Raritan Bay does not get the boardwalk hype of the southern Jersey Shore, but its waterfront towns know their way around a fryer. From Perth Amboy to Highlands, the bayshore is lined with fish markets, family counters, and old-school dining rooms that pile shrimp, scallops, clams, and flounder onto paper plates and platters.
Some spots sit right on the water, and others hide in strip malls along Route 36. All six on this list earn their place for a different reason, whether that is a century of history, a bay view with your fries, or a market counter that sells fried fish by the pound.
Save this one for your next shore day, or send it to the friend who always asks where to eat after the beach.
1. Keyport Fishery, Keyport, NJ

Fried fish sold by the pound tells you a lot about a place. At Keyport Fishery, the counter treats seafood like a market staple, not a side note, and that is exactly why it opens this list.
The storied market sits at 150 W Front St, facing the Raritan Bay waterfront. You can shop for fresh seafood, then grab soups, sandwiches, and fried platters to go.
The seafood combination platter is the classic order. Fried shrimp and scallops come with a heap of French fries, and the Louisiana crab soup makes a smart add-on for cooler days.
Plan around a few practical details. There are no restrooms, it does not deliver, and Monday is closed.
Hours run 9 AM to 7 PM Tuesday through Thursday and Sunday, stretching to 8 PM on Friday and Saturday. Friday and Saturday afternoons get busy, so a weekday morning or Sunday morning pickup is the calmer move.
Free parking is available in the lot and on the street.
2. Sirens Seafood, Leonardo, NJ

Some of the best lunches on Route 36 come from a counter, and Sirens Seafood proves it. The family-owned joint in Leonardo keeps things simple: order up front, grab a seat, and wait for the fryer to do its job.
Fried seafood platters are the main draw. The fried scallop platter and the cod sandwich are two standouts, and a po-boy rounds out the sandwich side of the menu.
Portions are generous, and service moves fast. Expect most meals to land in the $20 to $30 range per person.
Outdoor tables make it a good fit for a sunny afternoon, and kids fit right in. There is a restroom, plenty of free parking, and takeout or delivery if you would rather eat at home.
Timing matters here. Sirens is open Wednesday through Sunday from noon to 7 PM and closed Monday and Tuesday, so it works best as a lunch or early dinner stop.
3. Navesink Fishery, Atlantic Highlands, NJ

A strip-mall storefront is not where most people expect top-tier seafood. Navesink Fishery flips that idea, pairing a working fish market with a casual dining room at 1004 NJ-36 in Atlantic Highlands.
The kitchen keeps preparation simple and lets the fish lead. You can go fried or broiled on the seafood platters, and the menu also covers steamers, chowders, crab cakes, clams on the half shell, and baked halibut.
I like this one for mixed groups where not everyone wants the fryer. The quieter, relaxed setting is good for families too, with high chairs and a kids’ menu on hand.
Reservations are accepted, which is a nice bonus for a seafood spot this size. Curbside pickup and takeout are also available, though there is no delivery.
Hours run 11 AM to 9 PM Tuesday through Saturday and 11 AM to 8 PM on Sunday. It is closed Monday, and parking is free.
4. Bahrs Landing Famous Seafood Restaurant & Marina, Highlands, NJ

Serving seafood since 1917 gives Bahrs Landing a head start on just about every restaurant on the bayshore. The nautical-themed landmark sits at 2 Bay Ave in Highlands, right where Sandy Hook Bay meets the marina.
Fried seafood fans should look for the Fried Ahoy Shrimp and the fried seafood sampler. The stuffed flounder, packed with crabmeat stuffing, is the house favorite for anyone who wants a break from the fryer.
The menu also covers both a Jersey Lobster Roll and a Hot Lobster Roll, plus yellowfin nachos and a giant pretzel. Prices run roughly $20 to $60 per person.
Outdoor and rooftop seating put the water front and center. Dogs are allowed outside, and families will find high chairs and a kids’ menu.
Saturday afternoons and evenings are the busiest stretch, so dinner reservations are a good idea. The restaurant is open daily from 11:30 AM, closing between 8 PM and 9 PM depending on the day.
5. Fish & Sips, Keansburg, NJ

Here is a fun connection for regulars of the first stop on this list. Fish & Sips in Keansburg serves food from the well-known Keyport Fishery, bringing those fried recipes right to the beachfront.
The spot sits at 307 Beachway Ave along the Keansburg beach and boardwalk area. Its look is a little more stylish than the typical boardwalk stand.
Fried seafood baskets are the focus, with fish and chips and combo baskets leading the way. It is quick, casual food, and prices range from about $10 to $40 per person.
Groups and kids both fit in easily. Dine in or take your basket to go, but skip the delivery apps.
The schedule is short, so check before you head out. Fish & Sips opens Thursday from noon to 8 PM, Friday and Saturday from noon to 10 PM, and Sunday from 9 AM to 8 PM, with free street parking nearby.
6. The Barge Restaurant and Banquet Facility, Perth Amboy, NJ

Out on the northern edge of Raritan Bay, Perth Amboy has its own waterfront seafood tradition. The Barge, at 201 Front St, sits beside the marina with outdoor seating and an upstairs room for private parties.
Fried calamari is a strong opener, and the seafood combination platters come out generous. If you want a lighter plate, the Broiled Seafood Combination and the broiled scallops are solid alternatives.
Steak lovers are covered too, thanks to Surf and Turf. Starters include Blue Point oyster cocktail and clams casino.
The setting is quiet and a bit classy without being stuffy. Most meals run about $20 to $30 per person, which is fair for a marina view.
It is open daily, starting at 11:30 AM on most days and noon on Sunday. Reservations are accepted, parking is free, and Saturday evenings draw the biggest crowds.
From Perth Amboy to Highlands, these six stops show how much the bayshore has to offer. Pick one for this weekend and save the rest for later.
Enjoyed this story?
Add Fast Food Club as a preferred source to see more of our reporting on Google.