Staten Island runs on bagels, and the borough has strong opinions about where the best ones come from. Some shops never close, some open before sunrise, and a few have built their name on a single great breakfast sandwich.
This list covers six spots across the island, from Victory Boulevard to Amboy Road, that keep the morning rush moving. Save it for your next early commute or lazy weekend breakfast.
1. Brooklyn Bagels and Cafe, Staten Island, NY

Midnight cravings have a home on Victory Boulevard. Brooklyn Bagels and Cafe stays open 24 hours a day, every day of the week, which makes it one of the most dependable stops on the island.
The signature move here is the breakfast sandwich. Crispy bacon, eggs, and melted cheese on a fresh bagel is the order that keeps the counter busy, and the portions lean generous.
It is more than a breakfast place, too. The shop also works as a deli with hearty lunch options, plus coffee for anyone who needs a boost before work.
Weekday mornings into the afternoon tend to be the busiest stretch, while late nights are usually calmer. The staff is known for being friendly and quick, so even a line moves along.
You will find it at 3579 Victory Blvd, with a free parking lot on site. Takeout and delivery are both available, and most meals land in the 10 to 20 dollar range per person.
2. Bagels N’ Buns, Staten Island, NY

Early birds get the best shot at Bagels N’ Buns, since the doors open at 6 AM and close at 2 PM daily. That short window keeps the focus squarely on breakfast and lunch.
The iced coffee has a real following here. Pair it with a classic bacon, egg, and cheese and you have the shop’s most popular combination.
Bakery items share the spotlight with the bagels, and prices stay affordable for the neighborhood.
Mornings get busy every day of the week, so plan a little extra time on weekends. A free parking lot makes the stop at 2491 Victory Blvd simple.
Since there is no restroom on site, this works best as a grab-and-go visit. In-store pickup and delivery are both options if you would rather skip the wait.
3. The Bagel Box, Staten Island, NY

Size matters at The Bagel Box. The bagels here are big, fluffy, and full-size, which tends to surprise first-timers.
Down on the South Shore at 5840 Amboy Rd, the shop is open 24 hours a day, every day. That makes it a handy stop for night-shift workers and very early commuters.
One order worth knowing is the bacon, egg, and cheese with hot honey. It adds a sweet and spicy twist to a Staten Island standard.
The store is clean and the counter service is fast and friendly. Delivery is quick as well, and prices start low, with a range of about 1 to 20 dollars per person.
Saturday mornings into the afternoon bring the biggest crowds. Evenings are typically quieter, and the free parking lot helps any time of day.
4. Bagels on the Boulevard, Staten Island, NY

Opening at 4 AM gives Bagels on the Boulevard a head start on almost everyone. The shop on Hylan Blvd runs from 4 AM to 4 PM daily.
Toppings are the big draw. The spread selection is wide, so it is easy to switch things up from visit to visit.
Garlic and everything bagels are freshly made, and the menu also includes breakfast sandwiches and wraps. There is a good selection of baked goods, chips, gum, and drinks near the counter.
I like this stop for budget mornings, since most orders fall between 1 and 10 dollars. The shop is spotless, the staff is friendly, and dine-in seating is available if you want to sit for a few minutes.
Parking options include a free lot plus street parking at 1728 Hylan Blvd. Delivery and takeout are offered too.
5. Bagel Depot, Staten Island, NY

Hand-rolled bagels and late hours set Bagel Depot apart. The Richmond Rd shop stays open until 11 PM Monday through Saturday and 9 PM on Sunday, opening at 6 AM.
That schedule makes it a rare bagel stop for dinner-time cravings. Bagels are made on-site and often come out warm.
The egg salad has a strong reputation. A large selection of muffins and deli sandwiches round out the menu.
Prices are fair, generally 10 to 20 dollars per person, and counter service moves quickly. Quality can vary on busy days, so double-check your order before leaving.
Find it at 3459 Richmond Rd with a free parking lot. There is no restroom, but delivery and in-store pickup make things easy.
6. Forest Bagels, Staten Island, NY

North Shore commuters have a reliable friend on Forest Avenue. Forest Bagels opens at 5 AM daily and stays open until 9 PM Monday through Saturday and 7 PM on Sunday.
The bagels are made on the premises, and they run large. There is a big variety to pick from, along with breakfast sandwiches and good coffee.
Budget-friendly is an understatement here, with most orders landing between 1 and 10 dollars. The owners and staff are friendly, polite, and efficient.
Keep in mind it is a takeout and pickup operation only. There is no delivery and no dine-in, so plan to eat on the go.
The shop sits at 1180 Forest Ave with a free parking lot. Weekday mornings are busiest, while evenings are usually calm.
Enjoyed this story?
Add Fast Food Club as a preferred source to see more of our reporting on Google.