza & Italian Restaurant, Green Bay, WI

Green Bay is known for football, but its thin crust pizza deserves some attention too. Sammy’s on South Oneida Street has been part of that story since 1958.

Homemade pizza, pasta, and sauces are the point of pride here, all built on family recipes. The Italian sausage uses one of those recipes, and it pairs well with toppings like portobello mushrooms on a crispy crust cut into party squares.

If someone at your table is not in a pizza mood, the Italian beef is a strong pick, along with Pappardelle Bolognese or Chicken Fettuccine Alfredo. Bruschetta and garlic bread work well as starters.

The room is calm and casual. Curbside pickup and delivery are both options, and it opens at 11 AM daily, closing at 9 PM Monday through Saturday and 8 PM on Sunday.

6. Sammy’s Pizza Restaurant & Pub, Eau Claire, WI

Sammy's Pizza Restaurant & Pub, Eau Claire, WI
© Sammy’s Pizza Restaurant & Pub

Hungry and undecided is a great way to show up here. The Eau Claire Sammy’s offers a buffet with pizza, wings, pasta, and salad, plus a salad bar.

Sammy’s has been feeding the Chippewa Valley since 1957, moving locations over the years before settling on London Road. The pizza stays true to form, with a thin, crisp crust, savory sauce that is not sweet, and chewy cheese cut into tavern squares.

Families get plenty of help with a kids’ menu, high chairs, and birthday-friendly space. A private dining room, free Wi-Fi, and sports on TV make it easy for groups too.

Free on-site parking makes stopping simple. It is open 11 AM to 8 PM most days and until 9 PM on Friday and Saturday, with curbside pickup and delivery available.

From Racine to Eau Claire, these six parlors prove the square-cut slice still has a firm hold on Wisconsin. Save this list for your next road trip and bring a hungry friend.

Enjoyed this story?

Add Fast Food Club as a preferred source to see more of our reporting on Google.

Follow us on Google

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *